Jurors have decided that Robert Bowers is eligible to be executed. Now they must decide whether he will be.

The decision to send the Pittsburgh synagogue shooter to death row must be a unanimous one. It took the jury in his case less than two hours to weigh two weeks of testimony and agree unanimously last week that he should be considered for death. The decision was guided by and based on set factors that prosecutors, in this case, clearly proved, as evidenced by the verdict.

In this third and final phase of Bowers’ trial, jurors will not be bound by law, but rather their own individual moral decisions.

“They’ve been given definitions on this and that and the other thing, but right now, it really becomes a moral judgment,” said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense attorney now teaching at St. Vincent College.

Advertise with us

In the sentence-selection phase, which starts Monday, prosecutors will make their case for the death penalty, allowing shooting survivors and family members to offer victim-impact statements — that is, how immeasurably and irrevocably the shootings and the deaths have impacted their lives.

Bowers’ defense team will try to save his life.

“What you have left is going to be a very difficult thing for them,” Mr. Antkowiak said. “Just doing more psychiatric evidence, I don’t know if it is going to make that much more of a difference.”

This last phase is where Bowers’ childhood and background information will come in, but even that will be an uphill battle for the defense.

“It will have to be stacked up in juxtaposition to the testimony that’s going to be coming of the relatives of the people who died and the impact that their death has had,” he said. “That is going to be, and it always is, very compelling.”

Advertise with us

More than four years have passed since Bowers stormed the synagogue at the corner of Shady and Wilkins avenues Oct. 27, 2018. Three congregations were in the midst of Shabbat services: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and Night Light.

Eleven worshippers were killed: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.

While the upcoming stage is where the defense team will present mitigating evidence in a bid to spare Bowers’ life, they spent the three-week eligibility phase giving jurors a glimpse of the case they intend to put on.

The bulk of the testimony focused on Bowers’ brain and its functions, but the defense team did touch upon his childhood and home life. Records already entered into evidence paint a portrait of a withdrawn and sometimes violent child whose mother struggled to properly care for him, causing resentment that continued into adulthood.

The family was first reported to child services in 1973 after Bowers’ mother allegedly threatened to throw a 6-month-old Bowers out of a third-floor window. His father also allegedly turned the gas on in their apartment and threatened to kill himself and the child, according to social services paperwork.

Advertise with us

His biological father killed himself in 1979, though he and Bowers’ mother had been divorced for years by then.

Several records note a suicide attempt by Bowers when he was 10.

Weeks after his 13th birthday, in September 1985, he was admitted to McKeesport Hospital for “violent behavior at home,” according to the intake form. That included putting lighter fluid on his mother and threatening to set her on fire.

The same paperwork noted that he had “done some dangerous things in the past such as jumping off of a high altitude.”

He was at McKeesport Hospital until Oct. 9, 1985, when he was transferred to Southwood Psychiatric Hospital’s adolescent unit.

Advertise with us

On Nov. 22, 1985, he was transferred again, this time to the Bradley Center, for aggression and fire-setting. He was withdrawn and fearful, according to records. He wasn’t released until June 1986.

When he was 16, he was sent to St. John’s Hospital after his mother called police to report he was “exhibiting hostile, violent, frightening behaviors.” He also threatened to shoot himself in the head. At some point in late 1989 or early 1990, he was committed to St. Francis Hospital because of “repeated suicide attempts,” according to a police report from the time.

“I think what is afoot here has been an effort from the defense side to take a long look at this case,” Mr. Antkowiak said.

Attorneys for Bowers knew the guilt phase of the trial would be filled with horrifying evidence from the prosecution, and they knew how that would make their client look in the eyes of the jury.

Mr. Antkowiak said defense witnesses and testimony so far represented an effort to try to overcome all of that collective evidence: the horror of the crime, the premeditation, the lack of remorse.

Advertise with us

What the defense wants to get across to the jury, he said, is that “this is really reflective of a deep pathology that should be considered as a mitigating factor in that it’s not the product of just inherent evil, it is the product of an inherent deficiency of mind that should not lead to the ultimate punishment of death.”

Mr. Antkowiak said jurors will think about their decision for the rest of their lives.

“I don’t think these people are going to want to do this out of a sense of vengeance or out of a sense of personal revenge on behalf of the families,” he said. “They’re probably going to be trying to focus on the broader picture of what does this act, in all of its manifestations, represent?”

His explanation is one that prosecutors have alluded to numerous times over the course of the trial: There are some crimes that are so heinous, so abhorrent, that they cross a line that society has drawn and there is no punishment outside of death that could truly reflect society’s rejection of it.

“And that, ultimately, I think, is what is going to be going through a lot of the heads of those jurors,” he said. “Is this the case wherein we have to say no, we have to say this is not right — this is not going to happen in our society, in our world, period?”