Officials and advocates are expressing concern about a recent spate in deaths at the Allegheny County Jail and a lack of information being shared on the circumstances surrounding those deaths.
At the Oct. 7 Jail Oversight Board meeting, members held a moment of silence for three people who had died in the custody of the jail in the month of September.
Two days later, the county medical examiner reported the death of another incarcerated person. Paul Allen, 55, of McKeesport, “became unresponsive” at the jail and was taken to UPMC Mercy Hospital, where he was pronounced dead on Oct. 9.
“Allen requested medical assistance and walked to a gurney for transport to the jail’s medical housing unit. Medical staff determined he needed further treatment and he was transported to a local hospital,” Warden Orlando Harper said in an email.
On Sept. 12, a 48-year-old man died of COVID-19 at the hospital. The identity of that man, Robert Harper, had not been made public until the Post-Gazette contacted jail administration for further information.
In an email that day notifying the oversight board of Robert Harper’s death — without giving his name — the warden said that he was “hospitalized since late August and was unvaccinated.”
Read More
Vinckley Harris, 48, of Duquesne, became unresponsive at the jail and was taken to UPMC Mercy, where he died on Sept. 20. Mr. Harris had not been committed to the jail but was awaiting arraignment when he experienced a medical emergency, according to an email from the warden, Mr. Harper.
Justin Brady, 38, of Pittsburgh, died after being transported from the jail to the hospital on Sept. 23. He was still in intake when he experienced a medical emergency, the warden said.
Aside from Mr. Harper’s death from COVID-19, the causes of death for the other three men have not been released by the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office or by the jail administration.
“This is a systemic problem,” said Bethany Hallam, an Allegheny County Council member and a member of the oversight board.
Earlier this year, 55-year old Martin Bucek was found unresponsive by jail staff and taken to UPMC Mercy Hospital, where he was pronounced dead on July 3.
The county’s medical examiner released his cause of death on Oct. 8, saying he died of “asphyxia due to airway obstruction” by food.
For each death that occurs among a person who is in custody of the jail, the Allegheny County Police conduct a formal investigation, Mr. Harper said during the Oct. 7 oversight board meeting.
“Per the county police, there is nothing suspicious about any of the deaths, but like with any unexpected death, they will await the final cause and manner of death from the Medical Examiner’s office in the cases where that office took jurisdiction,” Mr. Harper said in an emailed statement.
The jail also does an internal review to determine “if any improvements need to be made to processes and procedures,” the warden added.
Ms. Hallam noted that though the oversight board had been notified of each of the deaths, the information given was scarce.
This lack of information is an example of a transparency issue, according to other members of the board.
“I think just in terms of a larger trend, I think that we see that transparency is really not [the jail’s] strong suit,” said Chelsa Wagner, the county controller and a member of the oversight board.
She went on to say that since Judge Kim Berkeley Clark — the Jail Oversight Board president — has requested the board be notified of jail deaths, it has “seemed more regular” but isn’t always the case.
“I know that I will hear from other sources and then sometimes from the media things that I have not yet heard, or maybe never do hear, from the jail,” Ms. Wagner said.
Ms. Hallam echoed that sentiment and said, “That should not be the case whenever the jail is funded by taxpayer dollars.”
“Notification of the death of any inmate at the jail is made, first and foremost, to their next of kin. This may be done by the hospital, the Medical Examiner’s office, or the chaplain at the jail. Once that occurs, general information on the death is provided to the Jail Oversight Board, and any identification of the inmate is provided to the media by the Medical Examiner following its protocols and procedures,” Mr. Harper said.
Only deaths ruled a suicide are reported via news release “for transparency reasons,” he added.
“No death is acceptable, and every death is tragic,” Mr. Harper said in an emailed statement. “Death is also a part of life and to expect that there would not be any deaths at the jail isn’t realistic.”
Even though county police do an investigation into every death at the jail, that information is seldom, if ever, shared with the oversight board, which makes it hard for them to understand the circumstances, according to Ms. Wagner.
“There certainly are going to be some deaths that are not preventable. But I think without detail it’s hard for us to really make that determination as to whether this was something that should have been prevented or not,” she said.
However, organizations like the Abolitionist Law Center, a Pittsburgh-based nonprofit law firm that litigates cases dealing with human rights violations in prisons, feel that these deaths “reflect a larger issue of ongoing and intentional neglect.”
“Our position is that these deaths that have taken place under Warden Harper and County Executive Rich Fitzgerald are not random or by coincidence,” said William Lukas, the communications director for the Abolitionist Law Center.
In light of these issues, Ms. Hallam has asked the Allegheny County Council to consider getting a majority of members together to pass a resolution to begin an investigation into the jail.
“It’s a power of council that is rarely used,” she said. “Council actually has a subpoena power and investigatory powers where a majority of council could vote to approve subpoenas and investigations into any county entity, including the jail.”
In the meantime, she thinks more unannounced visits to the jail by the oversight board could be a first step in improving the jail.
“When I went for my first visit a few weeks ago, they knew we were coming,” Ms. Hallam said. “It’s very frustrating to feel like the county administration is intentionally putting up obstacles for transparency in the jail.”
The Jail Oversight Board is required by statute to make at least two unannounced visits each year and write a report about the findings. Due to the pandemic, these visits had been put on hold until recently.
“Aside from Allegheny County Jail being abolished in its entirety, I do think that there needs to be a radical change in management,” Mr. Lukas said. “Without these changes in leadership, I think every person trapped inside ACJ is another potential death to be reported on.”
Mr. Lukas also suggested that investigations into the practices of the jail, like the one Ms. Hallam mentioned at council, would be a good place to start improving conditions.
As far as the oversight board goes, Ms. Wagner said that she believes they should hold executive session meetings, where they could go in depth over incidents like the recent deaths.
“I do think we’ve gotten a lot of good things done over the past year and a half,” Ms. Hallam said. “But it’s such a mess that it will never be a problem that is solved for as long as the Allegheny County Jail has its doors open.”
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.