A jury on Wednesday found a Beaver County man guilty of killing his friend last year.
Sheldon Jeter Jr., 23, of Aliquippa, was found guilty of first-degree murder in the killing of his 30-year-old friend Tyric Pugh in May 2020.
Police and prosecutors said Jeter gunned down Mr. Pugh on Kiehl Street in Aliquippa after the two went out for ice cream. The men were living together with Jeter’s grandfather.
The jury was socially distanced throughout the courtroom for much of the trial but requested to be together in the jury box as the foreperson read the verdict.
When the guilty verdict was read, there were gasps and cries of “Oh, my God” from the gallery. Jeter, clad in a purple button-up shirt and a blue medical mask, hung his head while the jurors confirmed that they agreed with the verdict.
Jeter is scheduled to be held at the Beaver County Jail without bail until his sentencing on July 21. He could face life in prison without parole.
Read More
The trial began on June 10 and closed Tuesday, with prosecutors focusing heavily on the evidence collected in the aftermath of the shooting, including security footage of Jeter driving near the scene just before the body was found and ballistic evidence that appeared to match his handgun.
Defense attorneys aimed at poking holes in the case, pointing out that there was no apparent motive for Jeter to have killed such a close friend and questioning the exhibits displayed by prosecutors.
“There were implications by the defense that there were shortcomings on the part of the investigation,” Beaver County District Attorney David Lozier said. “I think the jury answered that question quite sufficiently.”
Mr. Lozier praised the job done by investigators to collect and preserve evidence on the night of the killing.
“They presented that evidence diligently to the jury in an honest manner, and it defeated the defense’s attempts to sway and bring in doubt,” he said.
Throughout the trial, defense attorneys questioned the decision by police to drive Jeter’s vehicle when taking it in for analysis, especially because there was gunshot residue found inside the door that was used to connect Jeter to the shooting. But prosecutors maintained that the officers had worn gloves and laid down a blanket on the seat to avoid ruining the integrity of the potential evidence.
Defense attorneys declined to comment immediately after the trial. Jeter’s family also turned down requests for comment.
Jeter is also known for his connection to Rachael DelTondo, the cyberschool teacher from Aliquippa who was found shot to death outside of her parents’ home in May 2018. DelTondo was alleged to have had a romantic relationship with Jeter when he was a teen.
No one has been arrested or charged in the DelTondo case.
On whether Wednesday’s conviction would have any impact on the DelTondo case, Mr. Lozier would not say.
“Today is Tyric Pugh’s day. We’re going to stick with that,” he said.
The DelTondo case has received national attention not just because it remains unsolved but because of DelTondo’s romantic connections with Jeter. The relationship was the focus of an episode of CBS’s “48 Hours” in 2019.
Hours after the special aired, Jeter was found unconscious in a street in Aliquippa. His attorney said at the time that his client had passed out after a night of drinking.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.