Handyman charged with killing Whitehall woman
When she walks through her Florida home, Linda Valladares passes a picture of her sister, Elizabeth Wiesenfeld, who has been missing for five months.
Each time, she pleads with her.
"I keep saying, 'We're going to find you. Please reveal yourself,' " she said. "I'm just praying he'll tell where she is.
"I ask God, 'Please, let the devil tell where she is so we can have a funeral and say goodbye in the proper way.' "
On Thursday, Ms. Valladares learned that Douglas Berry -- “the devil” -- was arrested and charged with homicide in her sister’s death, even though Ms. Wiesenfeld’s body still has not been found.
Police have built what appears to be a strong circumstantial case against Berry, including evidence that shows him withdrawing cash at an ATM using Ms. Wiesenfeld’s debit card 13 hours after her disappearance in April. That same card — in pieces and melted — was later found by detectives inside a Miller Lite beer can in the trash at Berry’s home in Liberty.
Read More
Both the card and can had Berry’s fingerprints on them, according to the criminal complaint.
"She's a good person. She was living her best life," Ms. Valladares said. "Everybody's just devastated this could happen to somebody.
Why? For $500 from an ATM?”
In addition, to homicide, Berry, 48, is also charged with burglary, access device fraud, receiving stolen property and two counts of theft. He has been held in the Allegheny County Jail since May 2 on an unrelated gun charge.
The homicide case against Berry is the first to be prosecuted in Allegheny County without a body since 2007.
Even if Ms. Wiesenfeld is not found, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said at a news conference Thursday that he believes the case against Berry is solid.
"It’s because of the amount of evidence,” he said, adding later, “When you have hundreds of pieces of evidence, that's a different story."
Mr. Zappala said investigators delayed filing the homicide case against Berry, a longtime suspect, in hopes of recovering Ms. Wiesenfeld’s body first.
"There has been an extensive effort that’s been coordinated through county police to try to find Betsy," the district attorney said, noting investigators have searched wooded areas throughout Liberty as well as Latrobe, where Berry had been working.
"The chances we are going to find her at this point are not good,” Mr. Zappala said.
Still, detectives are hopeful that as fall comes, and trees lose their leaves, Ms. Wiesenfeld’s body may be revealed.
____________________
Video: Police said that Douglas Berry stopped at a CoGo’s convenience store on East Carson Street at 11:06 a.m. on April 30. While he was there, police believe he had Elizabeth Wiesenfeld’s cellphone, pretended to be her and texted her daughter: "I met someone were leaving now for about a week look after everything at the house please I'm going to have a good time for once."
Cogo's surveillance video
____________________
According to the 14-page affidavit of probable cause filed in the case, Ms. Wiesenfeld’s daughter, Kathleen Graham, of Bethel Park, knew almost immediately the morning of April 30 that something was wrong.
Her mom followed the same routine she always did. She had a cup of tea at her dining room table, read the Bible and wrote in her journal.
At 8:18 a.m., Ms. Wiesenfeld texted “good morning” to her daughter.. Ms. Graham responded at 9:07 a.m.
Two hours later, she received a text from her mom’s cell number: "I met someone were [sic] leaving now for about a week look after everything at the house please I'm going to have a good time for once."
Allegheny County detectives now believe that message was sent by Berry after he killed Ms. Wiesenfeld and while he sat in a Cogo’s parking lot in the 900 block of East Carson Street on the South Side. A Pittsburgh public works employee found Ms. Wiesenfeld's cell phone on May 2 several blocks away on East Carson at South Fifth Street.
When Ms. Graham received that text, she immediately became suspicious, according to the criminal complaint, because her mother had not mentioned anything like that when they spoke the night before.
After two phone calls and a text message to her mom went unanswered, Ms. Graham called Ms. Wiesenfeld’s work, Sarah Care, an adult day care in Forest Hills where she was a nurse, the complaint said. She learned that her mom hadn’t shown up that morning.
Shortly after noon, Ms. Graham called the Whitehall police and met them at her mom’s house. When they arrived, Ms. Graham noticed that the doors were not locked the way her mother would have left them, the complaint said, and her dog was running loose in the house, which she never allowed if she was out.
Inside, they found the area rug in Ms. Wiesenfeld’s bedroom askew and her closet door open. The woman’s purple glasses were behind the door, her bed was disturbed with red/brown staining in three places, and there were cigarette ashes next to it, even though she did not smoke.
Ms. Wiesenfeld’s wallet and purse were missing.
According to the complaint, video surveillance taken from a neighbor’s security system showed a dark pickup truck matching Berry’s Ford F-150 on her street at 8:39 a.m. that morning. The truck pulled into her driveway just prior to Ms. Wiesenfeld’s front door being opened at 8:40 a.m., which was recorded by her home security system.
Barlind Drive surveillance video
Her garage door then opened at 8:55 a.m., the complaint said.
The neighbor’s security video shows a “single figure in dark clothing rapidly walking towards the truck at 8:56:58 a.m.,” the complaint said. “The individual depicted is walking along the driveway that accesses Wiesenfeld’s integral garage and appears to have come from the rear of the residence.”
At 8:57 a.m., the truck then moves toward the rear of the home, and leaves two minutes later.
According to the criminal complaint, detectives were able to track Berry’s movements throughout the rest of that day and the next using license plate readers all over the South Hills, cell phone towers, additional video surveillance and store receipts.
According to the affidavit of probable cause, at 9:26 p.m. on April 30, video surveillance shows a man wearing a hood and a coat with distinctive marks on it using Ms. Wiesenfeld’s debit card to withdraw $500 at a PNC Bank ATM on Brownsville Road in Brentwood.
During a later search of Berry’s property, investigators found that card inside a Miller Lite beer can in the trash — in pieces and melted, with just a few remaining letters on the front spelling “L-I-Z-A-B” and “E-N-F”, but her partial signature visible on the back. Berry’s left thumb print was on the beer can, investigators said. Police also said a print from Berry’s right index finger was on the beer can.
Additional information from inmates at the Allegheny County Jail, who are unnamed, is also contained in the complaint.
He told one inmate that he “had taken the victim’s card and destroyed it by burning it down to his fingertips. Once it was burned down, Berry put it inside a beer can and swished it around,” the complaint said. “Berry was worried that a fingerprint would be found on the beer can, with Berry adding that he should not have thrown it in the garbage.”
He told the same inmate that he wasn’t worried about the ATM surveillance video “because the person in the video didn’t have glasses on and Berry was going to get his doctor to say Berry couldn’t do an ATM transaction without his glasses,” the complaint said.
Berry also told that inmate that he needed to get out of jail to move a body, the complaint said. And later, when referencing court paperwork, including a search warrant for Berry’s DNA, Berry told the inmate that investigators wouldn’t find his DNA because he bagged the victim’s body “in numerous layers” before he left the house, according to the complaint. He then made a strangling motion with his hands, the inmate told police.
Berry told the same inmate that the body was "a half an hour away," and that she "had it coming," the complaint said.
A different inmate who was Berry’s cellmate told police that Berry said he had a case of sulfuric acid in his truck and that it was easy to get rid of a body with that and a Rubbermaid container, the complaint said.
“Berry told Witness No. 4 that her body would not be found,” the complaint said.
During the investigation, police found four bottles of industrial strength drain cleaner — which is 93% sulfuric acid — in Berry’s vehicle, according to the complaint. Investigators were able to track the sale of the drain cleaner to a Lowe’s in Latrobe the day after Ms. Wiesenfeld went missing. Video surveillance shows Berry, wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and plaid shorts, paying cash, the complaint said.
Susan Gasser, a neighbor of Berry's in Liberty, said she saw a fire on his property around the time Ms. Wiesenfeld went missing.
"I'm just glad he's not coming back. We were worried," she said Thursday. "We knew he had to be doing something — now we know what.
"Too many fires, too many nights in a row."
Even before she went missing, Ms. Wiesenfeld had expressed concerns about her former handyman who’d done some work on her house but then continued to show up unannounced and unwelcome after the work was done, according to search warrants filed in the case.
Ms. Valladares said her sister loved her job. She had a dog, Ruby, who she walked often, was active in her church and in Bible study.
Ms. Wiesenfeld also cared for their mother, who died in December.
Her sister "always wanted to do the right thing" and lived for her daughter, Ms. Valladares said.
The night of April 29, Ms. Wiesenfeld exchanged text messages with her niece in Texas, Ms. Valladares said.
In one, she wrote, "I am so grateful for all the blessings in my life."
Ms. Valladares can’t fathom her sister simply having a cup of tea to start her day and then being attacked in her own home.
“Evil comes upon you, and that's the end of her life,” she said.
"She would have forgiven the devil. I can't."

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard. Staff writer Shelly Bradbury contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.