The Citizens Police Review Board will investigate a violent arrest last month in Downtown Pittsburgh that spurred calls for action from community groups and promises of an investigation by the city.
The arrest happened Aug. 25 just outside the Smithfield United Church of Christ at the corner of Strawberry Way and Smithfield Street. The church opened as a temporary shelter last winter for those without accommodations. Despite its June closure, many still gather on its wide concrete steps day and night.
A bystander captured video footage of the arrest, which ended in drug and assault charges against 32-year-old Jashon Martin.
The review board did not rehash the incident or the video during their virtual meeting Tuesday night; rather, they voted without objection to investigate that incident along with several others that had been referred to them in recent months.
The video, which was shared widely on some social media platforms, appears to show Martin struggling with the five or six officers attempting to handcuff him while he repeats that he’s done nothing wrong. Later, when Martin is prone on the ground, an officer appears to punch him in the face several times while another appears to strike him with his knee.
The arrest has since been deemed “objectively reasonable under the law” by Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto.
Read More
According to the charges filed against Martin, officers were surveilling the area on Smithfield Street and near Mellon Square “due to numerous and ongoing complaints from business owners and area stakeholders regarding open air illegal narcotics use and distribution, violence and general quality of life crimes such as littering and public urination/defecation.”
They first spotted Martin about 6 p.m. fighting with another man near Mellon Square, investigators wrote. They saw him again about 90 minutes later, dressed in different clothes and with a hood pulled over his head — a sign police took to mean he was trying to conceal his identity.
His body language and gait, police claimed, indicated to them he was armed and looking for the main he’d fought with earlier.
According to the complaint, Martin made his way toward the Smithfield Street church, where police said they saw him buy suspected marijuana from two teenagers and then sell suspected crack cocaine to two separate people over the course of a few minutes.
Police moved their unmarked car toward the church, got out and announced themselves, investigators said. They attempted to grab Martin in a bear hug.
From there, police alleged, Martin refused to be handcuffed, struggled with officers and “repeatedly attempted to reach to the front waistband area of his body.”
Officers wrote that they believed Martin was reaching for a weapon and “delivered a closed fist punch.” Martin allegedly bit one officer, who then “delivered more closed fist punches,” according to the complaint. Investigators did not mention any other use of force in the complaint.
Once Martin was in custody, police said they found a knife on the ground where the struggle had occurred.
Magisterial District Judge David J. Barton released Martin on nonmonetary bond the same night he was arrested, court records show. A preliminary hearing is scheduled for Oct. 10.
The arrest sparked outcry from community leaders who, in a joint statement the day after the incident, called for an investigation and the release of all body camera footage.
“The videos circulating on various platforms vividly depict a scene where the officers employed extreme and unjustifiable force, raising serious questions about the proportionality of their actions as well as violation of impeding the right of the public to video record,” the statement read.
The call for action and accountability came from Daylon Davis, president of the NAACP’s Pittsburgh branch; Tim Stevens, chairman of the Black Political Empowerment Project, and Brandi Fisher, president of the Alliance for Police Accountability.
Mayor Ed Gainey, in response to the backlash, created another community-led task force to address the issue. It will be called the Sentinel Review Task Force, and it will review police use of force incidents.
The mayor’s task force will be made up of residents, experts and public safety personnel to discuss “what policies may need to be changed in order to best serve the public,” Mr. Gainey said.
“This type of partnership can only work if the community has the trust of our officers, and that officers have the trust of the community,” he said. “And that we're building mutual respect to ensure trust is established.”
Beth Pittinger, executive director of the Citizens Police Review Board, said at the Tuesday meeting that she’d been asked to serve on that board.
“As it’s evolved and some of the facts have emerged from that particular incident and some of the practicalities related to any review of anything related to police, it seems that it has come to be more of an advisory committee to the chief,” Ms. Pittinger told board members.
She said she has been clear in her message to the city and police administration: “Don’t even think about undermining the board’s authority.”
The CPRB was created in 1997 through a referendum amending the city’s Home Rule Charter. Its place in the city is established in the charter and “that’s not something just anybody can do.”
“They don’t have any power to review incidents, investigate individual officers, there is no suggestion they would be receiving complaints — that’s just not in the cards,” Ms. Pittinger said. “They are not a disciplinary board.”
In fact, she noted, the city has no disciplinary board. The CPRB can investigate complaints and make recommendations, as can the city’s Office of Municipal Investigations, but any final disciplinary action is done by the police administration.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.