Pennsylvania State Police have closed four cold case homicide investigations, including two in Beaver County, after a confession from a notorious convicted serial killer.

Police say Edward Surratt, 79, of Aliquippa, confessed to the crimes after investigators interviewed him in March. Surratt is serving two life sentences at the Raiford Correctional Facility in Raiford, Fla., for crimes he committed in that state.

Surratt’s confession implicated him in the decades-old murders of six people across Pennsylvania in 1977 and 1978. His confession closed the cases of William and Nancy Adams, who were killed in Beaver County in 1977; Joel Krueger, who was killed in Bedford County in 1977; Guy and Laura Mills, who were killed in Fulton County in 1977; and John Shelkons, who was killed in Beaver County in 1978.

According to police, district attorneys in those counties have agreed not to prosecute Surratt for the newly confessed crimes due to his existing life sentences.

Advertise with us

Surratt has also been convicted of murder in South Carolina.

“PSP investigators never stopped seeking justice for the victims of these terrible crimes and their families,” said Lt. Col. Scott Price, deputy commissioner of operations for the Pennsylvania State Police. “We hope that the confessions announced today will help bring some semblance of closure to the victims’ loved ones.”

Investigators began communicating with Surratt about unsolved murders in Pennsylvania in 2018, police said, which eventually led to the confessions.

Surratt, a Marine Corps veteran and former Aliquippa truck driver, was long suspected of committing at least 18 murders in the late 1970s, most of them in Ohio and Pennsylvania.

During the fall and winter of 1977-78, the murders pulled the region into a panic, as they were often conducted by breaking into homes, fatally shooting males and then raping and killing females. The killings stopped, however, after Surratt was arrested in Florida in 1978.

Advertise with us

The confessions announced on Wednesday are not the first cold cases that Surratt has implicated himself in.

In 2007, Surratt admitted to six other murders. Two of the victims, John Feeny and Ranee Gregor, were teenagers at the time of their deaths. Mr. Feeny was found in late October 1977 in Findlay, Allegheny County; Ms. Gregor’s body was never recovered.

The other four victims, Linda and David A. Hamilton and Mary and John J. Davis, were killed in Beaver Township, Mahoning County, Ohio, in 1977.

Surratt allegedly told investigators at the time that the bodies of Ms. Gregor and Ms. Hamilton, who was also never found, were “unrecoverable.”

According to reporting by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette after the 2007 confessions, Surratt allegedly wanted a transfer to a prison in South Carolina for his cooperation, as he had been told that prisons in that state have spring mattresses and air conditioning. It is not immediately clear why Surratt wasn’t transferred.

Advertise with us

State police representatives could not be immediately reached on Wednesday for additional comment.

Nick Trombola: ntrombola@post-gazette.com.