The defense attorney for a Beaver County man convicted of homicide will seek a mistrial following concerns that a juror was connected to a slain Aliquippa school teacher with ties to the defendant.

Sheldon Jeter Jr., 23, of Aliquippa, was found guilty of first-degree murder last month in the 2020 killing of 30-year-old Tyric Pugh, whom he lived with.

Jeter’s defense attorney, Michael Santicola, claimed he learned after the trial that one of the jurors was a neighbor of Rachael DelTondo, a cyber school teacher killed outside her parents’ house three years ago.

While no one has been charged in DelTondo’s death, Jeter has been investigated and was found to have had a sexual relationship with the woman while he was still a teen, according to leaked police documents.

Advertise with us

An investigation by Mr. Santicola’s office confirmed that the juror lived next door to the home where DelTondo was found dead, the attorney said Tuesday, leading to concerns about her ability to be impartial in Jeter’s trial.

Public property records appear to show that the house is owned by the juror’s parents.

“I think it’s logical to think that they followed that case, that they were paying attention to the investigation, that they were following the media coverage, that she knew Sheldon Jeter’s name, she knew he was a person of interest in that case,” Mr. Santicola said. “And that’s something we think should have been revealed.”

Court records show that the juror was not asked about the DelTondo case during jury selection and did not mention that she was a neighbor to the family. Mr. Santicola said she should have answered affirmatively when asked if someone close to her had been a victim of a crime — a standard question for all potential jurors — since DelTondo was killed so close to her home.

Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier, whose office prosecuted the case against Jeter, was not immediately available for comment Tuesday afternoon.

Advertise with us

“If it is true that this juror ... was not impartial, and the things that we believe are true happened, then I think there would be an obligation to grant a mistrial because justice would not have been served,” Mr. Santicola said.

He also alleges that his investigation has revealed the juror was talking about the case with family members while the trial was going on, something Beaver County Common Pleas Judge Kim Tesla warned the jury not to do.

Mr. Santicola said he plans to make an oral motion asking for extraordinary relief at Jeter’s sentencing, which is set for Wednesday, and expects an evidentiary hearing will prove his allegations and lead to a mistrial.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli