A state appellate court has kept alive a challenge to the city of Pittsburgh’s efforts to remove a statue of Christopher Columbus from Schenley Park.
In an order issued Friday, Commonwealth Court sent the case back to an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court judge in response to a challenge by the Italian Sons and Daughters of America.
The statue has been covered since 2020 and its removal had been approved by former Mayor Bill Peduto following a recommendation by the city’s art commission.
Common Pleas Judge John McVay Jr. had dismissed the lawsuit in September 2022, ruling that Pittsburgh officials had the right to remove the divisive statue. The judge’s decision relied heavily on U.S. Supreme Court case law, specifically a case out of Pleasant Grove, Utah, in which the city rejected a proposed religious monument in a city park.
The ISDA argued during a hearing in October 2023 that because a 1955 ordinance was voted upon and passed allowing the statue to be built, an ordinance must similarly be voted upon and passed for the massive bronze monument to be removed.
In her opinion Friday, Commonwealth Court Judge Patricia McCullough said Judge McVay erred in concluding that ISDA’s claims “are barred in their entirety based exclusively on the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision.” She reversed his order and sent the case back to him.
Read More
The appellate court did reject the ISDA’s challenge to Judge McVay for refusing to recuse himself from the case. The court said Judge McVay did not commit an abuse of discretion when he issued a memorandum that remarked upon the heroic qualities and character flaws in Columbus’ legacy.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.