Everyone in the North Allegheny School District will have to wear a COVID mask starting tomorrow, a federal judge ruled Monday.
U.S. District Judge Marilyn Horan granted a temporary restraining order, requested last week by a group of at-risk students and their parents, that masks be mandatory again as they had been in 2020-21 and the fall of 2021.
The judge said she wished she had more time to decide, but school resumes tomorrow so she entered the order following a zoom hearing held despite the federal holiday.
The judge said the district has to reinstate its mask policy so long as the virus transmission rate remains high in Allegheny County.
"The district will be required to enforce it," the judge said.
She said she hopes to issue a written order later today.
Read More
The students and their parents filed the suit a week ago under the Americans with Disabilities Act and asked for an injunction to force the school board to reverse its December vote to allow optional masking.
The defendants are the district and the school board, which had voted 5-4 on Dec. 8 to allow parents to decide if their children should wear masks despite the recent surge in omicron infection rates here and across the United States.
Instead of following the recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control and other health professionals, the board majority "arbitrarily and capriciously" decided to eliminate the district's universal mask policy and put everyone at risk, according to the suit.
Lawyers for the district argued that the issue doesn't require an emergency injunction since the plaintiffs waited a month since the vote was taken to file the suit. They also said the district has extended the deadline for at-risk students to enroll in cyber classes if they choose and included a link to do so to every student, so the student needs are being met.
In addition, they said the plaintiffs haven't been able to establish that they will suffer harm if the optional mask policy is not rescinded. One of the requirements for granting an injunction or restraining order is proof of immediate injury or harm should it not be granted.
The judge sided with the plaintiffs, who are four children and their parents described as medically fragile. Their medical issues are not described in detail, although one child's immune system is compromised and all the children have disabilities that carry an increased risk from COVID as defined by the CDC, according to the suit.
The suit named the entire school board as defendants, although only five of them voted to make masks optional: Richard McClure, Elizabeth Blackburn, Marcie Crow, Vidya Szymkowiak and Shannon Yeakel.
Those who voted against are Britton Dozier, Paige Hardy, Kevin Mahler and Elizabeth Werner.
"The parents of the immuno-compromised disabled children are very pleased that the federal court has entered a temporary restraining order protecting their children from the decision of a majority on the North Allegheny School Board to eliminate universal masking in the face of the surge of infection caused by Omicron," said Ken Behrend, one of the lawyers for the plaintiffs, in an email. "As the federal court noted, what has changed from the board's vote on September 22, 2021 requiring universal masking?"





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.