The North Allegheny school board Wednesday approved a change to the health and safety plan on masks, to take effect when the state mandate is lifted.
Under the plan, which passed 5-4, masks will be required when the community spread in Allegheny County is high or substantial, and optional when the spread is low or moderate.
“Generally speaking, what’s happening in NA is also happening in the county,” said board member Kevin Mahler.
Mr. Mahler, along with Allyson Minton, Scott Russell, Elizabeth Warner and board President Andrew Chomos voted for the change. Libby Blackburn, Marcie Crow, Richard McClure and Shannon Yeakel opposed it.
A motion to table the item until the state mandate is lifted failed 4-5 with the same lineup of votes.
“I think this is about the best plan we can come up with that will meet the needs of both sides,” Mr. Chomos said, noting that the spread was in the low to moderate ranges in the summer when the original plan was formulated, making masks optional.
Read More
Mrs. Blackburn said that the district should not use Allegheny County’s spread as a guide but should just focus on what is going on in the North Allegheny schools.
“I don’t want a bunch of people who aren’t in the district or aren’t school-age children” determining whether a mask is necessary, she said. “I don’t think we should be linked with the City of Pittsburgh.”
But Mr. Mahler and Mr. Russell said that just looking at the schools leaves out parents and other adults in the district who commute to work in Pittsburgh.
“The reason it is called 'community spread’ is that people of all ages can spread to each other. This is about the community, not just students,” Mr. Mahler said.
On Wednesday, there were 513 new cases of COVID-19 reported to the Allegheny County Health Department. Of those, 67 were in children 12 and under.
The meeting was moved to 5 p.m. to accommodate many residents who signed up to speak and was held virtually because some attendees last month refused to wear masks. The Aug. 25 meeting was never convened because of the maskless attendees. At the time, the district was under a federal court order requiring masks. That order expired Wednesday.
At times, more than 300 people were tuned into the meeting. Sixty-seven people spoke, including more than a dozen medical professionals.
“The way masks really protect us the most is by preventing the people who have COVID from spreading it. Universal indoor masking is the only solution that makes sense,” said Dr. Mark Jablonski. “I am all about personal freedom and personal choice except when that choice can hurt others… It impacts my child, and it is no longer about your personal freedom anymore. Make the decisions based on public health, not public hysteria.”
Dr. Sylvia Choi, a pediatrician at Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh noted that the hospital’s capacity has been strained. “We have never been so busy this time of year,” she said. “As we do our part on the front lines … we need everybody else to do their part as well.”
Dr. Alisha Miller, a family practice physician, said that a person with the delta variant can infect five more people, double the amount from the original strain. There were 110 children under age 12 diagnosed with COVID the entire month of July and 152 children in two days this month, she said. “As physicians, we swear first to 'do no harm.’ We know that having children unmasked in school will cause harm. Would any of us volunteer for our child to be the one lost?”
Other parents who are not physicians urged the board to listen to the health experts.
“Unfortunately, there has been this culture war that has been pushed by the politicians and pundits. Please listen to the experts about health and safety,” said Joel McManus.
Many parents also opposed the mask mandate, citing their freedom to raise their children as they want.
Jessica Patterson said her special needs child is struggling with wearing a mask. “Each child is unique in their circumstances,” she said. “The choice should be put back in the hands of parents.”
Victoria Klaus said her son is “exhausted” at the end of the day because of wearing a mask. “We are watching you and God is watching you, too. Stand strong against the tyrannical decisions made by the government and (Superintendent Melissa Friez). Please stop this ridiculous behavior and follow the American Constitution.”
Matt Marcenelle said that the COVID survival rate for those under 19 is 99.997%. “You potentially have a better chance of being eaten by a great white shark in Western Pennsylvania than dying of COVID.”
“This is about freedom of choice. This is about raising our kids in a free country,” said Eddie Scherer. “Stand up and do what’s right. Doctors do not speak for the majority of people.”
Two high school sophomores also spoke, one on each side of the issue. Andrew Romanchik said he will submit a petition containing the signatures of 260 students asking that masks be optional. Sreeja Meda said that wearing a mask has been nothing more than a “minor inconvenience.”
“Is wearing a mask more traumatic than having loved ones die? Is it more traumatic than being quarantined? Is it more traumatic being in constant pain? I would rather wear a mask every day for the rest of my life than relive that pain (of loved ones who had COVID),” Sreeja said.
Also speaking was freshman Brandie Sunday, who said she was “appalled at the direction my school district is going in. …I’m vaccinated, but many of my fellow students are not vaccinated. And I’m scared.”
Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.