A pill mill doctor who traveled from California four times a year to dole out oxycodone to addicts out of a rented Coraopolis office and squirreled away hundreds of thousands of dollars in drug money as part of a carefully crafted retirement plan is headed to prison for more than 11 years.
U.S. District Judge Mark Hornak on Monday sent Paul Michael Hoover, 60, of Novato, Calif., to prison for 136 months. He also ordered him to pay $406,000 in restitution, most of it to the Social Security Administration.
In addition to dealing drugs and laundering money, Hoover ripped off Social Security by saying he couldn't work from 2012 to 2018 when he could and was working.
Although Hoover and his lawyer objected to a probation office report describing him as a drug dealer, Judge Hornak said that's exactly what he was, prescribing oxycodone to addicts to line his pockets.
He said Hoover was no different than someone dealing narcotics out of the back of a car or under a streetlight.
"You did it in an office while wearing a white coat and a stethoscope," he said. "And I'm not sure the stethoscope was operational."
The judge also said the doctor contributed to the opioid crisis.
"This was like shoveling coal into a furnace," he said of the addicted patients. "And it was all to fuel your greed."
Hoover, a pain specialist for years who had once trained at Allegheny General Hospital, had been charged in 2018 along with his romantic partner, Marcia Ramsier Arthurs, with conspiring to distribute pain pills as well as health care fraud and money-laundering.
Hoover was later charged again with the Social Security fraud. He pleaded guilty.
The case against Ms. Arthurs is pending.
Assistant U.S. attorneys Rachael Mamula and Cindy Chung said Hoover used his medical license and DEA registration to distribute large amounts of oxycodone by writing illegal prescriptions for people who had no medical need for it. The prosecutors said he conspired with Ms. Arthurs to falsely represent that the scripts were legitimate so that Medicare and Medicaid would pay for them at pharmacies.
Four times a year, the pair traveled from California to Pittsburgh to run the pill mill, doling out prescriptions for cash at a rented Coraopolis office to some 60 patients a day. They also mailed prescriptions from California to addicts in Pittsburgh for cash and money orders.
The scheme brought in big money, which Hoover hid in a series of shell corporation accounts, safe deposit boxes, safes and also through the purchase of a $325,000 property in Nevada.
The government sought a sentencing enhancement because of the sophistication of the money-laundering efforts. Hoover's lawyer, Stephen Gorman, objected.
But the government evidence included detailed records Hoover kept, even marking some of them "covert," in which he carefully tracked every step of his plan to hide drug money so he could retire comfortably.
In one set of documents recovered by federal agents, he even boasted that "I am bulletproof" and that "no one can hurt me" in describing his financial shenanigans.
"This looked pretty sophisticated to me," Judge Hornak said in granting the government request for extra jail time.
In addition to all his other frauds, Hoover also claimed falsely that he was disabled in an effort to dodge child support payments from his prior marriage.
Hoover apologized for all that he'd done, saying he was selfish.
"I'm very sorry that I abused my authority as a physician," he said.
He said he suffers from depression and bipolar disorder and that his divorce derailed his life.
"I ended up in a very dark place," he said. "Probably the most blessed day of my life was the day I got arrested."
He said he's found religion in prison, been reunited with an estranged daughter and is on the path to recovery.
He and Mr. Gorman asked for just six years in prison, but the judge said the 136 months was appropriate considering all the deceit in which Hoover engaged for years to run his drug operation.
"In many ways," the judge said, "you could be viewed as a kingpin."
The federal investigation was built partly on recorded office visits by three confidential sources and an undercover agent. Agents also watched the couple travel around as they
deposited cash in area banks.
Hoover is among some 25 medical professionals prosecuted in this district since former Attorney General Jeff Sessions created the Opioid Fraud and Abuse Detection Unit in 2017 to go after bad doctors. That number is the highest of any U.S. attorney's office in the United States.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.