Pittsburgh police arrested a Rankin man Thursday in connection with a middle-of-the-night sex assault in Oakland last month that led to a violent, frenzied struggle between the victim and her attacker.
The woman, a University of Pittsburgh student, said she choked and bit Robert Mitchell as he assaulted her in her bed, finally managing to escape when she got free from his grasp, according to a criminal complaint.
Detectives used DNA evidence, the defendant’s distinctive walk and surveillance video footage to identify Mr. Mitchell, 30, as the suspect, the complaint said.
Mr. Mitchell, who was wanted on a warrant for violating probation in a theft case, was picked up Thursday by the Allegheny County Sheriff’s Office.
He faces multiple new charges including attempted rape, attempted sexual assault, aggravated indecent assault and burglary.
Police said Mr. Mitchell entered the student's off-campus residence on Oakland Avenue around 4 a.m. on July 5 and sexually assaulted her.
The woman told police Mr. Mitchell got into her apartment through a back door she forgot to lock, the criminal complaint said.
He woke her when he got in her bed with his pants down and a black T-shirt on his head, partially concealing his face, the complaint said.
The woman fought him off, bit his right hand and choked him, according to police.
She yelled for help as he "grabbed her arms" and "held her down" on the bed, the complaint said. As they struggled, Mr. Mitchell tried to rape the woman, the complaint said.
At one point, the woman told police, she pulled the shirt that covered his face down to his neck and tried to choke Mr. Mitchell. When it seemed he couldn't breathe, she tried to pull him toward the kitchen by his shirt in an attempt to get a knife, the complaint said.
Mr. Mitchell grabbed the woman’s neck and attempted to choke her before she freed herself and escaped out the back door.
She then activated an emergency notification system, summoning police.
Officials said Mr. Mitchell also ran out the back door, but went to the front of the residence and made a left on Oakland Avenue.
The woman surmised that Mr. Mitchell might have been familiar with the apartment because the back door, which she believes he used to get in, is not easily seen, the complaint said. A roommate who also lives at the residence was not home at the time of the incident.
Video cameras in the neighborhood contained footage of a man matching the victim’s description of her attacker, right down to his ankle-high boots, camouflage shorts and black shirt. The man was captured on video around the time of the assault walking in an “elusive” way and in a distinctive, hunched manner.
A Pitt police officer watching the video was reminded of Mr. Mitchell; he had arrested the man before and knew him to have the same body type, hair style, full-arm tattoo and hunched walk as the suspect, the complaint said.
Detectives learned Mr. Mitchell was on probation, and they secured footage from the Allegheny County probation office showing Mr. Mitchell checking in July 2. Police said he wore ankle-high boots during that visit, and a Facebook photo they found had him wearing camouflage shorts that appeared to match the suspect’s, according to the complaint.
Mr. Mitchell had made all the check-ins with his probation officer — until July 8, the day after police released surveillance video.
Investigators then got another piece of evidence: DNA. A blood stain on the victim’s shirt — left, police believe, when she bit her attacker’s hand — was run through a database and generated a match. Police said the genetic material matched that collected from an open arson investigation from 2010. “Robert Mitchell was documented in the 2010 report as the person whom the victim believed burned down his house,” the complaint said.
On Thursday, Mr. Mitchell was picked up for probation violations and taken to Pittsburgh police headquarters.
There, police said, Mr. Mitchell gave varying accounts of the July 5 incident.
In one account, he told police he met the woman on the street and was invited over for sex when he was attacked by two unknown men. In another account, he stated he was sitting on her front porch charging his phone when two unknown men and an unknown woman assaulted him and dragged him into the house.
During the interview with Mr. Mitchell, the complaint said, a detective spotted something suspicious: a healing wound on the suspect’s hand.
Lacretia Wimbley: 412-263-1510, lwimbley@post-gazette.com or follow @Wimbleyjourno on Twitter. Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.