Tyler Smith’s substance abuse issues are neither a reason to torture severely disabled patients in his care nor why he should be granted leniency, a federal judge said Friday, adding that he failed to see how alcohol would lead Smith to commit such heinous acts.

“People have alcohol problems, but they don’t go to work and beat other people up,” Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan told Smith as he stood quietly by his attorney’s side.

The judge sentenced Smith to a maximum of 10 years and three years of supervised release.

Smith, 34, of New Brighton, admitted during a plea hearing in December that he and co-defendant Zachary Dinell assaulted disabled residents of McGuire Memorial in New Brighton from about June 2016 to September 2017, including punching and kicking them, spraying liquid irritants in their eyes and mouths, and, in one instance, removing a resident’s compression stocking in a manner intended to inflict pain.

Advertise with us

Smith pleaded guilty to conspiracy and violating the federal Hate Crimes Prevention Act. Dinell also pleaded guilty to similar charges and was sentenced to 17 years imprisonment, followed by three years supervised release. The two had been responsible for providing daily assistance to residents such as bathing, using the bathroom, oral hygiene, feeding and dressing.

Smith’s mother pleaded for leniency. Speaking in the courtroom ahead of his sentencing, Janet Smith asked the judge for a mitigated sentence, saying the past seven years and time in rehab had changed her son for the better.

“If you haven’t lived with an addict or two, then you’ll never understand,” she said.

Judge Ranjan told Smith he should be proud that he’s now clean.

“But it doesn’t take away the harm,” he said.

Advertise with us

Several of the assaults were recorded on Dinell’s cell phone — including one in which Smith jumped on top of a 13-year-old while the child was lying on his bed.

Smith also acknowledged that he and Dinell exchanged text messages in which they expressed their animus toward the residents, shared photographs and videos of residents, described their assaults and encouraged continued abuse of residents.

During one of several victim impact statements, Karen Pennell held up a photo of her son Connor Logan, who was one of Smith’s victims at 17. Illness as a newborn led Mr. Logan to have severe developmental delays and to be nonverbal, she said.

Ms. Pennell read a text message Smith sent to Dinnell about her son: “[Patient] number 10 got it bad last night.”

It has haunted her for years.

Advertise with us

“What the [expletive] did you do to my sweet boy,” she said. “He can never tell us; we can never know.”

Catherine Wickline’s son, Nicholas Maravich, had advanced cerebral palsy and was unable to roll over in bed, she said. Maravich died at 39 from injuries related to the abuse, she said.

“My Nicholas was magic, and I was honored to be his mother,” Ms. Wickline said.

“Tyler Smith, you never saw his beauty because you never even looked.”