The judge presiding over the capital case of accused Tree of Life shooter Robert Bowers says he doesn't have to question Mr. Bowers in person to make sure he understands that he has been waiving his rights for more than three years.

U.S. District Judge Robert Colville on Thursday denied a request by the U.S. attorney to order Mr. Bowers to appear to confirm that he knows that his defense team has been waiving his right to a speedy trial and his right to be present for all proceedings.

The judge said it isn't necessary.

"The Court is of the opinion that an in-person colloquy is not warranted, indeed, is not required," he said.

Advertise with us

He said Mr. Bowers' lawyers have shown their "deep appreciation and understanding" of their obligations in the case and there's no reason to question their representations.

The prosecution team had said in its motion that it wasn't challenging the competency of the defense but wanted to head off any future appeals based on his absence.

Mr. Bowers is accused of killing 11 worshippers at the synagogue in October 2018.

He appeared briefly after his arrest and for an arraignment. But other than that, he's never appeared in federal court in person or by video.

He waived his rights to appear through his lawyers for every proceeding, including a two-day suppression hearing in October and an inspection of the physical evidence at an FBI building.

Advertise with us

Prosecutors said questioning him in person will assure the judge and everyone else that Mr. Bowers' waivers have been voluntary.

But Judge Colville said he won’t do it.

Mr. Bowers faces the possibility of a death sentence if convicted. The defense team is seeking a plea deal that will spare him execution.

He is the fourth defendant to ever face potential federal execution in the Western District of Pennsylvania.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com