For nearly half an hour Wednesday morning, sheriff’s deputies knocked on the door of a Broad Street home to no avail — there was no answer, no communication, no indication that anyone was inside, Allegheny County Sheriff Kevin Kraus said.
Seven deputies were there to evict 63-year-old William Hardison Jr., the man who’d been living in the home. As minutes ticked by and they received no answer, the team breached the door to go inside.
“As soon as that happened, he opened fire,” Sheriff Kraus said Thursday, less than 24 hours after the standoff in the city’s Garfield neighborhood drew to a deadly conclusion.
The shooting started around 11 a.m. and sent the deputies — armed only with their law enforcement-issued handguns — scrambling for cover. One deputy suffered a minor injury as he dove out of the line of fire.
The shooting continued off and on for another six hours. At the end of it, police and Hardison had exchanged thousands of rounds of gunfire, and Hardison was ultimately found dead inside the home around 5 p.m.
Forty-seven Pittsburgh police officers — including a majority of the city SWAT team, along with 16 sheriff’s deputies and 12 Allegheny County Police officers -—were on administrative leave Thursday. Protocol in both departments dictates that officers who fire their weapon in the line of duty undergo an evaluation before returning to service.
Read More
The Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office officially identified Hardison Thursday afternoon, indicating he was “suspected of being shot by law enforcement.”
Sheriff Kraus said authorities gave Hardison every opportunity to end things peacefully.
“It’s unfortunate that a life was lost,” he said. “He made the decision and it was clear he made a calculated decision he was going to go all the way.”
Deputies had been to the home before, Sheriff Kraus said. Court records show deputies made one previous attempt to get Hardison off of the property. Deputies tried to serve an ejectment order May 10 on behalf of 907 East Street, a limited liability corporation that bought the home earlier this year.
Court paperwork shows that the deputies noted the “adult on scene refused to accept service” of the ejectment.
That was really a moot point, the sheriff said, noting tenants can’t refuse service of such a notice under state law.
Nothing in that encounter — and nothing that they found in Hardison’s background — led deputies to believe they’d be met with violence Wednesday morning.
“We knew about his past interaction with police, his beliefs and ideals,” Sheriff Kraus said. “Certainly we didn’t expect that kind of response when we got to the house.”
Officials have indicated Hardison might have held sovereign citizen or Moorish sovereign beliefs. The former is a belief that the government has little, if any, authority over individuals. Moorish sovereigns, according to the Southern Poverty Law Center, are an offshoot of the sovereign citizen movement.
A video uploaded to YouTube on April 28, 2019, appears to show Hardison involved in a tense verbal confrontation with police during a traffic stop. Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto acknowledged that video in a media briefing Thursday afternoon.
“Some of those behaviors we meet with sovereign citizens, but it doesn’t suggest for a moment that [the standoff] would have been the outcome — that they would meet us with firearms and violence,” Chief Scirotto said when asked about the video.
The chief said a check of police records showed Pittsburgh officers responded to the Broad Street home in March for a report that Hardison’s brother’s firearm had been stolen. He said that was the only time on record that Pittsburgh police were called to the home.
In that same briefing, Mayor Ed Gainey denied rumors and speculation that he knew Hardison or had previously met with him.
“I do know members of his family. A lot of his family members I grew up with, so I do know members of the family,” Mayor Gainey said. “I do not know him.”
Michael Pennix, a longtime friend of Hardison, said in the aftermath of the shooting that Hardison’s sovereign citizen beliefs had previously led to run-ins with police and a meeting with the mayor.
A woman who identified herself as Hardison’s niece, Latia Davison, said in a social media video posted about 3:30 p.m. Wednesday that her brother had gone to the mayor’s home to speak to him.
“This man been at your house,” Ms. Davison said in the Facebook Live video, speaking directly to Mayor Gainey. “You have even called this man and said, ‘I’ll be home in five minutes and we can talk about the paperwork.’”
It was not clear what paperwork she was referring to or when the incident took place.
Mayor Gainey said Hardison had never been to his house.
The failed attempt to eject Hardison from the property in early May led to attorneys for the LLC requesting a writ of possession be served. Once that has been issued to a tenant facing eviction, authorities have 48 hours to serve the tenant with that paperwork. From there, tenants have 10 days to move out before they’re forcefully evicted.
Records show Hardison did not respond to any of the court filings. Attorneys for 907 East Street on Aug. 7 asked the judge in the case for permission to “lock in” Hardison’s personal property — that is, lock him out of the home and lock his belongings inside. Common Pleas Judge Mary C. McGinley granted that motion Aug. 18.
That order by Judge McGinley set eviction for 10:30 a.m. Aug. 23.
After that, Hardison would be given 30 days to make arrangements to get his personal property. The new owners would then have the right to dispose of it.
Property records show 907 East Street bought the property on Broad Street for $25,000 on Feb. 2. The previous owner was Joseph Hardison, who bought the property in 1998.
Allegheny County property records as of January 2023 show that the company owns at least four other properties.
Meanwhile, the Broad Street property on Thursday was boarded up with a hand-painted “no trespassing” sign. A second-floor window was blown out, a large hole in the middle of it.

Pattie Means has lived in the area for four decades. She spent late Thursday afternoon picking up bricks scattered by armored SWAT vehicles that tore through her fence, which lay in two tangled pieces.
The neighborhood was relatively quiet, a far cry from the chaos and seemingly unending gunfire of the day prior.
Ms. Means was at home and still in her slippers when deputies initially banged on the door of 4817 Broad St., just two houses down from her. She said she went to the porch but was told to go back inside by the deputies.
She said she did as she was told.
“They probably banged on the door for maybe 15 to 20 minutes,” she said. “And the last time, I heard gunshots.”
She said she dropped to the ground. She was on the phone with her son, who told her to go to the basement and stay there. She hid there for three hours. Each time she thought it was over, there would be another volley of gunfire, some of it so loud it shook her house.
Ms. Means said she heard yelling at her window. It was a SWAT officer telling her to climb out. She tried, but the window was just a foot wide. Officers eventually escorted her out the front door.
She hunkered down with family in Stanton Heights and returned home later in the evening. As she trudged to her home, still in slippers and pajamas, an officer let her past.
“I think he just felt sorry for me,” she said.
There were hundreds of shell casings scattered along the street. The officer warned her not to step on them.

Mayor Gainey said social workers, the city’s trauma team and the neighborhood services team were out in the Garfield neighborhood offering support. He said they were also passing out claims forms to anyone whose property was damaged during the hours-long incident.
Ms. Means said numerous people came to her door Thursday offering counseling, pamphlets and claims forms. She said the city and her insurance will cover the damage to her yard and fence.
She said she didn’t feel unsafe coming back to her home, but she’s been grappling with the aftermath.
It was a sentiment shared by others in the small corner of the neighborhood.
Courtney Balestier likened it to a lightning storm.
“It was like this really intense, scary thing, and then it passed,” she said. “Then it’s like, well, the weather kind of got back to normal in a way. You never want to think about something so tragic in those terms, but that’s kind of what it’s like. It’s not what it’s normally like here.”
As she sat on her couch late Thursday afternoon, her dog Jasper snoozing next to her with his stuffed llama, she said she felt lucky nonetheless.
Bullet holes in her green Subaru were the only damage her property sustained. She’d criss-crossed pieces of duct tape over the holes until they’re repaired.
When the shooting started, she instinctively dropped to the ground, then took Jasper and her cat to an upstairs bathroom. Her windows were open, and the gunfire reverberated throughout her home.
“It sounded like it was in the house,” she said.
She moved to her basement, and a SWAT officer escorted her from her home around 12:30 p.m. She left with her cat in a carrier, and the officer helped her with Jasper. She stayed with a friend overnight even though she could have gone home. She didn’t want to be there in the dark, she said.
She doesn’t feel unsafe back at home, but she said she’ll never forget that feeling of fear as she hid.
“That feeling of just like getting as low as you could and hearing all of that everywhere,” she said. “Like, I never want anybody to experience anything like that.”
But focusing on checking in with her neighbors has helped, and there’s been a lot of milling around and chatting throughout the neighborhood.
“It does feel isolated to me,” she said of the incident. “I also think that honestly, you kind of have to think about it that way. It’s a horrible situation. I don’t know what’s going to happen to that house.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.