The former office manager and girlfriend of an imprisoned pill mill doctor admitted in federal court that she conspired with him to dole out narcotic painkillers to addicts for cash on regular trips the two made to Pittsburgh from California.
Marcia Arthurs, 62, of Mt. Lebanon, pleaded guilty Friday to conspiracy to distribute oxycodone, conspiracy to commit health care fraud, conspiracy to launder drug money and theft of public money.
Her boyfriend, Paul Michael Hoover of Novato, Calif., who had trained at Allegheny General Hospital and previously practiced in Beaver, is serving more than 11 years in federal prison.
The pair lived together in California and traveled four times a year to Pittsburgh, where they rented out a bare-bones Coraopolis office with no medical equipment.
From there, Hoover wrote illegal prescriptions for up to 60 patients a day who had no need for it. He didn’t examine anyone or do any follow-up checks. Customers paid cash for the prescriptions, usually $200.
Once the couple returned to California, they also mailed prescriptions to addicts in Pittsburgh in exchange for cash or money orders.
Hoover and Arthurs also falsely represented that the prescriptions were legitimate so that Medicare and Medicaid would pay for the pills at area pharmacies.
At previous detention hearings, prosecutors estimated the total pills the pair distributed from 2015 to 2018 was 262,000.
Evidence presented at Hoover’s plea and sentence indicated he considered the pill scheme his retirement plan. He hid his illegal income in a series of shell corporation accounts as well as safe deposit boxes and safes in California. The couple also bought a $325,000 property in Nevada and traveled all over the world.
Part of the evidence against Hoover and Arthurs included notes he kept in which he detailed the money-laundering efforts, including some he actually marked “covert.” He also wrote notes to himself boasting that he was “bulletproof” in avoiding detection.
In addition to dealing pills and defrauding Medicare, the pair also ripped off Social Security by saying Hoover could not work from 2012 to 2018 when he could and was working. Arthurs’ role in that fraud was to lie about her living and financial arrangements with Hoover.
The federal investigation of the couple was based in part on recorded office visits by confidential sources and an undercover agent.
U.S. District Judge Mark Hornak will sentence Arthurs in September.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.