Allegheny County Common Pleas President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark in a letter pinned to the court’s website called for the country’s top court and Allegheny County courts to ensure the development of a justice system that not only promotes equality but also ensures equity.
Judge Clark, who presides over the 5th Judicial District of Pennsylvania, said she felt the need to “consciously and publicly” address a waning confidence in the criminal justice system, amid growing evidence that Black people are at a greater risk of death at the hands of police. She said Black people are also more likely to languish in the child welfare and juvenile system than white people.
Her statements are in response to the “overdue” acknowledgement and celebration of Juneteenth, which was established as a national holiday last week, and the deaths of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor by police, she said. She is the first African American to serve as president judge in Allegheny County and has held the seat since 2018.
“As a former prosecutor, lawyer and judge, I take pride in the American system of justice, including the Constitutional protections that all citizens are afforded,” Judge Clark wrote. “I still have faith in our justice system, and I am particularly proud of the justice system here in Allegheny County. We are well-respected throughout the United States, and we are never satisfied with doing things the way we have always done them.
“We continue to work to improve our system of justice by making data-informed decisions, by implementing best practices, and by working collaboratively with law enforcement and other stakeholders.”
Having experienced Allegheny County’s foster system firsthand, Jerry Dickinson, a candidate for a U.S. House seat in District 18 and a constitutional law professor at the University of Pittsburgh, said the judge’s acknowledgement of disparities in the child welfare system “hit a nerve,” but in a good way, due to the fact that she mentioned it.
Read More
An underlying notion in Judge Clark’s letter is the reality that Pittsburgh is home to the nation’s darkest racial disparities — and these are disparities the justice system perpetuates, he said. Recent studies have shown that Pittsburgh’s Black residents could move to almost any other U.S. city of comparable size and have a better quality of life, according to a 2019 Gender Equity Commission report.
“I grew up in a foster home with a number of children here, so I know firsthand how the system disadvantages people of color,” Mr. Dickinson said Wednesday. “[Judge Clark] is a person of power, and we need people in power to step up and speak the truth. There are plenty of instances of state and federal judges who have spoken up about racial injustices in the system.”
Mr. Dickinson highlighted Judge Theodore McKee, chief judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit in Philadelphia, who has been a vocal advocate for criminal justice reform and has spoken about the balance between individualized treatment of defendants and consistency in decision making, among other systemic issues. Mr. Dickinson said Judge Clark joins a select number of judges who are willing to speak up.
“In many ways, this will hopefully inspire folks to take note and hopefully make change,” Mr. Dickinson said.
Democratic state Rep. Ed Gainey of Lincoln-Lemington — who recently made history as the first Black man to win a mayoral primary election in Pittsburgh — said he applauds Judge Clark’s leadership in acknowledging the history of injustice that people of color, women, the LGBTQIA+ community, low-income people and other historically disadvantaged groups have faced.
“Taking advantage of that opportunity will require changes to the administration of our courts, the policies and operations of our police departments, and our laws governing use of force, sentencing, and cash bail,” Mr. Gainey said. “I look forward to partnering with Judge Clark and other leaders across our region and the entire Commonwealth to pursue those reforms and build a more just and equitable future for the people of Pittsburgh.”
In her letter, Judge Clark added that in order to truly achieve justice, “the proverbial scales of justice must be balanced.” She called for the 5th Judicial District to “rise to this generational challenge,” recognizing there is an uneven playing field for ethnic minorities and those who do not squarely fit into traditional gender roles, other disadvantaged persons.
According to Beth Pittinger, executive director of Pittsburgh’s Citizen Police Review Board, Judge Clark's statement was “stunning,” and “right on time” in light of recent events in Allegheny County. She specifically pointed to Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr.'s decision earlier this month to amend a policy he set in place to cease plea deals with the clients of Black defense attorney, Milton Raiford. Mr. Zappala’s decision was in response to Mr. Raiford’s criticism of the DA’s office and the criminal justice system as being “systematically racist.”
“[Judge Clark] is right. I agree with her. The change that everyone wants to see has to be systemic. It's not just police. It's not just judges. It's the whole entire process,” Ms. Pittinger said Wednesday afternoon.
“If we reflect on what happened with the county district attorney and the retaliation behind that, these are things that make the public pause and say what is this? These are not things we want to see from the highest elected law enforcement official in the county. Her call for examination is quite appropriate. We can't change any of it unless we change all of it by holding the people accountable for administering these services and the basis for which their decisions are made.”
Ms. Pittinger commended city police for taking “overt steps” to address police relations in the community.
“Twenty years ago, Pittsburgh police were thumpers,” she said meaning officers that never progressed in rank due to an inherent nature to never stop crime. “You look at it today, and you have a whole unit of police walking all over the place, trying to understand what’s going on, and yet we've got the community killing each other. Judge Clark was right on target. We've got to look at the entire system.”
Despite cries for social justice from the community, Robert Swartzwelder, president of the Fraternal Order of Police Fort Pitt Lodge No.1, on Wednesday declined to comment directly about Judge Clark’s letter. He said, “My initial thoughts on Judge Clark's letter is that it is her opinion and that it’s based on her experiences.”
Activists in Pittsburgh in 2019 called for Mr. Swartzwelder to be fired after a grand jury accused the union president of impeding investigations of two police-involved shootings. The grand jury did not recommend criminal charges against Mr. Swartzwelder or anyone else in the police bureau.
According to Mr. Swartzwelder, police perspective on the use of force is driven by four standards, and “deeper conversations” are necessary when it comes to changing the law and systems that govern police use of force.
Those standards include the constitutional standard under the United States Constitution; the state law standard, which is covered by the Pennsylvania crimes code; the administrative standard that is governed by a plethora of police departments across the state and country; and the community standard, which is based on community perspective.
“Oftentimes, the community standard is driven by traditional and social media,” Mr. Swartzwelder said. “When traditional and social media are outweighed by constitutional standards, state standards and administrative standards as established by agencies, it starts to become problematic, and the community wants to believe that the problem is much more widespread.”
He said he believes there could be flaws in the way the community views the justice system but noted “that's why we have to have deeper conversations.”
“If we want to change the mission of law enforcement, the only cautionary tale that I ever give is this: Whatever entity that you're going to replace law enforcement with to handle that type of situation, they have to be properly funded, properly staffed for a 24-hour, seven-days-a-week, 365-days-of-the-year response, and they have to be able to respond in a timely manner,” he said.
Although certain systemic issues remain unaddressed, Allegheny Courts have been working to address racial and ethnic disparities and systematic racism in the justice system, Judge Clark said.
“We have made progress, but the struggle is ongoing,” she said in her letter.
Judge Clark pointed to these items as examples of progress:
• Utilization of the PA Detention Risk Assessment, which has reduced the number of juveniles held in pre-trial detention;
• Utilization of the Youth Level of Service/Case Management Inventory to help identify the risk factors for recidivism;
• Utilization of diversionary programs to prevent entry into the juvenile justice system;
• Establishment of a robust Department of Pretrial Services of Allegheny County;
• Utilization of treatment courts (Mental Health Court, Drug Court, Veteran’s Court, PRIDE Court) to divert individuals from incarceration to treatment;
• Establishment of Housing Court to reduce evictions, and improve judicial access through a Help Desk;
• Implementation of a Language Access Plan to promote equal access for limited or non-English speakers and deaf/hard of hearing court users;
• Fostering collaboration between Magisterial District Judges and community stakeholders;
• The MacArthur Safety and Justice Challenge with a focus on meaningfully addressing the racial and ethnic inequities in the justice system;
• The significant reduction of the population in the Allegheny County Jail and the continued efforts to reduce the population;
• Implementation of Anti-Discrimination and Implicit Bias Training consistent with the 5th Judicial District’s Non-Discrimination and Equal Employment Opportunity Policy that prohibits all forms of discrimination because of race, color, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, national origin, age, disability, or religion;
• Prompt investigation and redress of Non-Discrimination and EEO Policy violations to ensure that all individuals including employees, applicants for employment, litigants, witnesses, jurors, and court volunteers are treated in a dignified, civil, respectful and non-discriminatory manner;
• Collaboration with the University of Pittsburgh Institute of Politics, the Allegheny County Executive and the Allegheny Department of Human Services to address criminal justice reform.
Lacretia Wimbley: lwimbley@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1510 or on Twitter @Wimbleyjourno.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.