A juror in the case of a convicted Beaver County man indicated during jury selection that she may have had familial ties to the defendant through her husband.

According to court transcripts, the juror — who would become Juror No. 3 in the trial of 23-year-old Sheldon Jeter Jr. — told attorneys and Beaver County Common Pleas Judge Kim Tesla during voir dire that her husband may have been related to Jeter. Voir dire is when potential jurors are examined and selected to serve in the trial.

Jeter was convicted last week of first-degree murder in the shooting death of 30-year-old Tyric Pugh, who lived with Jeter and his grandfather in Aliquippa.

The juror, who the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is not identifying, became a concern to the defense when they learned after the trial that she was a neighbor to Rachael DelTondo, the slain teacher who had relations with Jeter when he was a teen.

Advertise with us

The DelTondo homicide has garnered national publicity as it remains unsolved. No one has been charged in connection to it, but Jeter was investigated, as were other men with whom DelTondo had relationships.

Defense attorneys did not question Juror No. 3 about DelTondo during voir dire because it is a separate case, and the woman did not mention the teacher’s killing during her examination with the judge, the prosecution and the defense. But she did say that Jeter “might be family” with her husband.

“You don’t personally know [Sheldon] Jeter?” Judge Tesla asked her, according to the transcript.

“No, but I know the last name,” the then-prospective juror replied, explaining that she believed her mother-in-law is a Jeter.

“So you may be related to the Jeter family,” the judge said.

Advertise with us

“Not me, yeah, my husband’s, that’s all,” she said.

The woman said she knew nothing about the case against Jeter in regards to Pugh’s killing. She also said “no” when the judge asked if there had been “any discussions at family meetings” about the case.

Jordan Colalella, the assistant district attorney who prosecuted the case, followed up on the subject after the judge finished his questions.

“So you indicated that, obviously you don’t personally know Sheldon Jeter,” he said, according to the transcript. “Do you ... know anybody in his family, anything like that?”

“I mean, if I track that information probably, but I don’t know nothing,” she told him, prompting the judge to remind her that she was not to obtain any outside information about the case and was only to decide based on sworn testimony if she was chosen.

Advertise with us

Mr. Colalella also asked if she had seen Jeter or his family at a family reunion setting or if such a meeting was going to happen in the coming weeks, to which she replied “no.”

He also reminded her that the jury’s verdict would have to be unanimous, so people would know how she voted. “Would the fact that you may have these tangential connections to that family, would that be something that would be bearing on your mind or that would prevent you from being a fair juror in this case?” he asked.

“No, sir,” she replied.

Randall McKinney, one of the attorney’s on Jeter’s defense, had no questions for the woman. Mr. McKinney and Mr. Colalella told the judge she would be an acceptable juror.

The defense assumed prosecutors would strike the woman or remove her from the jury pool because of her comments during voir dire, defense attorney Michael Santicola said Wednesday.

Advertise with us

“In hindsight, who knows what she would’ve said if additional questions were asked,” Mr. Santicola said, saying he didn’t give the situation much thought beyond thinking that she might be a good juror for the defense.

Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier declined to say anything about the juror on Wednesday. “I won’t comment because we don’t have a motion to respond to,” he said.

Judge Tesla, through his secretary, also declined to comment, citing ethical reasons that prevent him from speaking about a pending case.

That the woman was apparently related to Jeter was not a problem for Mr. Santicola or his team, he said, but her being a neighbor to DelTondo at the time of her killing is the issue.

“The fact that one of her husband’s family members may have been related to a Jeter — there’s lots of Jeters — is one thing,” he said. “To live next to the DelTondo family is another.”

Advertise with us

The teacher, who was killed outside her parents’ home in May 2018, was mentioned by other potential jurors who did not make it onto the jury. One man said he was friends with DelTondo’s aunt, the transcript says.

“So, of course, there is a lot of stuff on Facebook, and her probably talking to my wife,” he told the judge. “I’ve heard things here and there, but.”

Those comments led to challenges from both Mr. Colalella and Mr. McKinney, causing his removal from the pool.

Not only did he have knowledge of the case, Mr. Colalella said to the judge, but also “it’s the fact that he kind of runs in these circles where he’s heard people talking about it, and I do think ... that that would give rise to cause.”

Another potential juror was challenged after saying she had heard about the DelTondo case, in addition to concerns about police officers testifying. She told attorneys that “it’s ingrained in you, like, you’re just supposed to trust a police officer. That’s just the way I was raised,” and that she was only “90%” sure that she could impartially judge testimony from law enforcement.

Advertise with us

Mr. Colalella told the judge he didn’t think that comment “is going to cut it in the eyes of the Superior Court.”

“And, second, just her, her kind of wealth and knowledge about the DelTondo case is concerning for the commonwealth,” he continued.

Mr. McKinney said he agreed.

Two other people were challenged during the process because of their knowledge of the teacher’s killing, the transcript shows.

Mr. Santicola said he has not yet decided how to proceed with the information that the juror was a neighbor to DelTondo. He said he thinks his one opportunity may be to make a motion of extraordinary relief, where the judge could decide whether the potential legal problem is enough to delay the sentencing, acquit Jeter or order a new trial, depending on what the defense requests.

Advertise with us

Jeter is set to be sentenced on July 21 for Pugh’s killing. Under Pennsylvania law, he faces life in prison without parole.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli