The subject of a controversial arrest earlier this year in Downtown Pittsburgh will stand trial on drug charges, a judge ruled Monday, though she dismissed an aggravated assault charge related to the August incident that sparked outrage among community members.
Jashon Martin, 32, still faces three misdemeanor drug charges as well as one felony charge of possession with intent to deliver. Martin has remained in the Allegheny County Jail since his Aug. 25 arrest. Formal arraignment is scheduled for Jan. 8.
Video of Martin’s arrest near Smithfield Street and Strawberry Way drew demands for answers from community leaders. Police initiated an internal investigation but Chief Larry Scirotto ultimately ruled the use of force by officers involved was reasonable and within policy.
The video was not introduced as evidence during Monday’s preliminary hearing, which lasted about 90 minutes. Officers involved confirmed they struggled with Martin and used fists and knees to take him into custody.
The incident began shortly before 8:30 p.m. while Pittsburgh narcotics detectives were conducting surveillance Downtown.
Among the officers in the car were Detectives Calvin Kennedy, Eric Weinheimer and Scott Love. Detective Kennedy told the judge he focused his attention on Martin after he allegedly made two suspected drug sales.
Read More
Martin’s public defender, Yemi Olaiya, asked who came up with the plan to detain her client. All said it was a group effort and no one person was in charge, though Detective Love said he was the acting sergeant in the car at the time the decision was made.
Detective Kennedy said the officers pulled up to the scene in their unmarked car and he was the first out. He said he announced himself as law enforcement and grabbed Martin from behind in a bear hug. Detectives Love and Weinheimer were a few seconds behind him, he said. Officer Brian Prunty responded to the scene from nearby when a call went out over police radio about the arrest.
The detectives testified that Martin refused to comply with commands to put his hands behind his back, and he was ultimately taken to the ground where he allegedly continued to struggle. Officer Prunty said he tried to gain control of Martin’s head. He said Martin kept reaching toward his waistband.
He said he delivered “one closed fist strike” to Martin’s face and then tried to gain control of his head. At some point, he said, Martin bit down on his right middle and index fingers
Ms. Olaiya pressed the officer on how his finger ended up in her client’s mouth, asking the question several different ways until Assistant District Attorney Jarrod Caruso broke in.
“He does not remember how his fingers came to be in Mr. Martin’s mouth,” he said.
Detective Prunty said he struck Martin several more times until another officer ultimately stopped him.
“Yes,” he said when Ms. Olaiya questioned him on whether someone stopped him. “I don’t know why he stopped me. Maybe he saw something I didn’t.”
Detective Love said he used his knee to strike Martin but denied hitting him in the head. He said the knee strike was delivered to his midsection.
Multiple detectives testified that before Martin was taken to the ground, they saw a baggie in one of his hands. Detective Love said later testing of the contents indicated it was crack cocaine. Detectives said several baggies of suspected marijuana were found in Martin’s pockets. A digital scale was in his backpack, they said.
Ms. Olaiya asked each officer if they took any statements from witnesses, bystanders or those to whom Martin allegedly sold drugs. None did, they testified.
Martin’s attorney argued her client didn’t intend to bite Officer Prunty and, beyond that, he did not seek medical attention outside of that offered by city paramedics, and he did not miss any work because of it. She also argued that Martin wasn’t resisting arrest insofar as he wasn’t kicking or punching, but rather was just trying to get away.
Magisterial District Judge Leah Williams Duncan ultimately agreed — in part.
To meet the criteria of aggravated assault, she said, someone must have “intentionally and knowingly caused bodily harm.”
“I don’t believe the Commonwealth met that burden,” she said, noting that Officer Prunty’s fingers “inexplicably ended up in Mr. Martin’s mouth.”
Judge Duncan dismissed the aggravated assault charge but held the others over for trial.
Lawyers on both sides declined further comment after the proceedings.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.