Ezra Bozeman’s days at the state prison in Somerset County are generally confined to a hospital bed — a medical emergency earlier this year left him a quadriplegic, and even pressing the call button to summon prison staff presents a challenge.

Multiple doctors agree that his lifespan is severely shortened by his condition, which at this point also includes a pressure sore so deep it has reached the bone. They don’t agree, though, on just how short his time is — among the sticking points that could keep him from living out his final days in a skilled nursing facility as opposed to a state prison.

His attorney, Dolly Prabhu, of the Abolitionist Law Center, argued in front of Allegheny County Common Pleas President Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente last week that the Department of Corrections can’t provide the level of care he needs.

“It’s a prison, not a nursing home,” she said.

Advertise with us

Bozeman, 68, was convicted of second-degree murder in 1975, accused of killing Morris Weitz, the co-owner of an East Liberty cleaners, during an attempted robbery. Bozeman was just a week past his 19th birthday at the time of the crime. He has maintained his innocence.

He’s among nine DOC inmates who have applied for so-called compassionate release under state law: The opportunity to spend their dying days receiving care outside of prison walls. Only those who are deemed to have less than a year to live can apply and, even then, there are other strict requirements.

Bozeman’s case has gained notoriety given the breadth of the support he’s garnered, including from Gov. Josh Shapiro and at least a half-dozen state legislators. A skilled nursing facility near Philadelphia has agreed to take Bozeman, and the superintendent of his facility has signed a declaration stating that he would pose minimal risk if released to the facility’s care.

The District Attorney’s Office, though, is fighting his release to the nursing home, arguing Bozeman failed to make a compelling pitch for his compassionate release. In a hearing Tuesday, Deputy District Attorney Ronald Wabby Jr. said there’s no real proof that he’d receive better medical treatment outside of prison.

And while one doctor said he’s unlikely to live more than a year, his prison doctor wouldn’t put a timeframe on Bozeman’s life expectancy.

Advertise with us

In a court filing moving for Bozeman’s release to a nursing facility, his attorney pointed to what she said are deficiencies in care at SCI-Laurel Highlands, the Somerset County prison that generally houses inmates who require long-term care.

Bozeman didn’t have the serious pressure wound before he was released from Magee Rehabilitation to the prison, and prison staff do not reposition him every two hours, which mitigates the risk for such sores.

“Further, Mr. Bozeman struggles to get the attention of medical staff because he is unable to press the call button for emergency assistance,” attorneys wrote. “As a result, he is often extremely thirsty, denied water, and at risk of dehydration.”

‘I want to hear him say it’

Pennsylvania law includes seven requirements that petitioning inmates must meet. Among them: the medical needs of the inmate can be more appropriately addressed at a hospital or long-term care facility; the inmate is seriously ill and not expected to live more than a year; and the inmate doesn’t pose a risk if transferred to a medical facility.

Other pieces of the law are technical: A medical facility must have already agreed to take over medical care of the inmate, and there are no pending cases that would require the individual to appear in court. Everyone involved, from the DA’s office and corrections officials to victims in the case must be made aware.

Advertise with us

In Bozeman’s case, he has the support of Melissa Hainsworth, the superintendent of SCI-Laurel Highlands. In a signed declaration, she wrote that while he’d received several dozen misconducts during his sentence, most came early in his incarceration, and the last — refusing to obey an order — was in 2009. She wrote that the risk he poses “appears to be minimal.”

Mr. Wabby dismissed the information contained in Bozeman’s petition, saying he wouldn’t stipulate to any of it.

“There’s simply nothing here,” he said. “These aren’t even certified medical records.”

He called an affidavit in which Bozeman detailed his condition and current care as hearsay. Based on Bozeman’s condition, Mr. Wabby said, attorneys would have “prepared [the affidavit] with all the magical words.”

He said he wanted to hear Bozeman testify to his condition and treatment himself.

Advertise with us

“I want to hear him say it,” he said.

Ms. Prabhu said her client’s condition means he has mucus buildup in his throat that he has trouble clearing, and he can’t talk for any extended periods of time.

Bozeman underwent surgery in February to relieve pressure on his spine — an injury that his attorneys say went undiagnosed for years. The surgery was initially successful, according to notes included in the court filings, but a blood clot near the surgery during his recovery left him completely paralyzed.

Dr. Eric Quach, a Temple University physician who cared for Bozeman in the months leading up to and the weeks after his February surgery, believes Bozeman has little time left, writing that “given his age, serious medical conditions, and current circumstances, I do not believe that he is likely to live longer than the next year.”

But Dr. Andrew Dancha, the DOC physician who has cared for Bozeman in prison, was unwilling to put a timeframe on his life expectancy.

Advertise with us

“The prognosis for [Bozeman] is unclear, but his life expectancy will clearly be decreased due to his injury,” Dr. Dancha wrote in medical notes attorneys included in their petition to the judge.

“This will be true whether he remains in prison or is transferred to an outside nursing facility,” Dr. Dancha wrote. “At this time, I am unable to provide a life expectancy as this varies widely with different individuals with ever-changing medical issues.”

Meeting the burden of proof

Since 2016, the most recent for which data was available, through the end of 2023, 74 petitions for compassionate release were filed by Department of Corrections inmates. Of those, 44 were granted, 10 were denied, and seven were otherwise withdrawn.

In the same time, 13 people died waiting for decisions.

That’s not uncommon, according to Nishi Kumar, an attorney and head of medical-legal projects at the Medical Justice Alliance, an organization of physicians that work with incarcerated people.

Advertise with us

Many states have strict definitions of who can be released under compassionate release statutes, and some people are deemed “not sick enough.”

“There is a strong chance that person will die before they get a chance to come back to court,” she said.

So far in 2024, nine petitions have been filed in Pennsylvania, and five have been granted. One person died during the court process. Two are pending, including Bozeman’s.

The number of compassionate release petitions filed each year has increased: from three or four each year to 13 in 2022 and 18 in 2023. Some of that could be because of continued pushes for criminal justice reform and increased attention on cases similar to Bozeman’s.

Spotlight PA, a nonprofit Pennsylvania news outlet, profiled Raymond Caliman in early 2022. At 68, an infection had left him bedridden and deteriorating but not at imminent risk of dying. After Spotlight’s piece published, the Abolitionist Law Center took up Caliman’s case, and he was ultimately released to hospice care in Philadelphia. He died less than two months later.

Advertise with us

The next hearing on Bozeman’s request is Monday morning.

It’s not clear to what extent Bozeman might be required to testify. He appeared at the hearing Tuesday via video call. He lay in a hospital bed, and someone had to adjust the camera for him to be seen.

Judge Evashavik DiLucente all but told Bozeman she will grant his release if Dr. Quach can testify as to what he wrote in his notes about Bozeman’s prognosis. Mr. Wabby, of the DA’s office, will have the opportunity to cross-examine the doctor.

“I believe Mr. Bozeman will meet his burden of proof,” Judge Evashavik DiLucente said.