After hearing closing arguments from the prosecution and defense on Wednesday in the trial of Christian Bey, accused of fatally shooting an off-duty Pittsburgh police officer, the jury has begun deliberations.
Deputy District Attorney Stephie-Anna Ramaley argued key DNA testing, surveillance footage and other evidence point to Bey being guilty of killing Calvin Hall, while the defense argued there is reasonable doubt, saying police rushed the case and were biased against Bey since it involved the death of one of their own officers.
The closing arguments came a day later than expected after Bey reportedly wavered on his decision not to testify. This is the second trial for Bey, as the first was ruled a mistrial after a prosecution witness revealed his prior criminal history.
Bey, 34, allegedly shot and killed Hall in the summer of 2019 while the off-duty cop was visiting friends at a home on Monticello Street, the same area where a block party was happening. Prosecutors say the shooting stemmed from an argument Hall, 36, was involved in with several partygoers.
Bey’s attorney Carmen Robinson painted the scene as a chaotic “family affair,” in which potentially “tons of people” and several guns were involved. She said police rushed the case, and said Hall was the one agitated and waving his gun at people.
Ms. Robinson called back to body cam footage from that night showing Pittsburgh police Sgt. Tiffany Klein-Costa, one of the early responders to the shooting. She was seen talking to other officers questioning how Hall’s gun ended up in his car, as his body was found with an empty weapon holster. She said that gun may have been placed there by someone on the scene after Hall was shot.
Read More
“What doesn’t fit, we question,” she said.
Ms. Robinson also focused on one of the witnesses, who she said gave police a “generic description” of the suspect, a “Black man” in “dark clothes.” Ms. Robinson said the witness had ultimately identified him by “thick eyebrows.” The witness later said she could have seen Bey’s photo on social media, Ms. Robinson said.
She went on to criticize the private consulting firm that conducted the DNA analysis on the gun that killed Hall, claiming their results were not “definitive.”
She also contested the integrity of time stamps found on surveillance video at a bar, which Bey claims he was at the time of the shooting. That footage placed Bey at the bar hours after the shooting.
Deputy District Attorney Stephie Ramaley asked the jury to focus on what is important, “the physical evidence.”
“Physical evidence doesn’t lie,” she said.
Ms. Ramaley pointed to the three bullets and three cartridge cases found, as well as a stolen 45 caliber gun, which in DNA on the slide and trigger matched to Bey. She said the gun was found in an alleyway near his residence.
The three gunshots to Hall’s back shows a “specific intent to kill,” Ms. Ramaley said. She described expert testimony that claimed these shots came in from his back through the front of his body. This indicated that the victim’s back was to the apartment when he was shot.
Ms. Ramaley said “neutral” witnesses, neither of whom knew Bey or Hall, provided descriptions that matched Bey and footage from that night.
She claimed the defense’s witnesses, including Bey’s mother, “assassinated” Mr. Hall’s character.
“Do you really think a young Pittsburgh police officer would risk his career by pulling guns in an argument with drunk young women?” she said.
She urged the jury to “use common sense” in making their determination.
“This case is about good police work,” she said. “These officers follow the evidence. Now it’s your turn.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.