Governmental wheels are in motion to reopen Allegheny County’s only juvenile detention facility, a move that has drawn both criticism and cautious hope and has left progressives and criminal justice reformers at odds among themselves.

High-profile instances of youth violence have meant the conversations about what to do with kids who commit crimes have ratcheted up among residents, business owners and some public safety and elected officials.

Richard Garland doesn’t fit much into any of those groups, but his message in the wake of the news — that Allegheny County’s shuttered Shuman Center will reopen by next year — was simple.

“We need Shuman open,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Garland has dedicated decades of his life to working with and among many of the young people who are mixed up in street violence.

He’s created Reimagine Reentry, a program for individuals returning home after prison terms, and Gunshot Reoccurring Injury Prevention Services, or GRIPS, in which he meets with gunshot survivors while they’re still hospitalized to offer intervention. He’s an assistant professor of behavioral and community health services at the University of Pittsburgh, and he oversees the school’s Violence Prevention Initiative.

He also spent decades in and out of prison as a teenager and young adult in Philadelphia.

“Listen, I’m not a proponent of prisons or these kinds of things,” he said. “But there are young people out there that need some kind of circumstances for some of the things we’re doing.”

And up until 2021, the answer to that was the Shuman Center.

Advertise with us

The Sept. 15 announcement that the center would reopen under the private ownership of Adelphoi, a Latrobe-based nonprofit, drew cautious applause and strong rebukes.

It also threw gasoline onto a long-burning fire of discord between County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and a faction of county council — namely, council member-at-large Bethany Hallam and council President Pat Catena.

Both have long spoken against private ownership should Shuman reopen. On Friday, they claimed Mr. Fitzgerald does not actually have the power to contract out use of the facility.

In a press release, Mr. Catena pointed to powers granted to council by the county’s Home Rule Charter — specifically, that council has the power to “by ordinance, lease convey, vacate or abandon, or permit the use of county land, buildings or other real or personal property.”

That piece of the charter, Mr. Catena said, means Mr. Fitzgerald “overreached the authority that is actually granted to him.” He accused the county executive of doing so multiple times during his time in office but called this instance “the most egregious example.”

Advertise with us

Politicians in the region have largely agreed that there is a need for some type of youth facility in the area, though most have been sure to couch that with calls against privatization and for individualized and holistic treatment for kids sent there.

Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey, who won his 2021 election in part on his promise of criminal justice and policing reform, applauded the news that the facility would reopen.

The mayor has echoed the sentiments of public safety and other elected officials in the two years since Shuman was closed: It never should have happened — at least, not without a backup plan.

“If you’re picking up guns and you’re using guns — if you’re creating death in our streets — we don’t want you in these streets,” Mr. Gainey said. “So yes, violent criminals out here that are picking up guns and shooting people — we need a Shuman Center.”

He said that it has to be done right, stressing the need for actual youth services and programs — either within the facility or available to the facility — to prevent recidivism among juveniles.

Advertise with us

Ms. Hallam, a progressive who was and remains a vocal supporter of the mayor, told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV she remains “100% against the county selling out children who need help the most to the highest private bidder.”

Joe Rockey, the Republican nominee for Allegheny County executive, also disapproved of the move: “While I am in favor of establishing a juvenile detention and rehabilitation center,” he said in a statement last week, “I do not think Allegheny County should outsource the custody of its children.”

The divide is part of a larger narrative playing out nationwide — the question of how to treat and house youth who do or could pose a threat to public safety. The debate often centers around two opposite ends of a spectrum — either juvenile detention facilities stay open or they don’t.

Dennis Floyd Jones, a former member of the county’s Juvenile Detention Advisory Board and current CEO of Youth Enrichment Services, said it’s not that simple.

“People think it’s an issue of lock them up or not lock them up, and that’s just not the case,” said Mr. Jones, whose nonprofit has served more than 5,000 kids since its 1994 inception, offering everything from mentoring to funding trips for youth sports teams. Recently, it hosted a skating party.

Advertise with us

There are many aspects that make the idea of juvenile justice a gray area, he said. Child development must be taken into account, and there needs to be mental health services and educational services, and programs to reset their mindset and outlook. And all of that, he said, needs to be done while taking into account the unique trauma that many of the justice-involved children have experienced in their short lives.

“It’s a complex narrative that, for a lot of folks, there’s not a lot of easy answers,” Mr. Jones said. “The reality is, it is a ‘we’ problem, an ‘us’ problem. If we continue to pass it off as ‘this is just that community’s problems,’ we really miss the opportunity to bring together the best minds and the best resources.”

And public safety is part of that complex narrative.

“We have to have some type of a way to keep the community safe [when it comes to] a young person who is outside the margins when it comes to their behavior, particularly their behavior around guns,” he said. “Society can’t exist if you have folks who are constantly in a position to threaten and cause harm to others without any kind of deterrence.”

For years, the answer in Allegheny County was Shuman Center.

Advertise with us

The center, opened in 1974, was built to house up to 120 juveniles. Its operating license was revoked by the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services in August 2021.

In its final years, the center was hit again and again with violations and license revocations by the state. In 2009, county police and the state Department of Public Welfare investigated allegations that an employee slammed a teen’s head against a wall. Another employee was charged in a similar incident in 2013 after he was accused of smashing a boy’s head against a metal door frame.

Suicide attempts, assaults, fights and myriad other issues left the center with a series of provisional licenses, which are issued when violations are discovered. The provisional license is good for six months and is meant as a stopgap while violations are corrected.

At the time it closed, the facility was on its fourth provisional license.

That one had been granted July 1, 2021, and it was set to remain in place for the full six months “unless sooner revoked for non-compliance with applicable laws and regulations.”

Advertise with us

Continued violations pushed the state to revoke Shuman’s operating license. Officials noted that an inspection that preceded the revocation turned up violations that had been cited multiple times in the past. Those issues included failure to provide proper medical treatment and an overall failure to protect the kids by Shuman administrators.

“A lot of good people worked there and a lot of people had good intentions,” Mr. Jones said, though he noted that the center’s board was little more than a figurehead. “Board members were not really given access to a lot of the information about what was going on with inmates, behind the scenes, the administrative structure. We didn’t know they were closing Shuman until they closed.”

More than anything, he said, Shuman Center in its last iteration suffered from a near-constant identity crisis.

“The mission was never clear,” Mr. Jones said. “Are we here to try to get these kids and rehabilitate them, train them, work with them? Or are we here as part of the criminal justice system where we’re putting them here to punish them, segregate them from society?”

It’s not a matter of private vs. public, either, Mr. Jones said.

Advertise with us

“Whether it’s in a public institution or a nonprofit or a private corporation, we understand that it doesn’t matter,” he said. “It is the skills, the expertise, the resources that are available.”

He said that in the public vs. private sector debate, there is the chance that it all becomes about the money rather than the kids.

Most notably — and perhaps closest to home — is the 2008 so-called “kids for cash” scandal. Two Luzerne County judges were convicted of accepting money in return for sending juveniles who came before them to for-profit detention centers after the local county facility was shut down.

The kickbacks totaled some $2.5 million, and the scheme affected thousands of kids. The children involved were as young as preteens, and offenses were sometimes as minor as mocking an assistant principal on MySpace.

On the other side of things, Mr. Jones said, when it comes to nonprofits, it can become all about the mission.

Advertise with us

“In many cases, the bureaucracy and lack of experience and resources causes confounding of the goals,” he said. “You can’t say one is inherently good and one is inherently bad. It’s how it’s managed, the agreement, oversight, how you measure results and how you set yourself up for success.”

Adelphoi, a nonprofit, operates facilities across the state, and services range from foster care and education services to group homes and secure detention facilities.

That wide range of services was among the things that led Kim Berkley Clark, president judge of the Fifth Judicial District, to applaud the announcement of the Adelphoi contract.

“Adelphoi has a proven track record as a leading and highly respected agency that provides all levels of trauma-informed and evidence-based services for delinquent and dependent children,” she said, calling the contract a “crucial step toward creating a safer and more supportive environment” for young people in Allegheny County.

Mr. Jones said that makes Adelphoi one of the more unique organizations that he’s worked with, as several kids who have come through Youth Enrichment have been placed in Adelphoi programs.

Advertise with us

For their part, Adelphoi leaders say they are dedicated to caring for those in their programs in a holistic manner.

“I think our standards of care are transparent across all of our programs,” said Karyn Pratt, vice president of Adelphoi’s marketing and strategy. “We have a trauma-informed approach for all programs, including detention. When kids come into our programs, we recognize they most likely have had trauma at some point throughout their life experience.”

What was once Shuman Center, she said, will be called Highland Center.

Kids sent there will “have the benefit of that philosophy of care,” Ms. Pratt said. “It’s embedded in our training.”

Those housed at Highland will receive education services, health and dental care, and counseling and mental health services. Spiritual services are offered, and family members can visit. When they leave the facility, they receive after-care.

Advertise with us

The facility will undergo $4.7 million in renovations, the planning for which could begin as soon as early October. County officials said bids for the project were due earlier this month, and a contract should be finalized by late September. The contract will call for renovations to be completed by Dec. 31.

Renovations of the center, according to a release from Allegheny County, will include “a secure housing unit and support areas.” The scope of the work includes a gymnasium and one of the housing units.

Whatever the case, Mr. Garland said, something has to be done.

“Something has to happen. Probation is overwhelmed trying to keep track of these different young people. Parents are at their wits end,” he said. “Adelphoi, some of the programs they have are for not only the kids but the family as well.”

He said he’s impressed by that type of approach.

“We can improve things by curing the whole family in some of these situations,” he said. “We can bring down some of this violence. We might turn this whole thing around.”