Two Allegheny County Council members on Friday claimed neither County Executive Rich Fitzgerald nor the court system have the authority to enter into any kind of contract regarding the use of county-owned property, an allegation stemming from the recent announcement that the county’s shuttered juvenile detention facility would reopen under the private ownership of a nonprofit.
The announcement last week — that the nonprofit Latrobe-based Adelphoi would reopen and run Shuman Center — drew rebukes from some local elected officials and tentative applause from others. Among those who denounced the decision: County President Pat Catena and member-at-large Bethany Hallam.
The facility, previously run by the county, was shut down by the state in 2021 after years of repeated violations.
Mr. Catena said in a statement early Friday afternoon that Ms. Hallam would introduce legislation at next week’s council meeting that would seek a court ruling against Mr. Fitzgerald and the Court of Common Pleas.
A spokeswoman for the county declined to offer comment or a response to the claims.
In his press release, Mr. Catena pointed to powers granted to council per the county’s Home Rule Charter — specifically, that council has the power to “by ordinance, lease convey, vacate or abandon, or permit the use of county land, buildings or other real or personal property.”
Read More
That piece of the charter, Mr. Catena said, means Mr. Fitzgerald “overreached the authority that is actually granted to him.” He accused the county executive of doing so multiple times during his time in office but called the instance “the most egregious example.”
In announcing the contract last week, President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark cited the Adelphoi’s “proven track record as a leading and highly respected agency.”
“This is a crucial step toward creating a safer and more supportive environment for juveniles in the county,” Judge Clark said in a statement.
Shuman housed about 20 youth when it closed in 2021.
While the detention center will house only 12 when it reopens, once fully renovated, it will offer 60 beds.
The facility will undergo $4.7 million in renovations, the planning for which could begin as soon as early October. County officials said bids for the project were due earlier this month, and a contract should be finalized by late September. The contract will call for renovations to be completed by Dec. 31.
The center, opened in 1974, was built to house up to 120 juveniles. Its operating license was revoked by the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services in August 2021.
At the time, the facility was on its fourth provisional license, which are issued when violations are discovered. The provisional license is good for six months and is meant as a stopgap while violations are corrected.
The provisional license the facility was operating under at the time had been granted July 1, 2021, and it was set to remain in place for the full six months “unless sooner revoked for non-compliance with applicable laws and regulations.”
Continued violations pushed the state to revoke Shuman’s operating license. Officials noted that an inspection that preceded the revocation turned up violations that had been cited multiple times in the past. Those issues included failure to provide proper medical treatment and an overall failure to protect the kids by Shuman administrators.
Mr. Catena blasted the Shuman announcement almost as soon as it was made.
“We had an opportunity to obtain input from a variety of sources in a collaborative fashion in order to create a multifaceted juvenile justice center geared toward education, teaching skills, and breaking the cycle of recidivism while individuals are still in the juvenile justice system,” he said in a statement.
“Instead,” he continued, “the [Allegheny County executive] and courts have opted to embrace the cutting edge of decades-old thinking in order to warehouse kids in a center run by a for-profit business, while pretending that this somehow improves outcomes for the children that will be treated as commodities for which a contractor is paid.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.