Cigarette butts, apparent blood stains, an unusual text message, an ATM withdrawal, video footage and Elizabeth Wiesenfeld’s spoken fear before she disappeared led Allegheny County police to suspect Douglas Berry in her disappearance, according to search warrants obtained by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Ms. Wiesenfeld, 67, of Whitehall, who has been missing since April 29, started every morning the same way: She woke up, made tea, read her Bible and wrote in a journal, then put on her makeup and left for work around 9 a.m. She was very tidy, her daughter told police, and she always put everything away before she left for work.

But when police searched Ms. Wiesenfeld’s house on the morning of April 30 — hours after Ms. Wiesenfeld was last heard from — it wasn’t tidy at all, according to the search warrants.

A rug was askew, a closet door ajar, the dog loose, the makeup bag out. There were cigarette ashes beside the bed even though Ms. Wiesenfeld didn’t smoke, according to the warrants.

Advertise with us

An alarm system for the home on East Barlind Street showed the front door had been opened at 8:40 a.m. and closed at 8:43 a.m. The garage door had been opened at 8:55 a.m. and closed at 8:58 a.m. — but Ms. Wiesenfeld’s vehicle never left.

And then, at 11:11 a.m. that morning, a text was sent from Ms. Wiesenfeld’s phone to her daughter.

“I met someone were [sic] leaving now for about a week look after everything at the house please I’m going to have a good time for once.”

That didn’t sound at all like Ms. Wiesenfeld, her daughter told officers. And when she tried to call her mom, the phone rang and rang. On the next call, it went straight to voicemail.

All of Ms. Wiesenfeld’s suitcases were in her home, according to the search warrants. Her glasses were found behind a door, her prescription medications on the nightstand. Her wallet, phone and purse were missing.

Advertise with us

Before she disappeared, Ms. Wiesenfeld told her family she was afraid of a man who had been doing work on her house. She’d stopped hiring him to do jobs, she told them, but he showed up unannounced at her house in October anyway. That day, she’d ignored him until he left, according to the warrants.

Investigators believe that man to be Berry and they think he posed as Ms. Wiesenfeld and sent the mid-morning text to Ms. Wiesenfeld’s daughter. A convicted felon, Berry, 47, of Liberty, was arrested May 2 and is being held in the Allegheny County Jail on an unrelated gun charge. He has not been charged in connection to Ms. Wiesenfeld’s disappearance.

The morning she went missing, Berry’s truck, a 2015 Ford, was seen several times near Ms. Wiesenfeld’s house, according to the warrants. Investigators tracked Ms. Wiesenfeld’s cell phone and discovered that it was in the same areas as Berry’s truck between 9 a.m. until shortly after 11 a.m., according to the warrants.

Her phone was turned off at 9:21 a.m. near Dead Man’s Hollow, a conservation area south of McKeesport, then turned on again at 11:08 a.m. on Pittsburgh’s South Side. It was turned off again two minutes after the text to Ms. Wiesenfeld’s daughter, according to the warrants.

Five minutes after the text that was sent from the South Side, a license plate reader picked up Berry’s truck at the intersection of Carson Street and the Smithfield Street Bridge.

Advertise with us

Around 9:30 p.m. on the night of April 30, the day Ms. Wiesenfeld disappeared, someone in a blue sweatshirt with a distinctive white paint stain used Ms. Wiesenfeld’s ATM card to withdraw $500 at an ATM on Brownsville Road in Brentwood. The person was wearing what appeared to be a mask, according to the warrants.

A Ford Expedition registered to Berry’s wife was spotted by a license plate reader in that area at the same time, according to the warrants. And when officers searched Berry’s house on May 1, they found a blue sweatshirt with a white paint stain hanging on a hook by the door.

Investigators found what appeared to be bloodstains in Berry’s truck, as well as what appeared to be a bloody rag. They discovered a pack of cigarettes that matched the brand of cigarette butts the investigators collected in the driveway of Ms. Wiesenfeld’s house.

They also seized a gun, boots and counterfeit currency, according to the search warrants. They swabbed Berry’s mouth for DNA. And they said they found a ski mask in his truck.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter. Paula Reed Ward: 412-263-2620, pward@post-gazette.com.