A Pine Township man told police he thought he hit a deer when he allegedly struck and killed a man last year along McKnight Road in McCandless, according to charges filed this week.

Karl Scott, 36, was charged with being involved in an accident involving death or personal injury and was released on nonmonetary bail after he was arraigned Wednesday.

Police said Mr. Scott was the driver who struck 78-year-old Donald Leach at about 10:15 p.m. on March 11, 2023. Leach was crossing McKnight Road at Blazier Drive when he was struck.

Leach was pronounced dead at the scene.

Advertise with us

Mr. Scott was driving his mother’s 2017 Honda Accord northbound on McKnight Road when he struck Leach at the intersection of Blazier Drive, according to a criminal complaint. After that, he slowed down to ensure the vehicle was running properly but did not come to a complete stop and continued back to his parents’ residence in Pine. When he arrived home, he told his mother he hit a deer, the complaint said.

Two weeks later, after confirming what kind of vehicle damaged pieces left behind at the scene were from, police visited Mr. Scott at his parents’ home and found front-end damage on a car matching the damaged pieces.

Mr. Scott told police at that time that he was familiar with deer strikes and possible evidence that would be left behind, including fur from the animal. He told police he didn’t see any fur but did not think it was necessary to follow up with police, according to the complaint.

A preliminary hearing scheduled for Feb. 14.