A federal judge on Friday refused to grant a temporary restraining order that would force students and staff in the Upper St. Clair School District to wear masks again.

U.S. District Judge William Stickman IV said in a 32-page opinion that granting the request would "damage the independence and authority of the school board" and place the recommendations of the Centers for Disease Control "beyond their appropriate level of authority and to the exclusion of local, democratic authority over matters of prudential judgment."

The ruling is the exact opposite conclusion reached by a fellow judge on the federal bench in Pittsburgh last week in a similar case brought by the same lawyer, Ken Behrend.

U.S. District Judge Marilyn Horan ordered that full masking resume in the North Allegheny School District, starting last Monday.

Advertise with us

In both instances, a small group of at-risk students and their parents sued to reverse decisions by school boards to allow optional masking.

In the Upper St. Clair case, the board voted Jan. 10 to make masks optional starting this coming Monday.

The suit had said the vote put five "medically fragile" students in jeopardy and violated the Americans with Disabilities Act. It was the same claim raised in the North Allegheny case. In both instances, the plaintiffs said the board's action forced parents to make the "unfair and unjust" decision of whether to pull their children from school or face the risk of exposure to the virus.

"The board's vote neither accounts for the fact that transmission rate of infection from COVID-19 was still in the 'High' category on January 10, 2022, and that it continues to dramatically increase because of Omicron, nor that universal masking is essential to the prevention of the spread of this airborne disease," the suit says.

Judge Stickman, who heard the argument Thursday, said he was sensitive to the positions of both sides and the "strong feelings" generated by masking in schools.

Advertise with us

He also said he believes the arguments on both sides were made in good faith.

But he said the local school board was the ultimate authority.

"Prudential judgments about policy are left to the people," he said, "through their elected officials."

Mr. Behrend, the plaintiffs' lawyer, said he would file an emergency appeal with the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Judge Stickman was nominated to the federal bench in Pittsburgh by former President Donald Trump in 2019.

Advertise with us

Judge Horan was first nominated in 2015 by former President Barack Obama, but Republican senators refused to debate or vote on judge nominee confirmations, and her nomination expired in 2017. She was nominated again by Mr. Trump in 2017 and confirmed by the Senate in 2018.

Judge Stickman has been in the middle of controversial COVID matters before.

He made national news in 2020 after he ruled that parts of Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf's stay-at-home and business closure orders to control COVID-19 violated the U.S. Constitution.

He made the ruling in a lawsuit brought by four Western Pennsylvania counties and several Republican state lawmakers who argued that the governor's orders violated the First Amendment and the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment.

The 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals later dismissed Judge Stickman's ruling on the grounds that it was moot because statewide mitigation efforts had expired and state voters had since restricted the governor's emergency powers.