Two demonstrators arrested amid pro-Palestinian protests at the University of Pittsburgh earlier this summer will stand trial on aggravated assault and other charges, a judge ruled Monday after an hourslong and occasionally contentious preliminary hearing.

But Judge Xander Orenstein also dismissed some of the aggravated assault charges against Muhammed Ali and Cole Florkewicz, apparently based on the severity of the injuries sustained by the Pitt police officers who confronted the men during the June 3 protests.

Mr. Ali, 21, remains charged with two counts of obstruction of justice and one count of aggravated assault, riot, disorderly conduct, failure to disperse and conspiracy. The judge dismissed two counts of aggravated assault.

Mr. Florkewicz, 24, is charged with aggravated assault, disorderly conduct, obstruction of justice, riot, failure to disperse and conspiracy. Assistant District Attorney James Sheets withdrew one count of aggravated assault, and Judge Orenstein dismissed another.

Advertise with us

The judge offered to recuse from the hearings that went forward Monday, noting that family members live in Israel, some of whom are part of the Israel Defense Forces.

“I do not believe this would affect my judgment,” Judge Orenstein said.

Three other protesters who were set for preliminary hearings Monday afternoon either postponed or waived their hearings.

The charges stemmed from a second pro-Palestine encampment that formed on Pitt’s campus June 1. Dozens of protesters spent several days camped in Schenley Plaza in late April before deciding on their own to dismantle the camp.

Demands of that protest focused on forcing Pitt and nearby Carnegie Mellon to disclose and divest their connections and interests in Israel and condemned Israel’s actions in the ongoing war. Those demands evolved throughout the summer as demonstrators began to call on Pitt to terminate its chapter of Hillel and its Student Coalition of Israel.

Advertise with us

Confrontations between police and demonstrators escalated June 2 into June 3 as the latter swarmed the Cathedral of Learning and allegedly tried to wrestle barricades from campus police. Authorities allege some threw water bottles at officers, and at least one smoke bomb went off.

More than two dozen supporters waited for hours in the courtroom first for the hearing to start and then for it play out.

Five Pitt police officers testified: Officer Justin Reck, Detective Edward Wolff, Lt. Brooke Riley, Sgt. Benjamin Salvio, and Officer Keith Krauss.

The bulk of the testimony came from Lt. Riley, who testified that she had just taken a water break when a group of 20 to 30 protesters breached the metal barriers put up on the Cathedral of Learning lawn to keep others from joining the encampment.

She said she ran to the lawn and was hit with a can she alleged Mr. Florkewicz threw at her. She said she couldn’t recall the kind of can or whether it was full or empty. As she picked up one of the sections of metal fence, she said, Mr. Florkewicz and Mr. Ali both grabbed onto the same piece and started pushing and pulling it. Lt. Riley said the encounter left her leg bruised, and she pulled a hamstring and two fingers went numb for a time.

Advertise with us

Other officers said they were injured when they were hit with water bottles, and two fell as they tried to hold the line as protesters pushed through the barricades.

A back and forth between Mr. Sheets and Mr. Ali’s attorney, Aaron Sontz, prompted the judge to ask Mr. Sheets to “please take it down.” The judge also had to remind witnesses multiple times to answer questions directly.

Formal arraignment for both men is scheduled for Oct. 11.