In March, after almost a year of waiting for pandemic restrictions to be lifted, Pennsylvania State Police investigators Max DeLuca and Richard Fennell were finally able to sit down with serial killer Edward Surratt in an empty common area of Marion Correctional Institution in Lowell, Fla., to interview him about six Pennsylvania murders.
They got the confessions, and state police have now closed four cold cases.
“It was nice to be able to clear such old cases because, honestly, the longer they go cold, the longer they stay cold,” said Trooper DeLuca.
The men had met face to face only once before, when Trooper DeLuca first made contact with Surratt in 2018 and interviewed him about a homicide in which Surratt denied involvement. That case is still open and being investigated.
Since then, Trooper DeLuca and Surratt have had an open line of communication through letters. Eventually, Surratt wrote that he’d agree to discuss other open cases within Pennsylvania in which he was a suspect. However, no specific aspects of the cases were discussed.
Over the course of their communication, Surratt alluded to other homicides in the state.
“He only discussed Pennsylvania cases with me, but any that were outside of state police jurisdiction, we forwarded to those police departments,” Trooper DeLuca said.
When they met in the prison’s common room in March, surrounded by empty tables and chairs, Surratt, 79, appeared to be in good mental and physical health. He has been in prison since 1978 with two life sentences, plus an additional 200 years for sexual assault and burglary with a weapon. He also has been convicted of murder in South Carolina.
The six homicides he confessed to were of William and Nancy Adams (31 and 29 respectively), Joel Krueger (36), Guy and Laura Mills (64 and 65 respectively), and John Shelkons (56). All of the victims had been shot. However, although a few of the homicides had similarities, they were all unique in some way.
What unified them and made Surratt the primary suspect was the time frame in which they occurred and the geographical location of the murders. Two cases were in Beaver County, one in Bedford County and one in Fulton County. All were in 1977 and 1978.
The case that Trooper DeLuca originally approached Surratt about, which Surratt denied involvement in, occurred in the same geographic area and in the same time frame.
Trooper DeLuca came to the conclusion that Surratt was truthful in his confession because he was aware of details about the murders that the police had not released to the public.
“He was able to provide certain details on each case that we felt comfortable that only someone who was there or did the crimes would have knowledge of,” Trooper DeLuca said.
Since then, Trooper DeLuca said he has been in communication with family members of some of the victims who seemed thankful to have closure.
“Any time you can bring closure to a case or closure to a family, it is a great feeling, and it is a relief as well to know that you can focus on other cases that need your attention,” Trooper DeLuca said. “And I think it brings closure as well to the old officers who worked on these cases so they know that all of their hard work years ago didn't go to waste.”
Surratt — who admitted to six other murders in 2007 — has been cooperative with the recent investigation and wasn’t boastful, according to Trooper DeLuca. He wants to keep the line of communication open in case Surratt is willing to discuss any other cases in the future.
Trooper DeLuca’s unit works on 40 cases at any given time. About 20-25% of them are around 40 years old or older, according to Trooper DeLuca. Older cases become harder to work because witnesses and the original officers who worked the cases could be deceased.
Sometimes, when all leads have been exhausted and the suspects are deceased, the police have to close a case without solving it so that they can put more resources into other cases. However, for these homicides, the primary suspect, Surratt, was still alive and the cases were kept open, despite being decades old. Trooper DeLuca also noted though that the investigators looked at the cases from all angles and kept an open mind about who the killer might be.
“There are not any cases in state police jurisdiction where [Surratt] is the primary suspect, but that doesn't mean that he is not a person of interest in other Pennsylvania State Police cases,” Trooper DeLuca said.
Boyce Buchanan: bbuchanan@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.