Jordan Geiger made a final call after he crashed into a wooded area on Ben Avon Heights Road late in the afternoon on Aug. 2.
The 18-year-old had made it less than a half-mile from the Giant Eagle parking lot where, police said, he was shot during a gun sale gone wrong. He crashed his Chevy Cobalt a few hundred yards from the shopping plaza near Gass Road.
“I’m dying,” Geiger told an unnamed witness, who recounted the conversation to Allegheny County police detectives three days later. “I’m in the woods. Stained me. Got shot in my arm.”
“Stained,” the witness said, was slang for being robbed.
Back on Ben Avon Heights Road, Geiger stumbled from his car toward the road. Passersby, seeing the crash, stopped to help. Someone gave the teen CPR until medics arrived. Only after he was pronounced dead about an hour later did Allegheny General Hospital doctors find the gunshot wound under Geiger’s right armpit.
The nine-page criminal complaint against Emmanuel Houghton, 19, and 22-year-old Tyler Stewart detailed the setup of the gun sale that ultimately killed Geiger and the multi-county crime spree by Houghton and Stewart in the two weeks that followed.
Read More
The witness had been with Geiger just prior to the shooting when Geiger drove them to a party at Geiger’s grandfather’s house, the witness told detectives. While in the car, Geiger received a phone call on Snapchat from someone with the name Mr. Grim Reaper.
The witness, according to the complaint, knew that was the username of Houghton, who the witness had known for about a month. The witness knew Geiger had set up a gun sale but didn’t know with whom until Houghton’s call.
The witness said Geiger left the party in Ross to sell the handgun at the Giant Eagle near Camp Horne Road, according to the complaint. A short time later is when the witness received the phone call from Geiger. The witness and other friends took an Uber to Allegheny General Hospital, where they spoke with Highmark police officers. The officers at that point, however, were still unaware that Geiger had been shot.
The witness called Houghton and accused him of shooting Geiger, according to the complaint. Houghton first said he had sent a friend to the sale on his behalf but later noted he had heard Geiger moan, indicating that he had, in fact, been there.
Geiger’s Snapchat history captured his exchange with Houghton leading up to the shooting. Houghton urged him more than once to have the gun unloaded and in a bag.
A day after the shooting, detectives used license plate readers and security cameras to identify the two vehicles that they ultimately linked to Houghton and Stewart, both of which had previously been reported stolen. One was found abandoned with a flat tire not far from the shooting scene, and the other was spotted the same day in the parking lot at South Hills Village Mall.
When Upper St. Clair police tried to stop the vehicle, the driver, later identified as Houghton, took off. Police lost sight of the car, a white Chevy Traverse, and called off the pursuit, according to the complaint.
Later that night, Pittsburgh police found the Traverse on fire in the city’s Elliott neighborhood.
Stewart and Houghton would later tell police they had known each other for years, and both described themselves as being like brothers. They attended Carlynton High School in Carnegie at the same time, and they had both been detained at Shuman Juvenile Detention Center years earlier.
Houghton was ultimately taken into custody nearly two weeks later after an hourslong standoff in Monongahela in Washington County.
That incident began when Pennsylvania State police tried to stop a car that had been reported stolen overnight. Police said the driver, later identified as Houghton, took off, firing at police as he did. He eventually barricaded himself in a home near Third and Chess streets.
SWAT officers surrounded the home and cleared the scene about 2 p.m., according to Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV. They later realized Houghton was still in the home, and another standoff ensued. The TV station reported that Houghton went on Facebook Live about 6 p.m., and he was threatening to shoot officers and himself.
He asked to speak to his mother, who came and started talking to him via loudspeaker, KDKA reported. She begged him to come out. He surrendered about 7:30 p.m. Once in custody, Houghton was questioned by Allegheny County police regarding Geiger’s homicide.
Houghton said he had agreed to trade a gun with “J Bone” — Geiger’s nickname among friends and family members. He acknowledged he had a video call via Snapchat just before they were set to meet. He said Geiger looked “like an innocent, sweet kid,” noting that he had just graduated from high school.
When Geiger pulled next to Houghton and Stewart in the parking lot, Geiger “threw” the gun into their car, according to the complaint. Houghton pulled his own gun and told Geiger to chill. From the backseat, Houghton said, Stewart yelled for Geiger to “get the [expletive] off of him.”
Houghton told investigators he heard gunshot from the backseat. He said he heard Geiger moan and told him to get up. He said Geiger laughed, got in his car, and drove away.
Stewart was arrested later that night in Allegheny County after a sheriff’s deputy spotted a Jeep Cherokee driving erratically on Bausman Street in Pittsburgh’s Beltzhoover neighborhood, according to the complaint. The driver, later identified as Stewart, took off toward Route 51 and ultimately crashed on Banksville Road near McMonagle Avenue.
Stewart abandoned the crashed Jeep and ran toward Banksville Plaza, where he tried to carjack a man. Passersby tackled Stewart, and police took him into custody. He was wearing body armor and had multiple guns in the Jeep, which had been stolen from Carnegie.
Stewart, too, admitted to being part of the Aug. 2 gun sale. He said he followed Houghton to the shopping plaza in a stolen Honda but got into Houghton’s car, the stolen Chevy Traverse, once they parked. Geiger, he said, was supposed to get into the car with them but instead handed the gun to Houghton through the driver’s-side window. A struggle ensued, Stewart told police, and he told Geiger to “let him the [expletive] go.”
He said he heard a gunshot, and Houghton drove out of the parking lot, according to the complaint. He said the interaction lasted only a few minutes.
Both men face a slew of charges stemming from multiple incidents in recent weeks. In connection with the Aug. 2 shooting, Houghton and Stewart are both charged with homicide, robbery, conspiracy and weapons charges.
In connection with the Monongahela standoff, Houghton is charged with attempted homicide, attempted aggravated assault, fleeing police, receiving stolen property and firearms violations.
In the pursuit with police and sheriff’s deputies, Stewart is charged with attempted robbery, evading arrest, fleeing police, reckless endangerment, and a slew of gun charges.
Preliminary hearings for the homicide cases have not been scheduled, according to court records, and neither man is listed as having a defense attorney.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.