Early last week, Susan Gasser noticed her neighbor was burning something in the middle of the night.

She didn’t think that much of it at the time — her neighbor lived in the last house on their bumpy, privately owned dead end road in Liberty, next to an abandoned home and surrounded by forest.

But then on Monday, news broke that the neighbor, 47-year-old Douglas Berry, was the prime suspect in the disappearance of a missing Whitehall woman who was last heard from on April 29.

“It’s scary now,” Ms. Gasser said Tuesday.

Advertise with us

She wondered aloud if somehow the fire was linked to the missing woman, Elizabeth Wiesenfeld. “It was a big glow.”

Berry has not been charged in connection with Ms. Wiesenfeld’s disappearance, but was jailed Thursday on an unrelated gun charge after Allegheny County police searched his house and truck in connection to the investigation into Ms. Wiesenfeld’s whereabouts. Berry, a felon, is not legally allowed to have a firearm, but police said they found a handgun in his bedroom.

Berry was denied bond, according to court records, because he is the “prime suspect” in Ms. Wiesenfeld’s disappearance.

Berry is scheduled to appear Wednesday for a bond modification hearing in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, where a judge will determine whether there are conditions under which he could be released from custody.

Nobody answered the door Tuesday at Berry’s home off Washington Boulevard, where he lives with a woman and the woman’s daughter, according to a criminal complaint.

Advertise with us

Other neighbors who witnessed the fire early last week reported it to authorities, Ms. Gasser said. Allegheny County police on Tuesday confirmed they’d received that report and declined to comment further.

Ms. Gasser said she tried to keep her distance from Berry after she learned he had a criminal history, but that he was a smooth-talking, apparently nice man.

“He should have been a salesman,” she said.

Berry’s criminal history in Pennsylvania dates back to 1990, when he pleaded guilty to driving under the influence, according to court records. He was charged with burglary in 1991 and took a plea deal. He pleaded guilty to drug charges in 1994, simple assault in 1995, making terroristic threats and aggravated assault in 1996, and robbery and forgery in 2002. Most recently, he was arrested in October and charged with trespassing; that case is ongoing, according to court records.

Berry’s faced criminal charges in Montgomery, Chester, Berks, Beaver and Westmoreland counties over the years, according to the records.

Advertise with us

He had been hired by Ms. Wiesenfeld, 67, to do some work on her properties, a family member who asked not to be named said Monday. Ms. Wiesenfeld lives on East Barlind Street in Whitehall, a quiet road lined with brick houses and large green lawns.

Ms. Wiesenfeld’s neighbors often saw her walking her dog or working on her lawn, they said Tuesday. She seemed to have a variety of workers in and out of her house regularly, they said. Neighbor Kathy Corrado, 80, who lives a couple of doors down from Ms. Wiesenfeld, said detectives interviewed her after Ms. Wiesenfeld went missing.

“They asked if I heard any screams, if I saw anything, which I didn’t,” she said.

Ms. Wiesenfeld’s daughter reported her missing on April 30 after she failed to show up for work, according to a criminal complaint. Whitehall police found blood in her bed and discovered that a masked person used her debit card after she was last in contact with her family, according to the complaint.

“It makes you sick to your stomach to know that someone could do that,” Ms. Corrado said. “I hope they find her and it’s a good outcome, although the detective said it wouldn’t be.”

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.