An Italian heritage group that fought for two years to keep the Christopher Columbus statue in Schenley Park said it will appeal a judge’s ruling that city officials can remove monument at their discretion.

Attorneys for the Italian Sons and Daughters of America have argued that the mayor alone cannot “unilaterally override a duly enacted ordinance” – that ordinance, in this case, is the one passed by city council in 1955 clearing the way for the Sons of Columbus to erect and install the statue.

The 800-pound statue of the 15th-centruy explorer and colonizer was built in 1958.

“The Pittsburgh Home Rule Charter is clear that some rule-making authority is reserved for City Council, and the mayor must comply with those rules once enacted,” said George Bochetto, a Philadelphia-based attorney leading the ISDA movement to keep the statue in place.

Advertise with us

Common Pleas Judge John McVay Jr. ruled Friday that because the statue is in a city-owned park, it represents government speech.

Judge McVay relied heavily on previous case law from the U.S. Supreme Court. The 2009 ruling arose when the city of Pleasant Grove, Utah, rejected a monument proposal for a city park from a religious group.

Mr. Bochetto said that because an ordinance was passed in order to erect the statue, that ordinance must in turn be repealed in order to remove it.

“Based on the court’s ruling, the mayor can put up or take down any statue he wants on any city-owned property without regard for other branches of the city government,” the ISDA argued. “Obviously, this cannot be correct.”

The group also appealed a previous decision by Judge McVay not to recuse himself from the case. Attorneys representing the ISDA moved for Judge McVay to recuse himself in November 2020, accusing him of authoring an order “that promotes an inaccurate recitation of history and improperly contextualizes this lawsuit in history, casting Christopher Columbus in a bad light” – something attorneys argued made them question the judge’s impartiality.

Advertise with us

“While acknowledging that historical figures are people and necessarily come with heroic qualities along with character flaws, nonetheless racism slavery and prejudice must always be condemned and rejected by our city,” the order in question read. “Discrimination has and continues to exist. Indigenous people and the immigrants who followed have all unfortunately shared that experience, none of which should be acceptable to a community striving for better.”

Attorneys for the ISDA said Judge McVay’s refusal to recuse himself “constitutes a grounds for a reversal.”

“We believe that Judge McVay clearly misinterpreted the law,” said ISDA National President Basil M. Russo, noting he believes the appeal will fall in their favor. “The Columbus statue in Schenley Park is symbolic of the Italian immigrants’ contributions to the growth and success of the city of Pittsburgh, and we will not give up our fight to preserve that history.”

The ISDA and its attorneys filed the lawsuit in October 2020 following a vote by the Pittsburgh Art Commission to remove the statue from the park, and then-Mayor Bill Peduto recommended its removal as well.

Judge McVay had, throughout the two-year saga, urged the two sides to work together to find a solution — perhaps, he’d suggested, relocating the 13-foot statue to a different yet public location. He continued to urge them to work together in his opinion.