A Beaver County man convicted of first-degree murder was sentenced Wednesday to life in prison, despite an attempt by the defense to have the judge declare a mistrial.
Sheldon Jeter Jr., 23, of Aliquippa, was sentenced by Beaver County Common Pleas Judge Kim Tesla after he was found guilty last month of killing 30-year-old Tyric Pugh, who lived with the defendant.
Michael Santicola, Jeter’s attorney, made a motion before sentencing asking for a mistrial after he said one of the jurors lived next door to a slain cyberschool teacher who had sexual relations with Mr. Jeter when he was still a teen.
The teacher, Rachael DelTondo, was killed in her parents’ front yard three years ago. Although no one has been charged in her death, Jeter was frequently cited by authorities as a person of interest in the case because of his relationship with DelTondo.
The juror in question lived at the home next door and, Mr. Santicola argued, would not have been impartial due to her proximity to the DelTondo case.
But the judge denied that motion, saying much of Mr. Santicola’s claims were based on hearsay. The judge pointed out that the attorneys made the decision not to ask potential jurors about their knowledge of the DelTondo case during jury selection.
Read More
“After sitting through trial, there is overwhelming evidence to support the jury’s conclusion that he is guilty of first-degree murder,” Judge Tesla said when he denied the motion.
In his argument, Mr. Santicola said the notoriety of the DelTondo case —which gained national attention in an episode of the CBS television show “48 Hours” — meant it was known by nearly everyone in Beaver County, and it happened “just a few feet from where this juror lived.”
Public property records appear to show that the victim’s parents live next door to the residence where Ms. DelTondo was killed.
Because of that, the juror should have answered “Yes” when asked if anyone close to her had been a victim of a crime. Mr. Santicola also claimed that his office was told that she was discussing the case outside the courtroom with other jurors and her family — something that is prohibited during the trial.
But prosecutors said the allegations presented by Mr. Santicola were based on nothing more than “second-, third- or fourth-hand information.”
There was “no indication of any juror bias in this case and no reason not to go forward with sentencing today,” Beaver County Assistant District Attorney Jordan Colalella told the judge.
The judge agreed, calling the defense’s claims “hearsay upon hearsay,” criticizing an allegation, made without specific evidence, that the woman was discussing the case with another juror during a conversation outside the courtroom.
“They could have been talking about the weather for all we know, and I’m not going to grant a mistrial for that,” he told the defense.
Judge Tesla said he would leave any further matters to post-trial motions, which Mr. Santicola said he intends to file. If post-trial motions do not lead to a mistrial, he plans to appeal.
Two relatives of Mr. Pugh also gave witness statements prior to the final sentencing. Layla Willis, his younger sister, said he had been like a father figure to her.
“It’s been a little over a year now, and I’m still in shock and disbelief,” she testified. “I will never see my older brother again.”
His mother, Delma Pugh, thanked the prosecuting attorneys for their work on the case.
“I walk around day to day with a hole in my heart,” she said. “I have days where I cry for long periods and cannot control, and cannot stop, my tears.”
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.