Jury deliberations in the trial of a Beaver County man accused of killing his close friend will continue into Wednesday after attorneys wrapped up their closing arguments Tuesday.

Sheldon Jeter Jr., 23, of Aliquippa, is facing first-degree murder in connection to the death of 30-year-old Tyric Pugh in May 2020.

Beaver County Common Pleas Judge Kim Tesla recessed the jury until Wednesday at 9 a.m. after they began deliberating Tuesday afternoon.

Prosecutors focused their case on evidence that puts Mr. Jeter near the scene of the crime on Kiehl Street in Aliquippa just before Mr. Pugh’s body was found by passersby, in addition to ballistics evidence that they say connects the murder weapon to a handgun owned by Mr. Jeter.

Advertise with us

“There was no time for anyone else in the area to have committed a homicide,” prosecutor Jorden Colalella told the jury. “Just Sheldon.”

The defense has emphasized that the two men were so close that their relationship was almost familial, with Mr. Pugh living with Mr. Jeter. And there appears to be no motive for why Mr. Jeter would kill such a close friend when they were laughing and eating ice cream together that same night.

Defense attorney Randall McKinney compared the prosecution’s case to the junk room in his old family home: stuffed with useless items and toys to keep the rest of the house looking tidy.

“It’s like our living room,” he told the jury. “It’s neat and orderly. And then the junk room opens up upon cross examination.”

But Mr. Colalella, a Beaver County assistant district attorney, rebutted that metaphor, saying that Mr. Pugh’s killing was “personal” and there was no evidence that someone killed him in a robbery.

Advertise with us

“[The defense] want to say that the commonwealth is shoving this junk evidence into a room, and we’re doing that to pin this case on Jeter,” he said. But the real reason Mr. Jeter became involved with the case is because his home was on Mr. Pugh’s ID as his address, Mr. Colalella said, and police showed up to make a death notification to family.

While at that home, police overheard Mr. Jeter on the phone saying that Mr. Pugh had been shot — a detail that police had not yet disclosed, Mr. Colalella said. But the defense claimed that Mr. Jeter was smart enough to put the pieces together before police explicitly told him that his friend was killed.

Other evidence, like gunshot residue found in the vehicle Mr. Jeter was driving that night, also came into the mix. Defense attorneys said that evidence could have come from their client handling a gun belonging to his brother, a police officer, or from investigators who entered the car while taking it in for examination.

Prosecutors, meanwhile, said the brother testified that he had never seen Mr. Jeter use one of his firearms, and police used gloves and a blanket to preserve the integrity of the vehicle as a potential piece of evidence.

The trial has been going on since June 10. Both sides rested around 10:20 a.m. on Tuesday.

Advertise with us

Mr. Jeter gained national attention prior to this case due to his romantic involvement with a slain Aliquippa schoolteacher, Rachael DelTondo, whose 2018 homicide remains unsolved. The 33-year-old was a teacher at Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School, but was suspended when she was found in a car with a teenaged Mr. Jeter, who was one of her students.

No arrests have been made in that case, and Mr. Jeter’s attorney has denied any involvement in the homicide by his client.