Keith Edmonds, a Pittsburgh police officer fired after the 2021 death of Jim Rogers following a violent encounter with police, has been reinstated.
A neutral arbitrator made his ruling Friday, nearly two years after Officer Edmonds was fired along with several other officers involved in Rogers’ arrest. All appealed their discipline. Officer Edmonds was the only one whose appeal went to arbitration.
A statement from Maria Montaño, a spokeswoman Mayor Ed Gainey’s office, expressed dismay at the decision but did not indicate whether the city would appeal.
The statement alluded to the officer’s testimony in the arbitration hearings.
“Officer Edmonds himself testified that he violated [bureau] policies,” Ms. Montaño wrote, saying the ruling sets a standard that “even an admission of guilt by an officer isn’t enough to warrant disciplinary action.”
The arbitrator’s ruling says Officer Edmonds should be reinstated with back pay and benefits and face no discipline, according to Bob Swartzwelder, president of the union representing city police.
Read More
Rogers died Oct. 14, 2021, a day after he fell unconscious in the back of a police cruiser after he was arrested in Bloomfield.
Disciplinary hearings for the officers involved in the arrest went on for weeks. Once Officer Edmonds was fired, Mr. Swartzwelder said, the first step was to appeal the decision to the police chief, at the time Scott Schubert, who has since retired. When the chief upheld that decision, an appeal was filed with the director of public safety, Lee Schmidt.
Officer Edmonds ultimately was fired March 24, 2022.
His appeal then went to a panel of one neutral arbitrator and two partial arbitrators, one from the city and one from the police union — in this case, Mr. Swartzwelder. There were two full days of hearings — one in September and one in November.
For the neutral arbitrator’s decision to hold, at least one of the partial arbitrators had to concur with the decision. Mr. Swartzwelder said he was the concurrent opinion in this case.
He said he could not go into details about the hearings or the briefs and expert reports submitted by each side.
“I told everybody you have to wait until you hear all the evidence, and then the conclusion’s going to be that there was no misconduct,” Mr. Swartzwelder said. “It’s unfortunate that Mr. Rogers died, but he died for others reasons than police actions.”
The Pittsburgh branch of the NAACP decried the decision, calling it one that has “sparked justified outrage and profound disappointment.”
Daylon Davis, president of the branch, said the reinstatement erodes trust and undermines accountability.
“Such a decision devalues Black lives, reducing them to mere financial sums,” he said in a statement. “Regrettably, it seems the price tag of taking this Black man’s life has been valued at $8 million this time.”
The city settled a federal lawsuit with Rogers’ estate last year for $8 million.
The day of the incident, Officer Edmonds was dispatched to Harriet Street after someone called 911 to report that a man might have been trying to steal a bicycle from a porch. Some neighbors, however, later would contend the bike was left outside and was free for the taking.
Video released earlier this year by an attorney for Rogers’ family showed the officer’s interactions with Rogers.
Rogers, wearing a black T-shirt, gray sweatpants and a disposable COVID-19 mask, has no bike when the officer arrives. The interaction at first is tense but nonviolent. Officer Edmonds tells Rogers to put his hands up.
Rogers appears to become flustered when Officer Edmonds begins reaching into Rogers’ pocket. He starts trying to put his hands into his pockets. Officer Edmonds drops him to the ground.
Over four minutes, Rogers is struck again and again with Officer Edmonds’ Taser, appearing to become more disoriented and incoherent each time. He tried twice to run away, but he was stunned each time. He otherwise remained sitting or on his hands and knees as the officer issued his demands.
More officers arrived and he was eventually taken into custody. Rogers appeared to be in medical distress as he waited in the back of a police cruiser to be taken to the hospital. It took another 17 minutes before officers began driving. Rogers wasn’t breathing by the time officers reached UPMC Mercy about 45 minutes after the initial police call.
The Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office ruled Rogers’ death an accident caused by the interruption of blood flow to the brain.
Almost all of the officers disciplined for their actions — or inactions — the day of Rogers’ death have settled for lesser penalties and returned to work, though two retired before any official discipline was meted out.
Officer Edmonds was the only fired officer whose case went to arbitration — the city has not released the names or punishment of the other disciplined officers — and he was the last to receive his job back.
Two other officers who weren’t fired appealed their discipline, and they’ve also since returned to the bureau facing lesser penalties than those originally issued.
One officer who was suspended still is awaiting a decision on his appeal, and Mr. Swartzwelder said he expects that decision next week.
It was not clear why city officials agreed to settle those officers’ cases in arbitration. City officials said multiple times in a December media briefing that they believed that had it not been for police actions, Rogers would be alive.
“The city was very confident … that Mr. Rogers died because of the actions of the officers,” city solicitor Krysia Kubiak said in the Dec. 14 briefing.
“To put it plainly,” mayoral spokeswoman Maria Montano said in the same briefing, “Mr. Rogers would still be alive today if it were not for the actions of the officers on that day.”
The 52-minute video released earlier this year by attorney Todd Hollis is an amalgamation of footage recorded by bystanders, body-worn police cameras and cameras within the police vehicle.
Mr. Hollis said at the time that the goal in releasing the video was to “uphold the principles of justice and integrity in the legal system.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.