Responding to findings from the Venango County district attorney, the attorney representing the family of a Pittsburgh man shot and killed there in December said Monday that he expects a federal indictment after viewing evidence that had recently been presented.

“We have — since the district attorney’s statement — we have ourselves come into possession of a number of pieces of really important evidence, some strong evidence. We do expect and believe an indictment will be forthcoming on the suspect,” Paul Jubas said Monday.

Mr. Jubas said that due to the ongoing investigation, he could not “get into details” about what this new evidence includes.

The U.S. attorney’s office in Pittsburgh could not be reached Monday after Mr. Jubas’ late-afternoon news conference.

Advertise with us

Earlier in March, Venango County District Attorney Shawn White said 29-year old Peter Bernardo Spencer had been acting erratically and threateningly, and that under the Pennsylvania Stand Your Ground Law, his killing was a justified act of self-defense.

As a result, no charges would be filed in this case, Mr. White said.

But Mr. Jubas says the Stand Your Ground law doesn’t apply to this case.

“The Stand Your Ground law doesn’t apply if criminality was involved, and there was a lot of criminality involved [in this case],” he said.

He wouldn’t detail what he meant by “a lot of criminality involved” but said that “it’s clear that the suspect was involved in the same stuff that the district attorney is alleging that Mr. Spencer was involved in, which disqualifies him from the self-defense claim.”

Advertise with us

A witness told investigators that while the group was sitting around a fire, Spencer — who had been drinking, smoking marijuana and taking psychedelic mushrooms — started acting erratically and shooting his AK-47 assault rifle in the air.

A toxicology report confirmed that Spencer had consumed alcohol, marijuana and psychedelics, but it also showed Spencer had fentanyl in his system.

“It appears as though these mushrooms that were provided by Witness No. 1 were laced with fentanyl,” Mr. Jubas said. “It is entirely possible that he was drugged. There’s a lot of possibilities.”

Throughout the night, Spencer continued sporadically shooting his assault rifle and demanding his companions build the fire bigger. The shooter told police that he believed Spencer intended to kill the group, and he fired all the rounds of his handgun at Spencer, according to Mr. White.

“There are nine wounds, and five of them are wounds that struck Mr. Spencer in the back,” said Dr. Cyril Wecht, who was hired by the family to do a private autopsy.

Advertise with us

At Mr. White’s news conference on March 15, he said seven of the wounds found on Mr. Spencer’s back were exit wounds and that the others were likely caused by him falling as he was killed.

“I’m not giving you my interpretation,” Dr. Wecht said as he read from the autopsy report done by the Venango County coroner outlining where each of the five gunshot wounds was found on Spencer’s body.

Mr. White had announced that the Pennsylvania State Police Heritage Affairs Section determined that there was no evidence of racial bias on behalf of the shooter or any of the witnesses, all of whom are white, while Spencer was Black.

However, Mr. Jubas said the state police acted as more of a “middleman” and gave “no actual oversight” in the Venango County investigation.

Spencer’s family was not present at the news conference Monday afternoon, but Mr. Jubas said they are “completely confident” in a federal investigation and are feeling “optimistic.”

Advertise with us

Mr. White could not be reached for comment Monday evening.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com