Commonwealth Court arguments scheduled for Wednesday morning could mark the beginning of the end of a yearslong debate as to whether Pittsburgh’s monument to Christopher Columbus will join the dozens of others that have been removed or toppled across the country in recent years.

The Schenley Park memorial to the 15th century explorer has been covered since 2020 when, amid a modern reckoning with systemic racism within America and throughout its history, it became the target of vandals and calls for removal.

The city’s previous art commission recommended its removal at the time, a move endorsed by then-Mayor Bill Peduto.

With the push for the statue’s removal came pushback, and the Pittsburgh-based Italian Sons and Daughters of America (ISDA) filed a lawsuit against the city and Mr. Peduto in October 2020.

Advertise with us

The heart of the debate has pit history against itself.

Those in favor of its removal say Columbus was a murderer and colonizer whose landing in the so-called New World set off a genocide of Native Americans in the name of exploration and expansion. Statue supporters laud Columbus — who never actually ventured to what is now the United States — as an explorer who exemplifies a strong and heroic Italian American heritage.

But at the heart of the legal argument is the ISDA’s contention that because a 1955 ordinance was voted upon and passed allowing the statue to be built, an ordinance must similarly be voted upon and passed for the massive bronze monument to be removed.

As the legal process has played out over the ensuing three years, the future of the 13-foot, 800-pound statue has remained in limbo.

Just over a year ago, Common Pleas Judge John McVay Jr. dismissed the ISDA lawsuit, ruling that Pittsburgh officials had the right to remove the divisive statue. The judge’s decision relied heavily U.S. Supreme Court case law, specifically a case out of Pleasant Grove, Utah, in which the city rejected a proposed religious monument in a city park.

Advertise with us

That 2009 ruling said governments have the right to regulate monuments in city-owned parks because they “typically represent government speech.”

The ISDA appealed the ruling as well as an earlier decision by Judge McVay not to recuse himself from the case. The judge had, throughout the years-long saga, urged the two sides to work together. He’d suggest perhaps relocating the statue to a different but still public location. The possibility of a “teachable moment” fell flat with “ISDA’s refusal to agree to an alternative location such as a museum or history center.”

Now, the case awaits Wednesday’s oral arguments in front of a panel of judges.

Across the country, local governments have reckoned with statues that some say represent antagonists who wrought — directly or indirectly — pain and suffering on oft underrepresented groups, such as Native Americans and African Americans.

Much of the focus has been on tributes and memorials to figures from the secession-era South. Those pushing for their removal say they promote white supremacy and the Confederacy and stand as monuments to treason.

Advertise with us

Others say they represent history and heritage nonetheless.

That same historical introspection has led to the debate surrounding and removal of some Columbus statues across the country. Some local governments chose to remove the monuments. In other cities and towns, protesters toppled the monuments themselves.

In Baltimore in July 2020, protestors pulled down a statue of the explorer near the city’s Little Italy neighborhood. Hunks of the statue, unveiled in 1984, were tossed into the Inner Harbor. Later that same month in Chicago, city crews removed two statues of Columbus from public areas — one in Grant Park and one in that city’s Little Italy neighborhood.

Mayor Lori Lightfoot said at the time that the decision was made in light of other Columbus-related protests across the country, citing “demonstrations that became unsafe for both protesters and police.”

Earlier this year, officials in Columbus, Ohio, removed a statue of the city’s namesake from city hall.

Advertise with us

“For many people in our community, the statue represents patriarchy, oppression and divisiveness,” Mayor Andrew Ginther said at the time. “That does not represent our great city, and we will no longer live in the shadow of our ugly past.”

In Pittsburgh, Mayor Ed Gainey has remained mostly mum on the issue and lawsuit, which he inherited when he took office in January 2022. After Judge McVay’s ruling in October 2022, a spokeswoman for Mr. Gainey’s office said the administration was “reviewing the opinion and looking at the next steps moving forward.”

The mayor’s office on Monday did not respond to requests for comment on Wednesday’s scheduled arguments.