The North Allegheny school board has changed the masking policy for the third time this school year.

The board voted 5-4 Wednesday to “strongly recommend” masks, but not make them mandatory, when the state mask mandate ends.

It changed a plan that was adopted with bipartisan support on Sept. 22. That plan would have kept masks mandatory if the spread of COVID-19 in Allegheny County was either “substantial” or “high” and optional if the spread was “moderate” or “low.” The county is in the “high” range of COVID-19 spread. That plan changed one from August that had overruled the superintendent’s mask mandate.

Board members Elizabeth “Libby” Blackburn, Marcie Crow, Vidya Szymkowiak, Shannon Yeakel and board President Richard McClure voted for the change. All are Republicans.

Advertise with us

Leslie Britton-Dozier, Paige Hardy, Kevin Mahler and Elizabeth Warner, all Democrats, voted to keep masks mandatory.

A companion motion to require masks for five days upon returning to a school that had to close because of a COVID-19 outbreak failed, with only Mr. McClure and Ms. Warner voting in favor.

Mr. McClure noted that Gov. Tom Wolf said the state’s mask mandate will end on Jan. 16, while the second half of the school year begins on Jan. 18. By making the decision now, parents who do not want their children to attend school in person will have time to enroll in the North Allegheny Cyber Academy, he said.

“The landscape has changed since last fall. Vaccinations are now available for all of our student population,” Mr. McClure said.

Superintendent Melissa Friez said the district has held six COVID-19 vaccination clinics and is working with Giant Eagle on a seventh after winter break. Officials will also help families find vaccine providers for their children.

Advertise with us

She said 96% of NA’s staff was fully vaccinated, as well as 77.3% of high school students and 53.6% of middle school students. Just 2.4% of elementary students are fully vaccinated, though the vaccine for children 5-11 was just approved last month.

More than 200 residents attended the virtual meeting Wednesday, and approximately 50 parents and students spoke on the issue for three hours.

The comments, as in previous meetings, centered on two points: keeping students safe amid a global pandemic vs. the rights of parents to make health decisions for their children.

Sarah Hall said the motion was “clearly a political stunt,” as Mr. McClure and Dr. Szymkowiak, as well as two Republican candidates who were not elected, took funds from a political action committee that supported in-person learning and optional masks.

“Why risk more lives? How many lives are enough? There will certainly be more spread and more quarantining and more school closures,” she said, adding that her youngest child was exposed to COVID-19 by five different people in five days. Masking is “not perfect,” she added, “but it works.”

Advertise with us

Melissa Jackman said the motion gave parents “a say in the health and safety of our children.”

“Somewhere along the line, we have lost our way as a society. It is not normal for children to wear masks or sit 6 feet apart at lunch,” she said. “When does this end?”

Some parents who oppose mandatory masks said children do not wear them properly, pulling them up and down and chewing on them. Brittany O’Donnell said she saw photos of many children not wearing their masks properly in photos on the McKnight Elementary School Facebook page.

But eighth grader Sophie Leslie said the majority of the 800 students in her school wear their masks properly. “We are the people affected by what you are debating tonight. … Please vote to protect us.”

Victoria Klaus countered that wearing masks is interfering with children’s education. “They cannot read facial expressions and are having problems with reading.”

Advertise with us

Katie Schmidt, a teacher and mother of two, including one too young to be vaccinated, called masks a “highly effective mitigation strategy.”

“There will be a time when the rates fall. There will be a time to hand that decision back to individual families. That time is not now. I interact with masked students every day. It does not make an impact.”

Many of those who spoke in favor of continuing the masking policy were health care professionals, and some pleaded with Dr. Szymkowiak, an internist, to uphold the mask policy.

Dr. Szymkowiak said district policies must change when circumstances do, noting that, prior to the start of the pandemic, North Allegheny banned alcohol-based hand sanitizers. She added that the Allegheny County Health Department only recommends indoor masking but does not mandate it.

The other new board members, Ms. Hardy and Ms. Britton-Dozier, spoke against changing the policy.

Advertise with us

“I have serious concerns that this motion would result in more quarantines,” Ms. Hardy said. “It’s just too soon to make a change like this. It’s just too big a risk.”

Ms. Britton-Dozier called masks and vaccines “tools that we can use to help stop the spread,” adding that North Allegheny has not had any shutdowns this year and has had a reduction in the number of students quarantined.

“If it is not broken, don’t fix it,” she said.

Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.