University of Pittsburgh Chancellor Joan Gabel didn’t mince words when addressing the pro-Palestine encampment outside of the Cathedral of Learning.

In a 500-word address that Ms. Gabel started by saying she had “unsettling news,” the chancellor detailed the university’s response to a disruptive, sometimes violent protest that began Sunday evening and ended early Tuesday morning.

“What we saw [Sunday] night, and continue to see, are attempts to destroy property at the historical core of our campus, as well as accompanying action that in no way elevates open inquiry or allows for peaceful advocacy,” part of Ms. Gabel’s letter reads.

Her firm response that acknowledges both First Amendment protections and campus safety concerns was likely welcomed by Pitt leaders who have spent weeks watching leaders at other higher education institutions receive pushback for their responses to similar protests.

Advertise with us

And it comes as the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, a Philadelphia-based nonprofit that aims to protect free speech on college campuses and throughout the U.S., has recommended numerous “common-sense reforms” for school leaders dealing with demonstrations and unrest on their campuses.

Suggested reforms include protecting free speech, adopting institutional neutrality, and prohibiting disruptive and violent conduct.

“The best place to start is ensuring speech, protest and academic freedom policies align with the First Amendment, and then apply those policies fairly in every controversy, big and small,” Alex Morey, FIRE’s vice president for campus advocacy, said in an email.

“There's been growing pressure for years on colleges to censor controversial speech, or take sides on social and political issues. When universities do this, they demonstrate they're willing to cave when the pressure is high enough. And that incentivizes more calls for censorship.”

Those recommendations aim to prepare campuses for the fall semester after a chaotic end to the 2023-24 school year that saw student arrests, canceled commencement ceremonies and leader resignations at universities across the country.

Advertise with us

At Pitt, for 30 hours this week, the area outside of the cathedral was spun into a tumultuous protest that mirrored those that have occurred elsewhere.

Sunday night, dozens of pro-Palestine protesters set up camp outside of the cathedral, erecting tents and fences as they demanded that Pitt disclose and divest any investments connected to Israel.

As more protesters and Pitt Police flooded to the area, the demonstration quickly turned violent and disruptive, with one person arrested, the Cathedral of Learning defaced, antisemitic vandalism found on the Frick Fine Arts Building and numerous clashes between police and protesters over a two-day span. Three officers sustained minor injuries.

The protest finally cooled down and peacefully ended early Tuesday morning, as city and county officials negotiated with demonstrators.

Ms. Gabel’s letter and subsequent university communications were careful to distance Pitt from the protest.

Advertise with us

In her letter, Ms. Gabel said many of the protesters, including their leaders, were not affiliated with Pitt, although protesters have countered this claim. The chancellor also clarified that Pitt Divest from Apartheid, a student group that helped organize the demonstration, is not a registered student group and is not recognized by the university.

Large portions of protesters at schools such as NYU and Arizona State have also been unaffiliated with the campuses they demonstrated at.

Ms. Gabel attributed antisemitic vandalism and property damage to the protesters. And, while aiming to strike a balance between free expression and campus safety, she distinguished this protest from an April one near campus that remained mostly peaceful.

“The University of Pittsburgh is grounded in the spirit of discourse and dialogue, while ensuring all voices can be expressed in a safe way. However, we have no illusions that the efforts of this group [Sunday] night are directed toward free expression,” Ms. Gabel wrote. “They are markedly different from the largely peaceful protest in Schenley Plaza in April.”

That statement echoes pro-free speech, anti-disruption themes in responses by leaders such as Ohio State President Ted Carter and Yale President Peter Salovey.

Advertise with us

Pitt leaders likely viewed Ms. Gabel’s response to this incident as critical. Campuses have been thrust into unrest throughout the Israel-Hamas War, with some leaders finding themselves in hot water for their responses to the pro-Palestine protests. Critics have charged that vague or watered-down statements endanger Jewish students, threaten campus safety and demonstrate hypocrisy on campus free speech policies.

At the extreme end, backlash prompted the winter resignations of University of Pennsylvania President Liz Magill and Harvard President Claudine Gay.

Other presidents grilled for their handling of protests included those at UCLA, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Rutgers University and Northwestern University. Each of those leaders testified to the House Committee on Education and the Workforce about antisemitism on their campuses.

House representatives leveled criticisms against both Northwestern President Michael Schill and Rutgers President Jonathan Holloway for offering amnesty deals with protesters, discussing their investments and supporting scholarships for Palestinian students.

Academic leaders also attempted to dialogue with protesters at Columbia University, where President Minouche Shafik released a strong, detailed statement outlining the university’s policies and position.

Advertise with us

Despite that statement and dialogue efforts, the Ivy League school still saw a weeks-long protest that culminated in a canceled commencement ceremony and NYPD involvement. Encampments continue to pop up at the Manhattan university.

Ms. Gabel never interacted with protesters face-to-face throughout the Pitt demonstration. Pitt officials didn’t negotiate with protesters, either. Only city and county leaders were part of those talks.

As Pitt moves forward, school leaders remain committed to providing a “safe learning environment for all,” spokesman Jared Stonesifer said.

“We will continue to take the necessary steps to protect our campus community and ensure the thorough investigation of any alleged incidents of wrongdoing, misconduct, or policy violations,” Mr. Stonesifer said in an email.

Ms. Morey, from FIRE, said while schools prepare for the fall semester, they should focus on their core missions and purposes.

“Schools should return to first principles at the heart of what makes a university a university, including free expression and academic freedom,” she said. “Then they need to stand firmly by those principles in controversies big and small, no matter whether the pressure to censor is coming from powerful legislators or a handful of students.”