Four PetSmart employees are facing criminal charges after a dog died during a grooming at the East Liberty store in November.

Two groomers — Elizabeth J. Doty, 21, of Shadyside, and Julie A. Miller, 26, of Pittsburgh — are charged with two counts of aggravated cruelty to animals after a dog died while its neck was tethered in two places during a nail trimming, according to a criminal complaint.

Also charged are Shaphan D. Stonge, 37, of Ross, and Heather A. Rowe, 32, of Pittsburgh, two store “leaders” who each face one count of aggravated cruelty to animals.

The incident occurred on Nov. 17 when A.J. Ross, 35, took her dog — a toy poodle named Kobe — to the store for a nail trimming. Ms. Ross, of Highland Park, said the dog became nervous when his nails were trimmed and she asked the employees if she could remain in the grooming area with him. Her request was denied because of COVID-19 precautions, she said.

Advertise with us

Angela M. Fry, a Humane Society police officer, wrote in the criminal complaint that she viewed surveillance video from the store that showed Ms. Doty taking Kobe back to the grooming area. The video shows Ms. Doty securing the dog to a table with a grooming tether.

When Kobe’s neck hyperextended, Ms. Miller appeared at the table to provide assistance by holding the dog’s hind end, the complaint reads. Ms. Doty then secured a second tether around Kobe’s neck and began trimming his nails.

About 11 minutes and 42 seconds into the video, Kobe can be seen struggling, and his head was frequently shaking, Ms. Miller wrote in the complaint. Ms. Doty “briefly” looks at the dog’s head twice before resuming the trim.

The dog then tried to roll to the right while all four of his paws came off of the table and were suspended in the air, the complaint says, while Ms. Miller held his hind end. The dog continued to struggle in that position for 45 seconds. Ms. Doty attempted to correct his position on the table, but the dog continued to struggle.

At 14 minutes and 21 seconds into the video, the dog’s front paws are suspended over the table while Ms. Miller continues to hold the dog from the back, causing Kobe’s neck and body to hyperextend, according to the complaint. The groomers continued in that position for approximately 15 to 20 more seconds until the dog ceased to move.

Advertise with us

The dog could be seen with its neck supporting its entire body weight, Officer Fry wrote. Ms. Doty placed the dog on the table, removed the tethers and looked in the dog’s mouth to make sure his tongue was not blocking his airway. She began rubbing the dog and shaking it, but he remained unresponsive.

Ms. Rowe and Ms. Stonge enter the grooming area about three minutes after the dog stopped moving, the complaint says. They talked to Ms. Doty and Ms. Stonge began to rub Kobe’s body.

Looking for dog treats, Ms. Ross heard the call for a manager to enter the grooming area over the intercom. “I asked the clerk, ‘Is something wrong?’ Why would they ask for a manager to enter the grooming area?” Ms. Ross said.

“And she’s assuring me, like, ‘Oh, it’s probably nothing,’ but my intuition is like flaring at this point that something isn’t adding up here.”

Ms. Ross then entered the area and saw the employees looking at her motionless dog. She was told the dog had fainted, she said. She picked up Kobe and drove her dog to the nearest veterinarian, Banfield Pet Hospital, where Kobe was pronounced dead after unsuccessful attempts at CPR, the complaint says.

Advertise with us

The defendants did not have any attorneys listed, and attempts to reach them were unsuccessful. They are scheduled for a preliminary hearing on Oct. 4.

“We are heartbroken by and truly sorry for the loss of Kobe,” PetSmart said in response to questions. “After this terrible accident, we launched an internal investigation and found unintended failure to adhere to our pet safety processes.”

A PetSmart spokeswoman said the store “terminated the responsible associates” but did not clarify who was let go.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter @MickStinelli