Two years after George Floyd was murdered by a Minneapolis police officer and protests sprouted across the nation, changes have come to the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, but calls continue for more.
The bureau has faced both scrutiny and applause as the shockwaves that followed Floyd’s killing and the local protests that followed continue to ripple throughout the city.
Mayor Ed Gainey, who has said his election campaign was partially inspired by the racial justice protests that were held, said he believed Floyd was an inspiration.
“I believe that he was a seed that was planted,” Mr. Gainey said in an interview this week. “We didn’t bury him, we planted him, and in planting him, what we were able to do was talk about – nationally – police reform. And the fact that we’re still talking about police reform today is amazing.”
Mr. Gainey said continuing police community relations was something on which the city would have to work on daily. He declined to say what policies his administration was working on to improve those relations.
But an incident in Pittsburgh’s Bloomfield neighborhood last year brought a fresh focus to the issue.
Jim Rogers, a 54-year-old Black man, died after police used a stun gun on him multiple times during his arrest for the alleged theft of a bicycle.
That eventually led to multiple officers being fired, most of whom are arbitrating the terminations.
The incident, which occurred a month before Mr. Gainey was elected, tested the bounds of the mayor’s ambitions for reform just months after he took the oath of office. The firings were hailed by activists as a major step forward, but there was also frustration following the process, particularly with the confidentiality that surrounded the discipline because the officers were not publicly identified.
Maria Montaño, Mr. Gainey’s spokeswoman, said after the firings that they revealed the scope of what discipline outlined by the police union’s collective bargaining agreement requires.
“For a lot of us, we got an education as to what this process actually looks like and how patient we have to be in this process in order to discipline folks,” she said in March.
The decision to fire the officers shows a step in the right direction for the bureau, said Beth Pittinger, the executive director of the Citizen Police Review Board.
“I think it took a degree of courage and a break from professional tradition,” she said.
Traditionally, the bureau has “dragged its feet” in cases involving officer misconduct, Ms. Pittinger said, and terminating the officers sends an internal message about the standards to which police will be held.
“The chief recommended termination, and that is a very encouraging step, because it was clearly an egregious incident that occurred,” she said.
But she also cautioned that a county grand jury investigation, which will determine whether the officers face criminal charges, and the arbitration by the police union will impact the broader view of how Rogers’ arrest impacted police reform in the long term.
A yearlong audit released this week by City Controller Michael Lamb also suggested several recommendations on how police can improve police-community relations and safe interactions with the public.
Developing formal policies on arresting people with small amounts of marijuana, which is decriminalized in the city, and screening officers for involvement in extremist groups were among the changes suggested by the report.
Speaking Tuesday, Mr. Lamb said the community response to Floyd’s killing is what created the discussion that led to the audit of the police bureau.
“The reason around it came right out of that nationwide and communitywide response to George Floyd and other police issues around the country,” he said. “I think there’s no doubt that without that uproar – righteous uproar – we would not have gotten to this model of doing this kind of audit.”
City council last year passed a bill to end traffic stops for minor violations, and police had already reduced the number of such interactions prior to the legislation, the bureau’s recently-released annual report shows.
The change was applauded by Tim Stevens, chairman and CEO of the Black Political Empowerment Project, as “a positive first step, but only ... a first step.”
Ms. Pittinger said she thinks there has been more attention paid to the relationship police have with the community as caretakers and law enforcers.
“I think we’ve seen both legislative and administrative reaction to the community’s demands for attention to police practices and an awareness of reforms, at least an effort to assess what those reforms should be,” she said.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.