In a letter addressed to prosecutors, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. amended his newly created policy to cease plea deals with a Black defense attorney who criticized the DA’s office and the criminal justice system as being “systematically racist.”

Mr. Zappala said his office’s review of plea offers made to “only one attorney and only about racism will not necessarily achieve the goals of consistency in treatment of all defendants or avoiding false claims of discrimination,” according to the letter, which was dated Sunday and released Monday.

The DA’s office will now work to investigate all allegations of discrimination in plea offers, and will seek input for the appropriate offer, he said. The new policy applies to all defense counsel, all defense counsel clients and all protected classes of individuals, DA’s spokesman Mike Manko said.

The controversy stems from an email Mr. Zappala sent to his office on May 18 saying they were not to make plea offers to defense attorney Milton Raiford after he criticized the justice system and the DA’s office as “systematically racist” after a trial.

Advertise with us

The policy amendment invalidates the one previously enacted against Mr. Raiford, according to Mr. Manko. 

________________

Here’s a copy of the letter released to the public on Monday:

________________

The email also said that withdrawing charges against any of Mr. Raiford’s clients would have to be approved by the “front office.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Zappala in his Sunday letter said Mr. Raiford’s allegations were the first time he had heard claims of racism against his office by Mr. Raiford.

“Undoubtedly, you have heard the public reaction to my email that I sent to all Deputy District Attorneys on May 18, 2021,” Mr. Zappala said in the letter. “As I stated in my response to the public’s concerns, I wrote that email in order to ensure that this office makes consistent, evidence based plea offers, and to avoid false claims of racism against this Office and its Assistant District Attorneys.

“The previous email focused on a particular attorney because that attorney’s allegation of systemic racism in this Office was the first that I ever heard of, and the attorney announced his intention to make these claims in every case in which he is counsel, whether in state or federal court.”

Plea offers must be based on evidence and all the surrounding circumstances, the DA’s office said.

Mr. Zappala’s new policy states that if any attorney or unrepresented defendant raises concerns that the plea offer is treating the defendant differently because of the defendant’s protected status, then the DA’s office will obtain all facts for the assertion, including any cases that the attorney or defendant allege are comparable to the defendant’s case.

Advertise with us

The assistant district attorney will then investigate and potentially alert their supervising deputy district attorney for aid in the probe and input on the appropriate plea offer, Mr. Zappala said.

Defense attorney Paul Jubas said he hopes Mr. Zappala takes his new decision further.

“I certainly hope the DA is willing to review claims of racism outside of plea offers,” Mr. Jubas said.

According to Jerry Dickinson, a candidate for a U.S. House seat in District 18 and a constitutional law professor at the University of Pittsburgh, reversing the policy was the “right move” and will help if there is an investigation. But there could still be ramifications for Mr. Zappala and his office despite the updated policy, Mr. Dickinson said.

“Clearly, there's evidence that there was a policy in place that was arguably unethical, unlawful and unconstitutional, so as a result of that, for lawyers, questions of professional conduct or behavior are investigated by the Pennsylvania Disciplinary Board,” Mr. Dickinson said. “I suspect that if someone brought a complaint against Mr. Zappala and the DA's office, the Pennsylvania Disciplinary Board would investigate that and potentially [there would be] public reprimand or some other repercussion or consequence.

Advertise with us

“The question now is: How often has a similar policy been implemented and imposed? We don't know that. We know that Milton Raiford was the targeted lawyer, and his defendants and his clients were affected by that type of policy, but we don't know how many other times this type of policy has been implemented against other lawyers and defendants, and how widespread it is or the breadth and depth of it.”

Mr. Dickinson said it is also unclear whether or not the former policy has been disproportionately imposed on Black lawyers, Black defendants and Black clients. Mr. Raiford spoke out against systemic racism as a Black lawyer, which he “has every right to do,” Mr. Dickinson said Monday.

“The fact that this policy was imposed against him raises some serious questions about whether or not there was a racial element underlying the [original] policy,” Mr. Dickinson said. “Whether or not the policy has been reversed, the actions have compromised and undermined the public trust.

“We elect our public officials because we trust that they will make the right decisions and that they will treat defendants and lawyers equally.”

Lacretia Wimbley: lwimbley@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1510 or on Twitter @​Wimbleyjourno.