A federal judge on Friday said accused Tree of Life shooter Robert Bowers should be tried in Pittsburgh, rejecting his lawyers' attempt to get the case moved to another federal district.

U.S. District Judge Robert Colville, who recently took over the case from Judge Donetta Ambrose when she retired, said that the defense motion for change of venue is not warranted.

"Under applicable standards, the publicity at issue does not present the type of relentless, saturating, and blatantly prejudicial exposure that warrants the relief sought," he ruled.

He said the defense cannot show that careful questioning of potential jurors wouldn't be sufficient to seat an impartial jury.

Advertise with us

He said the issue might be revisited later if circumstances show that juror impartiality has been compromised.

The judge said publicity has diminished in the three years since the 2018 attack. A review of newspaper stories shows that the "initially feverish media attention has cooled markedly over time," he said. Many of the stories are event-directed and factual, he said, such as those describing court proceedings. Others refer to the attack only in passing.

Judge Colville also noted that defense motions to suppress material covered by the media, such as Mr. Bowers' statements at the scene and his social media comments, have been denied by Judge Ambrose.

"While one would not describe the publicity as advantageous to defendant, it falls far short of the grossly damaging coverage present in cases in which a change of venue was constitutionally required," the judge ruled.

The decision is another victory for the U.S. attorney's office, which argued that Mr. Bowers can get a fair trial in Pittsburgh. The defense, prosecutors said, "has not met the rigorous legal standard for this Court to find presumptive pretrial jury prejudice within the Western District of Pennsylvania."

Advertise with us

The defense team had argued that pre-trial publicity, as measured by newspaper accounts and a phone survey, has created a "presumption of guilt."

The defense team had hired a jury expert to search newspaper accounts and came up with more than 1,000 stories from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review and other papers.

The lawyers said the coverage portrayed Mr. Bowers as a "hate-filled, violent person who promoted anti-Semitic and anti-immigrant extremist views shared by others on the far-right of the political spectrum."

The expert also did a phone survey to determine the impact of the publicity on a potential jury pool in Pittsburgh, Harrisburg, Philadelphia and Washington, D.C. The expert said 92% of the prospective jurors in the Pittsburgh region knew about the case and thought Mr. Bowers is guilty.

Prosecutors countered that moving any federal trial is an extraordinary step and not warranted in this case. They cited other high-profile cases, such as the Boston Marathon massacre trial, that were held in the districts where the crime occurred.

Advertise with us

The prosecution team said the jury pool in the 13-county Pittsburgh division, with a population approaching 3 million, is large and diverse enough to produce an impartial jury.

The team also said the defense's reliance on the phone survey is suspect because so few people responded. Of 25,623 call attempts, the survey obtained only 400 interviews, a response rate of 1.6%.

Mr. Bowers faces the federal death penalty if convicted of killing 11 worshippers at Tree of Life in October 2018.

The Justice Department is seeking to execute him. Mr. Bowers' lawyers want a plea deal to spare him death. The trial is set for this summer.