Three years after its state-ordered closure, a juvenile detention facility will reopen soon in Allegheny County despite pushback, lawsuits, and what appears to be a lingering uncertainty as to the facility’s vision among some of the key figures involved — including the county executive, the district attorney and the operator of the facility itself.

The very idea of the facility for juveniles charged with a crime — colloquially referred to as “new Shuman” by some and officially called Highland Detention at Shuman Center by the private nonprofit that will run it — has been questioned since it was announced in August. County council almost immediately sued the former county executive, alleging he skirted the Home Rule Charter by not bringing the contract with Adelphoi to a vote before council.

The more vocal opponents on council have said they want the contract to be declared null and void.

But county officials have indicated they don’t believe that will happen and, regardless, they say the facility’s opening is imminent. The county is moving forward with the final pieces, including the appointment of a 10-member advisory board required by state law.

Advertise with us

“Our goal with the new Shuman is to provide excellent staff and holistic services including mental health supports, workforce development, and educational opportunities to allow for the young people to go on to reach their full potential,” Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato said in a statement announcing the advisory board. “Providing expertise and community input on the operations of Shuman are an important step to fulfilling that goal.”

That vision, though, seems to differ from that of others, including Adelphoi CEO Nancy Kukovich. She said that while staff will absolutely take a trauma-informed approach with the juveniles brought to the center, providing in-depth social services is not the current goal.

“I think one of the things that is emerging is, ‘What is detention?’” Ms. Kukovich said. “It’s not teaching them the trades. It’s not interview skills. It’s a very, very short pause. It’s detention. It’s a child who has been detained while the court makes the decision about what’s next.

“So it is a short-term service for safety and service to the courts,” she said.

Juveniles at the center in Lincoln-Lemington will receive meals, medical care and any other immediate needs. The focus, though, remains on relatively short stays.

Advertise with us

“That’s what detention is. It’s not treatment, it’s not reunification, it’s not how to get the community involved,” Ms. Kukovich said. “It’s a short, little, hopefully 10-day stay. That’s what we intend to do, that’s what we are doing now.”

The Latrobe-based private nonprofit runs 19 residential facilities across the state, and its services include foster care, education, in-home services and detention. Sixty-six of Pennsylvania’s 67 counties have a contract with Adelphoi.

The organization has also been housing Allegheny County youth in another facility since Shuman Center closed.

The county has been without a juvenile detention facility since September 2021, when its operating license was revoked by the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services. While the facility, which opened in 1974, was built to hold 120 juveniles, only about 20 were housed there when it closed.

At the time, Shuman Center was on its fourth provisional license, which is issued when state regulators discover violations. A provisional license is good for six months, and it’s meant as a stopgap while violations are corrected.

Advertise with us

The provisional license Shuman was operating under at the time had been granted July 1, 2021, and it was set to remain in place for six months “unless sooner revoked for non-compliance.” The state revoked the provisional license about a month and a half later amid continued violations — some new and some that had been cited time and again, including an overall failure by Shuman administrators to protect the young people.

Since it closed, there has been no in-county detention facility for juveniles. Some are housed at the Allegheny County Jail, some are sent to other counties, and some are held at an out-of-county Adelphoi-run facility. Others who would normally be held in detention are released on electronic monitoring.

A 21st century detention facility

That in itself has been a problem, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said, a nod to myriad reports of teens on home monitoring who are accused of more violence or who become victims of violence themselves.

“We need someplace to send them,” Mr. Zappala said. “We need someplace to hold people responsible for their actions.”

Ms. Kukovich emphasized the short-term nature of youths’ time there.

Advertise with us

“It’s not, ‘Get in here, you’re a felon, we’re locking you up,’” she said. Rather, staffers “will help them get acclimated, calm them down, get them something to eat and a good night’s sleep, and then start some form of education the next day.”

But Mr. Zappala said the center is not meant to be an education facility and, even if it was, he said, “I was out there the other day and I don’t even see that component right now.”

“I want a court out there — I want to expand mental health court, I want to expand drug court to address juvenile issues,” he said. “I can’t get anything done because nobody seems to even know how Shuman’s going to operate.”

To Ms. Kukovich, the vision is clear: A short-term stay — 10 days, ideally, she said — in which a youth is evaluated and assessed and ultimately placed by the court system.

The assessments include all aspects of the person’s life, she said: where they are in school, their behavior, their home life, and so on. Adelphoi staff will perform some of those evaluations, specialists with courts or county will perform others, she said.

Advertise with us

“So it’s this pause, everybody calm down, now let’s take a look at this child,” she said. “Let’s assemble all the information we have so we can hand it off to the judge so the judge makes a good decision.”

A work in progress

The new Shuman has been a work in progress since at least August, when the previous county administration announced the Adelphoi contract — worth about $73 million over five years.

What is set to open in the next few weeks is the first phase of what’s to come. A 12-bed pod is the stop-gap to provide some amount of space for juveniles while the rest of the facility is renovated and modified. The goal is 60 beds.

The rest of the renovations will be done at the same time, and so the prospect of housing more than a dozen kids won’t be a reality for 18 to 24 months.

Construction and renovations were the biggest hold up in terms of getting the facility open for the first 12 kids, Ms. Kukovich said, and work crews were met with myriad problems that one might expect in a building of that age.

Advertise with us

“A 50-year-old facility, you pull down the ceiling and, ‘Oh, my goodness, this isn’t connected to that,’” she said. “So there were things that they were not expecting.”

On top of that, Adelphoi personnel were spotting design flaws that Ms. Kukovich said just wouldn’t work in a 21st century detention facility. There were no electronic locks, she said, only keys, and there were no adequate security cameras.

“And we’re saying, ‘Well, that might have worked 25 years ago, but that’s not safe anymore, and you need to ante up,’” she said.

Because those are relatively one-time issues, she expects the next phase of work to go a bit smoother than the first.

Concerns over privatization

Pushback on the Adelphoi plans began almost immediately upon the announcement of the contract in a joint statement by former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and then-President Judge Kim Berkley Clark, who at the time oversaw the Fifth Judicial District. Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente has since taken over that post.

Advertise with us

Within a week, council members voted 9 to 4 to direct their solicitor to sue the county executive, arguing he had no right to enter the contract without council approval.

The argument centers on a specific clause in the county charter that says council has the authority to “by ordinance, lease convey, vacate or abandon, or permit the use of county land, buildings or other real or personal property.”

County solicitors say council is misinterpreting that piece of the charter.

In March, the judge overseeing the case ruled the lawsuit could move forward.

Much of the concern stems from the fact that the contract amounts to the privatization of the facility, something that some fear could mean little oversight. County officials, though, have stressed that there are actually multiple layers of oversight, including the advisory board.

Advertise with us

Ms. Innamorato submitted five appointments to county council for approval, and Judge Evashavik DiLucente selected three more members for the 10-person board. The remaining two seats will be filled by Ms. Innamorato and Controller Corey O’Connor.

Among the county executive’s nominees is anti-violence advocate Richard Garland, who has dedicated much of his life to working with many of the young people who might have landed in Shuman if it were open.

He’s created Reimagine Reentry, a program for individuals returning home after prison, and Gunshot Reoccurring Injury Prevention Services, or GRIPS, in which he meets with gunshot survivors while they’re hospitalized to offer intervention. He’s an assistant professor of behavioral and community health services at the University of Pittsburgh, and he oversees the university’s Violence Prevention Initiative.

He also spent years in and out of prison as a teenager and young adult in Philadelphia.

“If I have anything to do with it, I understood what Shuman used to be and how impactful they tried to be,” he said. “I’d like to build on what they’ve done in the past and actually look at the future.

Advertise with us

“If it’s a short stay, before that kid leaves that institution, we have to make sure that they’re booked up for services for real so they don’t get in anymore trouble,” he said.

Mr. Garland is perhaps an unlikely advocate for a youth detention center, and he dislikes the word “detention.”

“In my experience in the criminal justice system, it’s always based on us being the hammer to that nail. That’s not really helping young people,” he said.

Mr. Garland said that if council approves his appointment, his hope is to be a voice for the youth.

“I have not forgotten where I came from,” he said. “I’m going to be a squeaky wheel.”

Advertise with us

Private facility or not, this is an opportunity, he said, and a private organization is better than no organization — and it’s better than the adult-oriented Allegheny County Jail.

“Look, somebody has got to do something. We going to wait another two or three years?” he said. “People can keep arguing about Shuman, and we can argue all we want, but we need a place where we can get them on the straight and narrow.”