A Washington County judge heard arguments Friday about whether Allegheny County Council members should have a say in approving a new contract for operations inside the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center — but a final decision is still up in the air.
The Allegheny County Council had sued former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald’s administration and the county courts in September over a contract entered into with Adelphoi, a Latrobe-based nonprofit, to run the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center.
At the heart of the suit is whether the county executive and the county courts have the unilateral authority, per the county charter, to enter into a contract for an outside provider to run the center, without council approval.
Mr. Fitzgerald and his colleagues believed they did, but a majority of County Council members disputed that.
Allegheny County Council President Patrick Catena has specifically cited a clause in the charter that states the council has the authority to “by ordinance, lease convey, vacate or abandon, or permit the use of county land, buildings or other real or personal property.” In the council’s original complaint, it cites several examples of leases in county parks where a council vote was executed to complete those agreements.
In a response to the complaint, Dennis Biondo Jr. and Lisa Michel, assistant county solicitors, said the council is not properly interpreting that part of the county charter. The executive branch has contracting powers in the county charter, and if taken to its extreme, council’s argument means the legislative body would be required “to pass an ordinance anytime County property is involved in any contract where a service provider enters the property,” they state.
Read More
“In other words, Council asserts that it would be required to review and pass upon any contract for maintenance, or any service provided by a vendor on County property,” the response states in part. That would mean the executive’s contracting authority in the county charter would essentially be meaningless, the county argues.
During oral arguments on Friday, Mr. Biondo told Washington County Judge Katherine B. Emery that because Adelphoi was only providing services throughout a county-owned facility, the legislative branch did not need to approve the contract with the nonprofit.
But Frederick Frank, the County Council’s solicitor, said the council should “have its day in court” to prove that Adelphoi would have complete use and control of Shuman — and that calling the contract simply one where services are provided is untrue.
“We believe this whole service system [argument] is a red herring,” Mr. Frank said in court Friday.
Mr. Biondo Jr. and Mr. Frank declined comment after oral arguments, and Judge Emery did not immediately rule from the bench.
The Shuman Center, which could house up to 120 juveniles, was closed in September 2021 due to state violations and licensing issues. It had opened in 1974 and is located in the Lincoln-Lemington neighborhood.
Juvenile detention and criminal justice was a hot-button issue during local political campaigns in 2023, and intensified when the county administration and courts revealed they were contracting with Adelphoi to reopen the center in 2024 — first with 12 beds, and then increasing as further renovations to the facility were completed.
At the moment, juveniles who have been detained and would otherwise be held in Shuman are being held at the Allegheny County Jail in Pittsburgh or, more often, released to a guardian or sent to juvenile facilities in other counties.
In a 9-4 vote with two abstentions, the council voted in September to direct its solicitor to sue the administration and courts. The two sides have issued filings staking their claims since then.
Judge Emery presided over oral arguments Friday, as Kim Clark, the former president judge for Allegheny County, recused herself and all county judges since they were involved in the contract with Adelphoi.
Steve Bohnel: sbohnel@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.