For neighbors on the far end of Garfield’s Broad Street, it’s hard to move on when nothing has changed.

They’d like to forget being ushered from their houses a year ago by police in bulletproof vests and SWAT gear, but it’s hard when the house next door is still riddled with bullet holes.

And they’d like to forget the fear of what they might find when they finally returned to their homes after hours of gunfire. That’s hard, too, when one home’s boarded up windows and doors stand in stark contrast to the neatly kept lawns on either side.

Neighbors around the battered home would like to forget the carnage of Aug. 23 — a massive shootout that shattered the peace in their quiet corner of the Garfield neighborhood and killed a troubled man hell bent on keeping the home he thought should belong to him. For them, the problems drag on.

Advertise with us

“Nothing’s been done,” said Jackie Lane, who lives in one of those homes with a neatly kept lawn. “Could it be repaired? Just fix a few windows there and paint a little bit.”

The property’s decay started long before last August, when 63-year-old William Hardison Jr. took aim at sheriff’s deputies who came to lock him out of 4817 Broad St., and it has created more than just an eyesore. Mice and other vermin drawn to the dilapidation have found their way into Ms. Lane’s home. She doesn’t want to think about the shooting anymore, but neighbors have been forced to deal with the fallout.

She recently took on the task of cutting the grass at 4817 herself. She’s called the city’s 311 line to report the issues. The department told her nothing can be done until the legal process plays out.

“I’m calling back today — I’m gonna call back every day,” she told the Post-Gazette last week. “Something has to be done.”

“Nothing’s been done," Garfield resident Jackie Lane said of the home next door at 4817 Broad St. In the year since a six-hour standoff killed 63-year-old William Hardison Jr., who'd been squatting in the home for months. "Could it be repaired? Just fix a few windows there and paint a little bit.” (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Two doors down from 4817 Broad St., Cheryl Patterson is just starting to feel comfortable sitting on her porch again. During the shooting, SWAT teams ushered her out her front door as gunfire rang out — shots intended to distract Hardison, officers told her.

Advertise with us

She had hidden in her walk-in closet, under her bed — wherever she could, as gunfire seemed to come from all directions.

“I tell you that it wasn't easy,” she said. “A lot of people were still afraid, and then it took me a while before I could actually come out and sit out here. It wasn't easy for the neighbors.”

She can still point to two bullet holes in the overhang on the front of her house. She never filed a claim with the city, she said, because the damage seemed negligible.

In the weeks after the shooting, police came by to ask questions. Trauma therapists offered resources. Ms. Patterson said she didn't bring up the incident in conversation much because neighbors were still on the edge. They still are, she said.

Today, she feels safe in her home and neighborhood, but she knows that others don’t —particularly those who had to shelter inside their own homes during the hours-long gunfight. “We still drive by and look at it, you're thinking, God, it's been a year,” she said.

Advertise with us

‘A total loss’

The lack of movement is not for lack of trying, according to a representative from 907 East Street, the LLC that bought the property in early February 2023 — months before the standoff.

He said the delays have been caused by an uncommunicative mortgage holder. “We’ve said, ‘Hey, this property is a total loss, use the insurance that’s in place to satisfy this debt because this is a loss for us,’” he said. “And they’re not responding.”

The company representative asked not to be identified so as to speak about the legal process and for fear of another round of backlash he said was driven by misinformation in the aftermath of the shooting.

The intent is for the property to go back to the Garfield community, the representative said: Once the red tape is cleared, 907 East Street plans to donate the property to the Bloomfield Garfield Corp. to ultimately turn into affordable housing.

“I wish I could snap my fingers and be done with it,” he said.

Advertise with us

It’s not lost on the neighborhood that a man died in the home. Hardison believed the house belonged to him, but the courts and the deed to the property said otherwise. When his brother, who bought the property in 1998, died in 2021 without a will, the house fell into disrepair.

The two-story row house on Garfield's Broad Street remains an eyesore and perpetual reminder of the six-hour standoff that rocked the small corner of the neighborhood and killed 63-year-old William Hardison Jr. in August 2023. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The apparently abandoned home caught the eye of a 907 East Street employee. When a homeowner dies without a will, the property goes to a parent or, when there are no living or locatable parents, a sibling. In this case, it legally belonged to Hardison’s father in Detroit, who agreed to sell to 907 East Street for $25,000.

The sale was finalized Feb. 2, 2023.

About two months later, according to the 907 East Street representative, the company sent an insurance agent out. When the agent tried to get inside to take a photo of the electrical box, a man chased him off the property.

Neighbors informed the new owners that Hardison had taken up squatting inside the home. The company representative stressed that this was not a livable property — it had no heat, no water, he said, the roof leaked and drywall was peeling. Hardison had affixed handmade “no trespassing” signs to the front door along with a number of foreboding scribbles: “Not for sale” and “see U in federal court.”

Advertise with us

The representative said neighbors were afraid of Hardison, and 907 East Street representatives tried in vain to reach him. “We attempted for several months after that to get in touch with him to figure out what it was that he wanted or if we could come to some sort of deal,” he said. “He wouldn’t respond.”

The company began the ejectment process, which differs from an eviction mostly in that it applies to squatters as opposed to tenants. He said Hardison did not attend hearings on the matter.

About two weeks before the ejectment was supposed to be served, neighbors reported  Hardison seemed to be stockpiling gasoline. That drew concern, which is why there was a larger-than-normal law enforcement presence on scene to serve the ejectment notice.

Deputies knocked on the door for about a half hour before resorting to forcing open the front door. When it finally swung open around 11 a.m., Hardison opened fire, sending the deputies scrambling for cover. One dove from the porch, and another took cover behind a car.

The police response that followed was massive. Likely thousands of rounds were fired over the ensuing six hours. Hardison was found dead inside the home about 5 p.m.

Advertise with us

Dozens of officers from numerous departments were part of the gun battle. The day after the shooting, 47 Pittsburgh police officers — including most of the city SWAT team — were on administrative leave, along with 16 sheriff’s deputies and 12 Allegheny County Police officers. Protocol in those departments dictates that officers who fire their weapons in the line of duty undergo an evaluation before returning to service.

Because local agencies were involved, Pennsylvania State Police took over the investigation. A spokesman for the local troop declined to answer a list of questions posed by the Post-Gazette for this story, saying the investigation “is still listed as ongoing with different partners.”

Standing as a reminder

Ms. Patterson, the neighbor two doors down, said that while she doesn’t understand how it came to a fatal standoff, she wasn’t surprised there was trouble. She and other neighbors had called 911 numerous times. She said in the time leading up to the standoff, neighbors noticed Hardison bringing guns and gasoline into the house.

“He was troubled,” Ms. Patterson said. “He said, ‘I ain't going nowhere.’ He had all kinds of signs on the porch for the police. He said that he wasn't coming out there alive, and he didn't.”

Cheryl Patterson lives two doors down from the house at 4817 Broad St. in Pittsburgh's Garfield neighborhood. It's been a year since 63-year-old William Hardison Jr. opened fire on sheriff's deputies serving an ejectment order on him after months of squatting in his late brother's row house. The Aug. 23, 2023, shootout killed Hardison and damaged homes all around his. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Authorities have said Hardison believed himself a Moorish sovereign citizen. Those who believe themselves “Moors” subscribe to a theory that purports a centuries-old treaty with an African nation puts Black people in America outside the reach of U.S. law.

Advertise with us

The movement first emerged in the 1990s, and it is based on a treaty with Morocco signed in the late 1700s — a treaty that those in the Moorish sovereign-citizen movement believe grants them a special status above the law.

In a widely publicized online video from 2019, Hardison can be seen arguing with Pittsburgh police officers who had formed a loose circle around his white pickup truck. “I’m a Moor! I’ve got every right to travel from here to Timbuktu,” he is heard shouting at the officers.

The video shows him draping a Moroccan flag over the sill of his open driver’s side window, telling onlookers that police “know what this is.”

Friends and family members, in the aftermath of the standoff, said Hardison was a kind man suffering mental health issues. They said he had a big heart, stood his ground, and saved files on everything.

“He believed what he believed in, and he [stood] on it 100%,” Hardison’s niece, Diamond Brown, said a day later. “He was a loving person.”

Advertise with us

Some family members believe Hardison should have been allowed to stay in the house on Broad Street. “He was a veteran,” Rayshawn Brown, Hardison’s nephew, said a few days after his death. “[The police] should have never done that.”

Another of Hardison’s nieces agreed. “A man getting evicted ended up losing his life,” Nakeya Tompkins said. “That’s a problem.”

‘We could have reached out’

That’s one of the more difficult pieces of it all for Rick Swartz, who has served as executive director of the Bloomfield Garfield Corp. since 1986. He pointed to myriad neighborhood and social service organizations that could have tried to help Hardison.

But the key is making that call. Mr. Swartz said no one in a position to help Hardison knew who he was before Aug. 23 — no one made a call to say their friend or family member was squatting in an uninhabitable house with no utilities, that they were afraid something bad might happen to him.

“We could have reached out to him and tried to figure out where you can go that would at least provide you with safe and secure housing,” he said. “We would not have let him be put out on the street.”

Advertise with us

His voice holds a tinge of animosity for the man who threw the neighborhood into the spotlight for all the wrong reasons — whose gunfire, he said, was indiscriminate and “conveyed to those neighbors that he really didn’t care what kind of loss of life occurred that day.”

“There were other, better choices that he could have made to help himself out of that situation,” he continued, “but he didn’t make those choices. Instead, he went with the direct confrontation with law enforcement that he thought was going to somehow win the day, and it didn’t.”

At the same time, he said, he understands that Hardison believed the house should be his.

“I think he felt entitled to be there,” he said. “I think from an emotional standpoint, that’s understandable. From a legal standpoint, it wasn’t.”

Pittsburgh police, using a rook, work their way along Broad Street as they and other law personnel respond to an active shooter situation in Garfield on Wednesday, August 23, 2023. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The effects have lingered in the neighborhood, he said. There was the terror that was the day in question, and there have a host of problems that came alongside the continued decay of the property: the mice, the sewage backups, the dampness and mold.

Advertise with us

And then there’s how it ended.

“That by itself really rattled people,” he said, “not because they thought law enforcement acted imprudently, but because [Hardison] had taken this standoff all the way to the limit. He at no time just wanted to surrender to the authorities and hold onto his life.

“I think that shocked people as much as anything,” he said.

Mr. Swartz said the neighborhood has worked to move on. There have been stumbling blocks, like the lag in paying back homeowners for the damage to their property. There’s also the looming reminder on Broad Street.

“The house is standing as a reminder to those neighbors of what happened on that day,” he said.

Advertise with us

‘It was so traumatic’

The shootout left behind damage not just at house at the center of it, but at surrounding homes, too. For Ms. Lane, that meant broken windows, a damaged water pipe, bullet holes in the living room, dining room walls, the gutters, gazebo and on the roof.

Some of the damage was caused by gunfire. Other things, like her fence, were destroyed by SWAT vehicles trying to get closer to the property.

All told, the damage to Ms. Lane’s property racked up costs of around $55,000. The city ultimately paid her $7,000 deductible, she said, but it took months to see that money. The neighborhood association pitched in $3,000 to replace her fence.

Ms. Lane and Ms. Patterson stayed in their Garfield homes after the shooting, and Ms. Patterson said it would have been too difficult to leave a place she’s called home for 44 years. She still thinks it’s a great neighborhood for families and retirees alike.

Others left quickly in the aftermath, said nearby neighbor Sandra Gibson, who lives off of North Mathilda Street. She said the family across the street moved out soon afterward.

Advertise with us

“It's a brand new house,” she said. “They haven't even been in there a year, and they just let it go, because it was so traumatic.”

What didn’t help, she said, was how long it took to clean up around the nearby properties. Ms. Gibson and other residents had to call the city repeatedly.

“The trash that they left all over, shell casings, empty water bottles, it was just a mess,” she said.

She called the standoff a draining situation that lasted long after the gunfire had stopped, part of which had to do with the damage caused by police who trampled through backyards and used homes to shield themselves from gunfire.

“The lady across the street, she still talks about it to this day, because it had such an impact on her,” Ms. Gibson said.

“She was here, and they tried to take over her house. It's like the police didn't really care about the other people's properties. You know, they just want to get that one person and that one person only, not knowing that you are hurting other victims. You're making them a victim.”