For years as sheriff’s sales loomed and code violations piled up against Prasad Margabandhu and his East Carson Street property, the Mt. Lebanon man allegedly used baseless bankruptcy filings to stave off creditors — a scheme that federal prosecutors say culminated in a four-alarm fire set intentionally at Mr. Margabandhu’s direction.

Mr. Margabandhu, who has owned multiple properties and businesses in Allegheny and surrounding counties, is charged with bankruptcy fraud, mail fraud, conspiracy and malicious destruction of property. He could not immediately be reached for comment.

The 16-page indictment unsealed Wednesday revealed the lengths to which 47-year-old Mr. Margabandhu allegedly went to keep the three-story building from going to sheriff’s sale.

Mr. Margabandhu bought property at 1925 East Carson St. on the South Side March 4, 2019 — the day it was set to go to sheriff’s sale for unpaid taxes but before the sheriff’s sale. The previous owner, on the day of the sale, filed for bankruptcy. The property was sold for $5,000 to a corporation named Shane Tracy Enterprises the same day.

Advertise with us

Mr. Margabandhu owned Shane Tracy Enterprises.

The sheriff’s sale was rescheduled for June 2, 2019, according to the indictment. One day before that, Mr. Margabandhu allegedly filed his own fraudulent bankruptcy petition — a move that meant the sheriff’s sale was postponed again.

Prosecutors allege Mr. Margabandhu “had no intentions of complying with” the requirements of the bankruptcy petition.

This scenario played out three more times between 2019 and 2022, according to the indictment. Each time, the bankruptcy filing was ultimately dismissed by Bankruptcy Court because, according to prosecutors, each filing was meant only to delay the sheriff’s sale and leave creditors hanging.

In June 2022, Mr. Margabandhu devised a plan for someone else — identified in the indictment only as “C.U.” — to set fire to the East Carson Street property. The two negotiated payment that C.U. would receive in return for his fire-starting and when he would receive those payments, according to the indictment.

Advertise with us

The fire was reported shortly before 4 a.m. June 22, 2022. Authorities at the time said that although crews were on scene within five minutes, the fire grew to four alarms. Buildings on either side of the property had to be evacuated, and it took some 50 firefighters to put out the blaze.

Mr. Margabandhu filed an insurance claim the same day. The building was condemned after the fire.

While Mr. Margabandhu was allegedly filing fake bankruptcy petitions, code violations and citations were piling up at the East Carson Street property, records show.

From October 2020 through earlier this month, more than 100 citations were issued to 1925 East Carson St., according data kept by the Western Pennsylvania Regional Data Center. The site is a collaboration among the University of Pittsburgh, Allegheny County, and Pittsburgh that makes that kind of data publicly available.

Among the myriad complaints: Rubbish and garbage throughout the property; failure to get building permits for work and renovations; missing and broken windows; old furniture strewn about behind the building; and failure to clean up fire damage.

Advertise with us

Criminal complaints were issued in nearly two dozen instances, records show.

The most recent code violations were issued Feb. 7, citing the continued failure to address fire damage — including missing windows, a charred roof, and extensive water damage.

In 2018, tenants of a Penn Hills apartment complex owned by another of Mr. Margabandhu’s companies were evicted without notice after utilities were shut off for failure to pay. Mr. Margabandhu told the Post-Gazette at the time that he’d never received a shutoff notice and said an ownership dispute caused the issue.

In December 2022, Mr. Margabandhu came under fire for what neighbors in Arlington Heights called disgraceful conditions at a former church bought by another company owned by Mr. Margabandhu. Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV reported the city had issued numerous citations to the owner and condemned the building.

“The property gets cleaned up and people or someone dumps,” Mr. Margabandhu told the TV station at the time. “Need to catch the culprits.”

Advertise with us

Records show Mr. Margabandhu was incurring citations related to businesses and properties in Westmoreland County as well.

Arraignment is set for Feb. 28 in federal court.