Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. responded Thursday to criticism that he directed his office to cease plea deals with a Black defense attorney who criticized his office and the criminal justice system as racist.

The controversy stems from an email Mr. Zappala sent to his office in May saying they were not to make plea offers to defense attorney Milton Raiford after he criticized the justice system and the DA’s office as “systematically racist” after a trial.

The email also stated that withdrawing charges against any of Mr. Raiford’s clients would have to be approved by the “front office.”

Mr. Zappala’s statement late Thursday afternoon said he sent the email in response to Mr. Raiford’s statements that his office was “making different plea offers based on skin color and ‘doubling down’ on plea agreements.”

Advertise with us

The email was also in response to Mr. Raiford’s statement to the court that he would not go “for those crazy plea agreements,” Mr. Zappala wrote.

“In order to ensure that this office makes consistent, evidence based decisions, and avoid false claims of racism against this Office and its Assistant District Attorneys, I took seriously that attorney’s stated desire not to accept plea offers, and directed my Deputy District Attorneys to memorialize any plea discussions with this attorney and not to offer pleas to that attorney without approval from the front office,” his statement reads.

The comments came after a May 13 trial in front of Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani, Mr. Raiford told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, because of pent-up frustrations exacerbated by the murder of George Floyd and the subsequent social unrest.

Mr. Raiford said he thought there was a lack of action by figures in the Allegheny County court system to address racial inequities in Pittsburgh.

“What I said on that particular day is nothing that I haven’t said every day to somebody for the last several years, in terms of the systemic racism that exists in Pittsburgh particularly, and the criminal justice system of which I am a part,” Mr. Raiford said.

Advertise with us

He said the emails show that Mr. Zappala is exerting control over the criminal justice system, and he believes his clients are now being denied due process.

“I’ve had clients that have called me yesterday and said, ‘I think I’m going to get another lawyer now because this guy is not going to offer you any plea deals.’”

Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto said he believed there should be a full investigation into the incident through the Attorney General’s Office, and the state Supreme Court should determine what the next steps would be regarding legal action.

“My opinion is that it is an abuse of office, that it is a personal attack on one individual,” Mr. Peduto said. “And having been on the side of the DA’s attacks over the years, I know what it’s like.”

Pennsylvania State Rep. Ed Gainey, who just beat out Mr. Peduto for the Democratic nomination for Pittsburgh mayor, agreed that Mr. Zappala should apologize and be open to any investigation into the incident to preserve public confidence in the DA’s office.

Advertise with us

"Systemic racism in our criminal justice system is nothing new, but the progress made in recent years to acknowledge and begin the process of reckoning with it are difficult but necessary steps toward a more just future,” Mr. Gainey said. “District Attorney Zappala's decision to retaliate against criminal defendants because their attorney gave voice to the growing consensus about the need for criminal justice reform was a disappointing step backward, and a sign of how much more work remains to be done to deliver on the promise of equal justice for all.”

At the same time, multiple local elected officials said they wanted to see the DA step down or be removed from office.

State Rep. Emily Kinkead, D-North Side, called on Mr. Zappala to resign or be removed immediately. “He just instructed his office to punish the clients of an attorney who criticized the criminal justice system as a whole (not just the DA's office) for being ‘systematically racist,’ ” she wrote Wednesday on Twitter.

Likewise, state Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, said the DA should be “removed immediately,” while Rep. Sara Innamorato called the action “an abuse of power.”

Jerry Dickinson, a constitutional law professor at the University of Pittsburgh and a candidate for Pennsylvania Congressional District 18, called on Mr. Zappala to resign immediately and called his actions “unethical, unlawful and sanctionable.”

Advertise with us

“Beyond ethical and public policy concerns, Mr. Zappala’s actions violate the First Amendment,” he said in a statement. “A policy of ‘no plea offers’ made to a specific lawyer for speaking against systemic racism means the government is treating the lawyer and his clients differently based on the lawyer’s protected speech.”

He continued: “A policy that reprimands Black lawyers (and their clients) for speaking out about racial injustice will cause other lawyers to hesitate to exercise their rights and deter free expression and speech for fear of legal reprisal in violation of free speech.”

Tim Stevens, chairman and CEO of the Black Political Empowerment Project, and William Anderson, chair of the Allegheny County Democratic Black Caucus and who has been represented by Mr. Raiford in the past, echoed the sentiments at a press conference on Thursday evening and also called on Mr. Zappala to resign.

“All one has to do is review the percentage of Blacks sitting in the Allegheny County Jail when compared to the percentage of Black residents who reside in Allegheny County, to consider that there just might be some problems with the justice system of Allegheny County,” Mr. Stevens said. “For the District Attorney to potentially ‘pile on’ to these horrible statistics by not allowing any of Mr. Raiford’s clients to ever qualify for a so called ‘plea deal’ has to be some form of district attorney misconduct.

“His behavior is callous, unethical and prejudicial. It is truly time for another individual to sit in the Office of the District Attorney for Allegheny County.”

Advertise with us

The report has also led to criticism from people within the criminal justice system, with the Allegheny County Bar Association saying Mr. Zappala’s statements effectively negated clients’ right to counsel.

“Should these instructions from District Attorney Zappala be carried out, this would be unethical and retaliatory to criminal defendants based on ideological differences between the District Attorney and their defense counsel,” Elizabeth L. Hughes, president of the bar association, wrote in a statement. “Such a response by the District Attorney only operates to promote unequal treatment in the criminal justice system.

“The purpose of the Office of the District Attorney is to serve the people of this Commonwealth. The ACBA stands against any action that unfairly weighs the scales of justice or deprives any individual of rights guaranteed to all of us under the Constitution.”

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman said he would not take plea agreements following the allegations coming to light, saying he thought it would be more fair to everyone.

“I have the right to accept or reject any plea agreement,” Judge Cashman said. “And in looking at what this new policy is, it is deciding a case not on the merits of the particular fact pattern but rather on who the defendant chose to represent him, and that’s not the way the system should operate.”

Advertise with us

Judge Cashman said he understood why Mr. Zappala would be upset with the “incendiary” allegations, but the penalization was done at the expense of the client having a fair prosecutor and undermined the system.

“There are other Black attorneys who have expressed a similar view as Mr. Raiford, and they’re not being subject to the same sanction,” he said. “So it would appear to me that, with respect to Mr. Raiford’s clients, those clients are not being treated the same way everybody else is. That’s not right.”

According to Bruce Ledewitz, professor of law at Duquesne University, there are two ways Mr. Zappala could be removed from office in this situation. One would involve an impeachment in the state House of Representatives followed by a conviction in the state Senate.

The other method would be if he was removed by the governor “for reasonable cause” following a full hearing and two-thirds vote in the state Senate. That process is less formal and could be quicker than impeachment, Mr. Ledewitz said.

He added that a district attorney should have known that this type of retaliation would be an abuse of power. “Unless the email report is false, I don’t see how Stephen Zappala can remain in office.”

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1869 and on Twitter @MickStinelli. Staff writer Nick Trombola contributed.