An order to reinstate a Pittsburgh police officer who was fired last year after being accused of sexually assaulting a co-worker was upheld in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.

Judge Alan Hertzberg issued the order April 20 agreeing with an arbitrator that Aaron Fetty should be permitted to return to his position. It was not immediately clear if the city would appeal the judge’s decision.

The decision came almost two years after the city’s Office of Municipal Investigations in 2021 received an anonymous complaint detailing an alleged sexual assault.

According to court documents, the assault occurred after several officers, including Mr. Fetty and the alleged victim, went to the bar after a police cookout.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fetty then drove his co-worker home “where he allegedly perpetrated an indecent assault upon her,” documents read.

The Office of Municipal Investigations examined the claims, but found they did not meet criteria established in the PA Crimes Code, Indecent Assault. They did find, however, that Mr. Fetty’s actions violated the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police’s rules on unbecoming conduct and truthfulness.

The city charged Mr. Fetty with violating the rules. They reached an agreement with Mr. Fetty and the Fraternal Order of Police that he would serve a three day suspension without pay, enter into a five year last chance agreement for sexual harassment and be transferred to a different zone.

During this time, Allegheny County Police also investigated the incident. No charges were filed.

On Dec. 30, 2021, the victim sent a bureau-wide email alleging she was sexually assaulted by Mr. Fetty.

Advertise with us

That same day she was granted a temporary order for protection of victims of sexual violence against Mr. Fetty. During a hearing last March, the judge who issued the order for protection found a “preponderance of evidence” that she was a “victim of sexual violence and at a minimum Fetty committed the act of sexual assault,” according to court documents.

Based on new information from the email and the judge, the city again charged Mr. Fetty with violating rules on unbecoming conduct, truthfulness and conduct toward superior officers and other employees.

He was suspended for five days, pending termination. Mr. Fetty was officially fired Sept. 27.

He appealed the decision and the police union filed a grievance.

On Nov. 17 three arbitrators held a hearing and ordered the city to reinstate Mr. Fetty to pre-termination pay and duties as soon as practical and to make up all lost wages.

Advertise with us

The city then filed a statutory appeal against the order in December, appealing to Judge Hertzberg.

Federation of Police President Robert Swartzwelder said decisions made by arbitrators are not typically appealed unless somebody’s constitutional rights were violated or there’s an irregularity in the proceedings. None of those factors, he said, occurred during Mr. Fetty’s hearing.

“The city, when they don’t like an outcome they’ll just appeal it anyway because it’s not their money, it’s the taxpayer’s money,” Mr. Swartzwelder said.

Once the decision was appealed, however, Judge Hertzberg heard arguments from both sides and reviewed recording from the arbitrator hearing to make sure there were not any violations, Mr. Swartzwelder said.

“All he does is uphold the decision of the arbitrator because he’s not allowed to retry the case,” Mr. Swartzwelder said.

The mayor’s office did not respond to a request for comment.