After two days of unrest and clashes with police, it took an hourslong conversation between local officials and pro-Palestinian protest leaders to facilitate the peaceful removal of an encampment on the University of Pittsburgh campus on Tuesday.
Mayor Ed Gainey said officials worked to de-escalate the situation after eruptions of violence at the encampment, which was erected outside the Cathedral of Learning on Sunday. After nearly three hours of negotiations, the protesters peacefully left campus around 2 a.m.
At a Tuesday afternoon news conference, Mr. Gainey didn’t provide much detail on the substance of those conversations, but maintained that the negotiations were focused solely on keeping everyone involved safe.
He said those involved were not endorsing or meeting the demands of protesters, who want the university to "terminate" two on-campus Jewish and Israeli student groups — the Student Coalition for Israel and Pitt's chapter of Hillel, the Foundation for Jewish Campus Life.
They have also demanded that Pitt "demilitarize" campus police by removing armed officers and severing ties with the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police. While they reiterated those demands, Mr. Gainey said they didn’t dwell on them.
"I don't have any influence over international relations," Mr. Gainey said "Our number one priority was finding ways to work towards a safe resolution to a situation that had become unstable."
Read More
He would not elaborate on what specific tactics were used but said they provided protesters with "options, an assessment on what was likely to happen" if the encampment was not cleared.
But he faltered on what those options were. “The option that was considered was for them to be safe, and we had a conversation about how we can de-escalate,” he said. “That’s the option we talked about, public safety.”
He said he did not use law enforcement as a bargaining chip. protesters asked him if there might be more arrests, and he said it was a possibility.
"We couldn't predict what would happen," he said. "Our job was to keep everybody safe."
One person was arrested Sunday as protesters clashed with police, and Pitt Chancellor Joan Gabel said the group was attempting "to destroy property at the historical core of our campus."
Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt said the city called in additional county and state officers as a precaution on Monday afternoon.
"If it escalates significantly, you can go to the point of less lethal or tear gas," he said. "But our ultimate goal for public safety is always that de-escalation happens through conversation, not physical action."
There have also been conflicting reports on who was present for the conversations about dismantling the camp.
Earlier Tuesday, Maria Montano, Mr. Gainey's communications director, released a statement saying that officials met with Pitt students and Pitt faculty.
But in an email to the Post-Gazette, Pitt spokesperson Jared Stonesifer said the negotiations were held with protesters who were "largely unaffiliated with the University."
Ms. Montano later clarified that the protesters "self-identified" as students.
Allegheny County Chief Executive Sara Innamorato said they spoke with people from Jewish and Palestinian communities, including a Palestinian student who said they have family and friends in Gaza and had experienced anti-Arab harassment in Pittsburgh.
"We heard their stories and their pain," she said.
Though the requests made by the protesters are predominantly aimed at the leadership of Pitt, she said she encouraged all those involved to address their concerns.
"We will continue to balance and keep everyone's First Amendment rights intact while standing resolute against antisemitism, Islamophobia, racism, and hate in all its forms," she said.
The demonstration began Sunday evening, with between 150 and 200 protesters at its peak, many of whom camped out overnight Sunday into Monday. A fence was erected on Sunday night using power tools, pieces of wood and chain links. Protesters also set up tents and formed a human chain on the cathedral grounds.
By Sunday night, several protesters had defaced the cathedral and placed materials in one of the building's doorways, seemingly with the intent to ignite the materials, Ms. Gabel said.
The Frick Fine Arts Building was also defaced with antisemitic graffiti, Ms. Gabel wrote in a statement to the university community, and a weapon was thrown through one of its windows.
Clashes between protesters and police continued throughout the day Monday, with protesters rushing the cathedral. A pink smoke bomb firework went off and protesters threw water bottles and attempted to wrestle the barricades away from police. Police threw some of the protesters to the ground and medics and additional police units were called to the scene.
By 8 p.m. Monday, things had calmed down somewhat, but protesters with makeshift riot shields constructed out of halved plastic garbage cans stayed in place behind the barrier in front of the cathedral, while other demonstrators warned people to leave if they started to feel unsafe.
Maddie Aiken contributed to this report






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.