A Highland Park woman has filed a civil lawsuit against PetSmart, alleging the pet superstore killed her dog while grooming him at an East Liberty location two years ago.
A.J. Ross, 36, filed the suit in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court last month.
Last year, four PetSmart employees were charged with aggravated cruelty to animals in connection to the incident. Two of them — store groomers Elizabeth J. Doty, 22, of Shadyside, and Julie A. Miller, 29, of Pittsburgh — still have active criminal cases against them.
Ms. Doty and Ms. Miller are also named as defendants in the civil complaint.
Ms. Ross alleges in her lawsuit that she obtained surveillance footage of the November 2020 grooming that shows PetSmart employees putting two tethers around the neck of her dog, Kobe, who was already wearing a muzzle. That caused Kobe to asphyxiate and die, Ms. Ross alleges, as Ms. Doty and Ms. Miller ignored his “obvious distress and panic” as he struggled.
“No one from PetSmart appeared to have any knowledge or training about what to do under the circumstances, and there was no effort made to resuscitate the dead or dying Kobe,” the lawsuit reads.
No attorneys for the defendants were listed in civil court dockets. A lawyer representing Ms. Miller in her criminal case declined to comment.
A representative for Ms. Ross could not be reached Tuesday.
In a statement, PetSmart said it was “heartbroken by and truly sorry for the loss of Kobe.”
“Following this terrible accident in 2020, we immediately launched an internal investigation and cooperated with the authorities involved,” the statement reads. “In response, we terminated the associates who violated our pet safety policies and did not meet our high standards of care. We proudly perform more than 13 million grooming services per year and the actions of these two associates do not represent the standard of care provided by our more than 10,000 salon associates.”
The suit accuses Ms. Miller, Ms. Doty and PetSmart of negligence and intentional infliction of emotional distress. It also charges PetSmart with one count of negligent hiring, supervision and retention in addition to violating trade practices, fraud and deceit.
Ms. Ross, in her lawsuit, says she would have stayed with Kobe during his grooming but was not allowed due to COVID-19 restrictions put in place by the store.
Upon returning to the store about 10 minutes after leaving the dog, Ms. Ross saw that he was unresponsive. Store employees said he “passed out and went limp,” the lawsuit reads. It was after “persistent inquiries” that she came back to the location the following month and viewed the surveillance video.
A PetSmart spokeswoman had said in May 2021 that the store “terminated the responsible associates” but did not clarify who was let go.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.